What are the risks of altering a Vue prop from the child component?

While Vue does allow for props mutation, it is generally not recommended. According to the documentation found at https://vuejs.org/guide/components/props.html#one-way-data-flow, it is advised to avoid mutating nested props unless there is a tight coupling between the parent and child components.

Although this approach may seem acceptable, various forum posts strongly advise against it due to potential issues such as data corruption upon re-rendering of the parent component (Vue 2 - Mutating props vue-warn).

Personally, I prefer to follow the recommendations rather than engaging in debates regarding this practice. However, the team I am part of heavily relies on prop mutation.

While it currently works for us, I have concerns about potential problems that may arise in the future. Are there any risks of Vue prohibiting prop mutation in upcoming versions or making subtle changes that are only compatible with one-way data flow?

I am curious how others handle situations where deep object changes are necessary. Implementing these changes using emits requires numerous adjustments across all components in between.

Additionally, I am interested to know how common the practice of prop mutation is among developers. Is anyone else following the same approach?

javascriptvue.jsmutationprop

Answer №1

When it comes to mutations, there are two main types - mutating a primitive value (such as String, Number, Boolean) and mutating an Object.

Modifying a primitive value within a child component will revert back to the original value provided by the parent when the child is re-rendered.
The level of risk involved in this situation depends on your specific use case - Vue can only caution you with a message like "Hey, make sure you know what you're doing". It's possible that in future Vue versions, this warning could potentially be upgraded to an error, although even the developers themselves cannot confirm if or when this change might occur.

On the other hand, altering an Object means directly modifying its properties. Since Objects are accessed by reference rather than value, any changes made in the child component will persist and impact the parent component (possibly causing unintended side effects). Ultimately, the decision on whether to mutate directly or communicate with the parent through event emissions depends on your individual scenario - at times, immediate mutation might be more practical, especially for deeply nested data within the Object.

The primary concern here is to stay vigilant and monitor your application (and browser console) to catch instances where Vue warnings transition into errors.
Ideally, it would be beneficial to encourage your team members to refactor the code in order to minimize these mutations as much as possible (although eliminating all mutations entirely may not always be feasible).

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Saving an edited polygon path in Vue using Google Maps

In my Vue component named BaseMap, there is a nested component called Location. The Location component features an editable Polygon marker. // BaseMap <GmapMap> <Location :location="location" /> </GmapMap> // Location <gmap-marker ...

google-mapsvue.jsvue-componentpolygon

In Reactjs, you can prevent users from selecting future dates and times by modifying the KeyboardDateTimePicker component

I am currently using the Material UI KeyboardDateTimePicker component and have successfully disabled future dates with the disabledFuture parameter. However, I am now looking for a way to disable future times as well. Any suggestions or solutions would b ...

javascriptreactjsdatepickermaterial-ui

Is there a way to access the value of a variable in Express that is stored in a different file?

Looking for a way to fetch the value of a variable that is located inside app.use? chatbot.js: const express = require('express'); const app = express.Router(); app.use(['/chat', '/chatbot'], (req, res, next) => { const ...

javascriptnode.jsexpressfile-handling

Generate text in a random spot effortlessly

After doing some research on various development platforms, I stumbled upon this JSFiddle that seems to have a solution for my requirements. The only thing missing is the ability to input a specific word (without user input) and automate the process at fix ...

javascripttext

Checking for palindromes should also result in a negative outcome

function checkPalindrome(input) { let cleanInput = input.replace(/[\.,-\/#!$%\^&\*;:{}=\-_`~ ()]/g,"").toLowerCase(); let reversedInput = cleanInput.split('').reverse().join(''); if(cleanI ...

javascriptpalindrome

What methods can I use to ensure that a user's credentials are not shown in the URL?

My NextJS application sometimes behaves unexpectedly. Whenever I have a slow connection and the initial load time of the site is longer than usual, after trying to log in to the application, the credentials I entered are displayed in the URL. This happens ...

javascriptperformanceauthenticationsecuritynext.js

Is there a way to use XMLhttprequest to send a post request to my personal Node server using vanilla javascript?

