"Exploring the versatility of utility functions in Vue components: whether to keep them

When it comes to registering functions in Vue Component, my preferred way is to only register methods in the component that are required by the view or need direct access to component data. Other functions that are not needed by the view are kept outside of the Vue component. The assumption here is that utilityFunction() and utilityFunctionTwo() are currently only used within this specific component.

Here is an example:

<template>
    <button @click="bar"></button>
    <button @click="foo"></button>
    <button @click="baz"></button>
</template>

<script>
  export default {
      name: "SampleComponent",
      data() {
          return {
              someVariable: "ABC",
              otherVariable: 123
          }
      },
      methods: {
          foo() {
              //some logic
              utilityFunction(this.someVariable);
              //other logic
          },
          bar() {
              //some logic
              utilityFunction(this.someVariable);
              utilityFunctionTwo(this.otherVariable);
              //some other logic
          },
          baz() {
              //some logic
              utilityFunctionTwo(this.someVariable);
              //some other logic
          }
      }
  }
  function utilityFunction(arg){
      //do something
  }
  function utilityFunctionTwo(arg){
      //do something
  }
</script>

Arguments may vary, utility functions can be pure and return values or mutate arguments. There could be various scenarios, but the key is understanding the context of usage.

Another approach is to add those functions as methods to your component like this:

<template>
    <button @click="bar"></button>
    <button @click="foo"></button>
    <button @click="baz"></button>
</template>

<script>
    export default {
        name: "SampleComponent",
        data() {
            return {
                someVariable: "ABC",
                otherVariable: 123
            }
        },
        methods: {
            foo() {
                //some logic
                this.utilityFunction();
                //other logic
            },
            bar() {
                //some logic
                this.utilityFunction();
                this.utilityFunctionTwo(this.otherVariable);
                //some other logic
            },
            baz() {
                //some logic
                this.utilityFunctionTwo(this.someVariable);
                //some other logic
            },
            utilityFunction() {
                //do something
                console.log(this.someVariable)
                //other stuff
            },
            utilityFunctionTwo(arg) {
                //do something
            }
        }
    }
</script>

In this approach, you may not always need to pass arguments to the method since it has access to the component's data object.

I personally lean towards the first approach for several reasons:

  1. I have a concise list of methods that are actually used by the template or required by the component. This helps maintain clarity and organization.
  2. If a function becomes useful elsewhere in the future, I can easily move it to a separate .js file and import it into other components.
  3. Functions do not have unnecessary access to the component's scope if they don't require it.
  4. It saves me from typing the this keyword repeatedly, especially when using lambda functions.

Whether to prefer one approach over the other might be subjective based on personal preferences, but there may also be objective factors to consider such as performance implications or adherence to certain principles of software design.

Answer №1

The main distinction lies in the fact that the utilityFunction and utilityFunctionTwo helper functions are not able to be tested. They cannot be accessed directly and are unable to be mocked, even if desired:

  export function utilityFunction(arg){
      //do something
  }

  export function utilityFunctionTwo(arg){
      //do something
  }

As described in more detail here, it is only possible to spy on or mock a function if it was exported from a module and utilized in another module.

To enhance testability and reusability, it is recommended to relocate utilityFunction and utilityFunctionTwo to a separate module.

Since these functions are exclusively used internally by a component and not reused elsewhere, one practical approach is to designate them as private methods using underscore notation:

    methods: {
        ...
        _utilityFunction() {
            //do something
        },
        _utilityFunctionTwo(arg) {
            //do something
        }
    }

A drawback to this method is that unlike regular functions, methods cannot be automatically eliminated as dead code if they remain unused.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Learn the process of obtaining a location and showcasing it on Google Maps

I am working on creating a program that utilizes modernizer to ask for the user's location and then displays it using Google Maps. So far, I have been able to use geolocation to determine the coordinates of the user's location and attempted to in ...

The SVG image created is not appearing on the screen

I'm working on a JavaScript project to display SVG elements, but I'm encountering an issue with the "image" element. For some reason, when I create the image element dynamically, it doesn't appear in the browser. However, if I manually copy ...

What is the process of declaring a variable within a Vue template?

Issue I find myself in a situation where I must temporarily hold the output of a function call in Vue templates. This is a common scenario within loops, especially when computed properties are not easily applicable. <ul> <li v-for="vehicleType ...

