What is the reason that accessing array elements with negative indices is significantly slower compared to accessing elements with

Let's explore a JavaScript performance test:

const iterations = new Array(10 ** 7);

var x = 0;
var i = iterations.length + 1;
console.time('negative');
while (--i) {
x += iterations[-i];
}
console.timeEnd('negative');

var y = 0;
var j = iterations.length;
console.time('positive');
while (j--) {
y += iterations[j];
}
console.timeEnd('positive');

The initial loop goes from 10,000,000 to 1 and accesses an array of that size using negative indexes. This loops through the array in sequential order.

Contrastingly, the second loop counts down from 9,999,999 to 0 while accessing the same array with positive indexes, essentially going through the array reverse order.

In my experience, the first loop takes more than 6 seconds to finish, whereas the second one completes in just around ~400ms.

What could be causing this speed discrepancy between the two loops?

Answer №1

When iterations[-1] is evaluated, it results in undefined, which can be slow due to having to traverse the entire prototype chain. Additionally, performing mathematical operations with NaN will always be sluggish since it is an uncommon case.

It is also beneficial to initialize iterations with numbers to increase the usefulness of the test.

For optimal performance testing, make sure that the compared codes lead to the same operation in the end...


Here are some general thoughts on performance tests:

In today's computing environment, optimizing code is primarily the compiler's responsibility. Code optimized by the compiler will generally outperform attempts at manual optimization through "tricks." It is best to write code that the compiler can easily optimize- typically resembling what most developers would produce. By focusing on writing code that is easy for engines to optimize, such as:

 let acc = 0;
 for(const value of array) acc += value;

 // or
 const acc = array.reduce((a, b) => a + b, 0);

Remember, at its core, it is just a loop. Attention should be directed towards ensuring the overall algorithm performs efficiently (with a time complexity of O(n²) or better), rather than solely fixating on optimizing loops.

Answer №2

Expanding on the explanation provided by Jonas Wilms, it's important to note that Javascript does not support negative indices like some other programming languages such as Python.

In JavaScript, using iterations[-1] is equivalent to trying to access iteration["-1"], which attempts to find a property named "-1" within the array object. This explains why iterations[-1] will result in being undefined.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

String variable representing the name of a React element

As I was reviewing the source code of a React UI library, I stumbled upon an interesting code pattern that I will simplify here: function Test() { let Button = "button"; // ... return <Button>Click me</Button>; } I'm curious about ...

The console log is displaying 'undefined' when trying to access Node.js fs

Recently, I was engrossed in developing a Next.js blog. After completing the frontend, I shifted my focus to building the backend using Next.js. ./pages/api I created a new file: ./pages/api/blogs.js To test my backend functionalities, I generated some J ...

How come my web page is not displaying the guages from guage.js?

I am utilizing guage.js to create a graph based on this Fiddle. However, upon adding the same code to my website, the rendering does not appear as expected: https://i.sstatic.net/fIkQr.png Upon inspecting in Chrome developer tools, I noticed that the ele ...

Error: Cannot execute 'x' as a function

I am currently developing an Express web application that initiates JavaScript scraping code upon the page's initial load. Below is the node web scraping code (scrape.js): const request = require('request-promise'); const cheerio = require( ...

Scroll a div using JavaScript/jQuery

I'm currently facing some challenges in resolving this issue. My goal is to pan a DIV using jQuery. The process is quite straightforward - on mouseDown, I capture X & Y coordinates and then subtract them from the newly obtained X & Y values during mou ...

serving files using express.static

I have set up express.static to serve multiple static files: app.use("/assets", express.static(process.cwd() + "/build/assets")); Most of the time, it works as expected. However, in certain cases (especially when downloading many files at once), some fil ...

What is the maximum file size that the data link is able to store?

For instance, a file like an image, video, or sound can be saved in the data link Take an image for example, it may be stored with the initial link: ..... followed by various characters. But, is there a specified size limit at whic ...

Top approach for triggering and re-triggering AJAX using php

I'm in the process of deciphering instructions from my developer. Our approach may not be entirely correct, so I want to ensure that we are on the right track. This is our objective: On a webpage, there exists a button. When this button is clicked, I ...

Understanding how to extract inner text and splitting it can be a challenging task for developers when working with Javascript

Exploring the following basic html code: <div id="content"> This is a test </div> I am puzzled as to why this works: $(function(){ text = 'this is a text'; word = text.split(' '); alert(word[1]) }) while this does not: ...

The placement of the FirebaseAuth.onAuthStateChanged call in an Angular application is a common concern for developers

Where is the best place to add a global listener initialization call in an Angular app? Take a look at this code snippet: export class AuthService { constructor( private store: Store<fromAuth.State>, private afAuth: AngularFireAuth ) { ...

Unable to carry out specific tasks in a particular order with GULP

I'm having trouble getting the TASK cssmin to execute after scss. It works fine when the folder destination is not empty and .css files are already compiled with the 'scss' task, but if the folder is empty, the cssmin task doesn't creat ...

Error when parsing JSON due to the presence of backslashes within the serialized object

When trying to call a server side function and parse the response in client side using JavaScript and Ajax, I encountered a parse error. It seems that the issue lies with the backslash that the JavaScriptSerializer adds to serialize the object. The respons ...

Two unnamed objects cannot be combined using the AsyncPipe

Currently, I am looking to implement an autocomplete feature using Angular Material in Angular 8. Below is a snippet of the code used in the TypeScript file: @Input() admins: User[]; userGroupOptions: Observable<User[]>; filterFormFG: FormGrou ...

Optimizing my AngularJS bundle is pushing me towards upgrading to Angular 5

Regarding my AngularJS application, it was initially created using 'yo angular-fullstack' with JS scripting instead of TS. It is functional but experiencing performance and user experience issues. The deployment is on AWS ElasticBeanstalk nano i ...

"Step-by-step guide on showcasing a specific blog post using its unique identifier in an Angular/Express/MongoDB application

I'm struggling to figure out how to retrieve a single blog post by its ID, especially since I am new to this. Currently, my main blog application has an ng-repeat functionality that fetches all posts. What I really want is the ability to click on a p ...

Guide on utilizing the disable feature in SortableJS for a Vue project

I have successfully implemented the draggable effect on my el table using element-ui-el-table-draggable and it's working perfectly. Now, I am looking to incorporate the disable option from SortableJS, but I'm unsure how to integrate these two fu ...

Utilize a Chrome extension to emphasize text within a contenteditable element by underlining it

I am in the process of developing a Chrome extension that highlights specific words when a user types them. For example, if a user inputs "hello," I want to highlight or underline it. The challenge arises when dealing with content editable divs in platform ...

What is the best way to encode an image into JSON format?

let canvas = document.createElement('canvas'); let context = canvas.getContext( '2d' ); context.drawImage( video, 0, 0 ); let image_src = canvas.toDataURL('image/jpeg'); let dataURL = canvas.toDataURL("image/jpeg"); let image= ...

JavaScript tabs function malfunctioning upon page load

I attempted to implement tabs on my website using this example: http://www.w3schools.com/howto/howto_js_tabs.asp Although everything is functioning correctly, the default tab isn't opening as expected. The tab opens, but the header color does not get ...

Is it possible for my OAuth2 callback page to share the same HTML page? Also, what is the process for obtaining the token?

In my setup, I am working with static html and javascript along with C# Web API. One of the scenarios I encountered involves a link that triggers an oauth2 server from my HTML file named index.html. The question arises: Is it appropriate to establish the c ...