I have encountered an issue while trying to send data to Node using XMLhttprequest. The data I am attempting to send looks like this (/q/zmw:95632.1.99999.json). My connection to Node is set up correctly, but I was receiving an empty object. So, I decided ...

javascriptjsonajaxnode.js

Looking to extract a particular set of information from past records in a GAS web application

Regarding a previous query I made before (Check for login username and password, and then bring data from every previous entry). I've developed a web application to monitor the working hours of employees at my organization. The app is straightforward ...

javascripthtmlgoogle-apps-scriptgoogle-sheets

Obtaining the latest state within the existing handler

In my React application, I have a handler that shuffles the state entry data: state = { data:[1,2,3,4,5] }; public handleShuffle = () => { const current = this.state.data; const shuffled = current .map((a: any) => [Math.random() ...

javascriptreactjs

Vue: updating the :root CSS variable for a child component leads to an error - TypeError: Unable to access properties of undefined (reading 'style')

Fiddle: https://codesandbox.io/s/hardcore-mestorf-w1lsob?file=/src/App.vue In my project, I have created two simple files that are responsible for displaying a circle on the screen: https://i.stack.imgur.com/0ddI3.png The goal is to modify the circular ...

vue.jsvuejs3

Limit the user's ability to choose just one radio button from each of two groups that have identical values

Currently, I am developing a web application that involves creating a virtual team. Users are able to choose players and then assign a "Captain" and a "Vice-Captain" for the team. To facilitate this, I have implemented two radio button groups where users c ...

javascriptjquerylaravelbootstrap-4radio-button

Comparison between Filament Group's loadCSS and AJAX technologies

The loadCSS library developed by Filament Group is widely recognized as the standard for asynchronously loading CSS. Even Google recommends its use. However, instead of using this library, some suggest utilizing ajax to achieve the same result. For example ...

javascriptcssajaxperformance

Vue.js navigation guards, restrict access to all unauthorized routes, grant entry to specific routes upon successful authentication

I'm currently working on implementing a navigation guard in Vue.js with a specific logic: I want to restrict access to all routes that require authentication and redirect users to the login page if they are not authenticated. The only exception is the ...

javascriptspringvue.jsvuexvue-router

Sending data from PHP to a text file upon clicking a button

I have been struggling with AJAX and despite my efforts to research on Stack Overflow and other online resources, I still can't get it to work. Any help would be greatly appreciated. My issue involves a formatted JSON file that I am able to parse usi ...

javascriptphpjqueryajax

Is it possible to use a shell script to replace the external CSS file link in an HTML file with the actual content of the CSS file

Seeking a solution for replacing external CSS and JS file links in an HTML document with the actual content of these files. The current structure of the HTML file is as follows: <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C ...

javascripthtmlcssawksed

Cannot render <Image> inside <Section> component

As a beginner in React, I am attempting to create an app following a tutorial. In my component, I utilized the figure tag but it's not showing up when inspecting element in Chrome. Here are the code snippets: The tutorial includes a div tag as a chil ...

javascripthtmlcssreactjs

Encountering the error "Cannot read property 'header' of undefined" while conducting tests on Nodejs using supertest

In my server.js file, I have set up my express app. I tried to run a demo test in my test file using express, but unfortunately, the test did not run successfully. const request = require('supertest'); const express = require('express' ...

javascriptnode.jsexpresssupertest

When trying to implement a dark/light theme, CSS variables may not function properly on the body tag

Currently, I am in the process of developing two themes (light and dark) for my React website. I have defined color variables for each theme in the main CSS file as shown below: #light{ --color-bg: #4e4f50; --color-bg-variant: #746c70; --color-primary: #e2 ...

javascripthtmlcssreactjs

JavaScript: Changing the names of all object keys

As a beginner, I am struggling to rename some objects in my key using a map function. Below is my current array: "platforms": [ { "id": 6, "name": "PC (Microsoft Windows)" }, { "id": 11, "na ...

javascriptarraysreactjsdatabase

Developing Attributes in JSON

Greetings stackOverflow Community, I'm struggling a bit with creating JSON objects. I have code snippet that is meant to populate a list called members with names, and then add a property to each of those names. Here is the specific snippet in questi ...

javascriptjsonnode.js