Creating a date in the style of a credit or debit card expiration date

I need to create dates in the format of 'Thru: 12/20' (similar to a credit/debit card expiration date). How can I generate a date in this specific format? new Date().toJSON().slice(0,7).split('-').reverse().join('/') Although ...

Command for Sniping with Discord.js

I am currently working on creating a snipe command using Discord.js in my bot. I have set up command handlers and everything seems to be working fine, including the on messageDelete event. However, I encounter an error when I delete a user message and try ...

I need to use Cheerio to scrape data from a web page. The data is structured in a specific format. How can I dynamically parse these tables that may have variable structures

Help! I'm struggling to understand arrays, objects, and loops. Why isn't there a simpler way for me to select elements from the DOM and export them as JSON? Here's the format I'm trying to achieve: From table ONE: Created th : Created ...

How are fetch and post related to each other?

I am not facing any issues with executing the program. My question revolves around two parameters that are located in different places within a file and their relationship. I have an HTML file: <!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en"> <hea ...

Choosing locations within a certain distance

I'm currently working on developing a map feature that allows users to search for nearby dealers based on their location. One issue I'm facing is figuring out how to properly utilize variables in an SQL statement. The process involves using Java ...

When using a JavaScript associative array, there are often many fields that are

I'm working with an associative array where the key is the item's ID. For example, if the item has an ID of 104, then the object would be array[104] = {item.info}; However, when I output my array in the component, it displays values from 1-103, ...

The input value may contain certain characters at any position

An issue has arisen with my directive that is meant to validate an input field to ensure it does not include the characters &, <, > .directive('refValidate', [function () { var regExp = /^[&\<\> ]*$/; return { ...

Adding data to MongoDB using an axios request

Upon receiving an object from a webpage, the data is posted using axios. The structure of the object is as follows: { "select_6": "serviced_apartments", "select_9": "4", "textarea_12": "hellow&qu ...

How to Utilize findIndex to Validate the Presence of Elements in an Array of Objects using TypeScript

I need assistance in checking which properties from an array are present in another array of objects and which ones are not. My object structure is as follows: var tempObj=[{id: '1', color: 'red, blue, green', age: 27},{id: '2& ...

How does the call method on array.prototype.includes work with arguments x and y?

Curious about the functionality of array.prototype.includes.call(x, y);. Discovered that includes() confirms if an array has the specified value and provides a true or false result. Learned that call() invokes this alongside any optional arguments. The ...

Issue with Vuex: token is not being stored in local storage

I have a Vue App store set up with Vuex: import Vue from 'vue' import Vuex from 'vuex' import axios from 'axios' Vue.use(Vuex) export default new Vuex.Store({ state: { email: null, token: localStorage.getItem(&apos ...

"Embrace the Use of Cookies" in TradingView

I had previously developed a script to automatically click on the 'Accept Cookies' button on the TradingView website (), using the following code: wait.until(EC.element_to_be_clickable((By.XPATH,"//span[text()='Accept all']")) ...

Postponed attaching event listeners to a Vue 3 instance within an iframe

Due to a specific requirement, I find myself in need of running a Vue instance inside an iframe. After some research and adjustments based on this thread from the Vue forum, I was able to achieve this goal while adapting the code for Vue 3 and removing unn ...

Using jQuery for asynchronous calls in conjunction with Node.js

Here is a snippet of my code with an API Endpoint. app.get('/clients/zvb/:id', function(req, res) { console.log('ZVB Query loaded as var = file;') var path = './public/queries/zvb.sql' var zvb = fs.readFileSync(path, "u ...

Is there a way to extend the styles applied to elements after the page has finished loading?

I have created an application with a element positioned at the top of the page. Directly below this element is another div. Upon clicking a button within the first element, HTML content from a website is loaded into the second div, bringing along all its ...

Vue 3's Paged.js does not respond to requests for page breaks

Currently, I'm working on implementing page breaks in Vue.js 3. Despite my efforts and utilization of the specified CSS code, I am facing challenges with the ".page-break" class parameter. While I can successfully modify other elements like titlePage ...

The equivalent of the $.curCSS method in jQuery version 1.10 is as follows:

While working with a library called mcdropdown from http://www.givainc.com/labs/, I encountered an issue with the $.curCSS method. The latest version of jQuery no longer supports this method and suggests using $().css instead. Following the documentation, ...