Why do we even need Angular controllers when directives can perform the same tasks as controllers?

As a new Angular developer, I have to say that I am really impressed with the architecture of this framework.

However, one thing that puzzles me is the existence of controllers. Let me elaborate:

Services in Angular seem to have a clear purpose: 1) Store model data needed throughout the application 2) Handle business logic 3) Communicate with the server

Views: 1) Display the model data

Directives: 1) Create scopes 2) