I am looking to find all possible combinations of a string while keeping the correct order intact and avoiding duplicates. The goal is to create more flexible solutions for Japanese quizzes by allowing a mix of kana and kanji characters. To achieve this, I need to generate all possible combinations for comparison with the user's input.
Here is the current syntax of the function: (located here)
Genki.getAlts('{月曜日}と{水曜日}と{金曜日}に{日本語}のクラスがあります', 'げつようび|すいようび|きんようび|にほんご');
The text within curly braces will be replaced by alternative text in the second argument, referred to as replacements. However, each alternate text should only replace the corresponding index. For example:
- 月曜日 can only be replaced with げつようび
- 水曜日 can only be replaced with すいようび
- and so on...
For instance, if we have the following:
Genki.getAlts('...{A}...{B}...', '1|2', true);
I want it to produce various combinations, such as:
'...1...{B}...'
'...1...2...'
'...{A}...2...'
'...{A}...{B}...'
The current function works effectively with 2-7 replacements, but when handling more than 8 replacements, some combinations are missed. The total number of combinations can be calculated using the formula: Math.pow(2, 8)
, yielding "256" combinations for 8 replacements, yet the getAlts() function currently returns only 234 combos, resulting in a coverage of 91%.
This is where I am facing challenges. I created the code independently, trying my best to include as many combinations as possible, but I believe there might be a simpler approach that I am missing due to my limited math skills.
- Code: Genki.getAlts()
- Test page: lesson-4/workbook-6 || page source (the console will display all current combinations)
To illustrate a case where the algorithm falls short, open your console and you may encounter a warning related to the last problem:
234/256 (91.40625% combo coverage for 8 replacements; 22 missing combos
Problematic code snippet:
Genki.getAlts('{1:私}はきのう{学校}で{1:写真}を{1:撮}りました。{2:私}は{家}でも{2:写真}を{2:撮}りました。', 'わたし|がっこう|しゃしん|と|わたし|いえ|しゃしん|と', true);
And a straightforward example involving 10 replacements for testing purposes:
Genki.getAlts('{A}{B}{C}{D}{E}{F}{G}{H}{I}{J}', '1|2|3|4|5|6|7|8|9|10', true)
Is there a simple method to retrieve all combinations for a string regardless of the specified number of replacements? While I understand the number of combinations using Math.pow(2, n)
, I am unsure how to systematically generate them all.
I am open to suggestions regarding existing algorithms or frameworks that could address this challenge.
PS: The current implementation functions well up to 7 replacements, with issues arising beyond this limit. Although avoiding exceeding 7 would be ideal, it is not always feasible. Moreover, the current approach used may not be optimal, hence the desire to improve upon it.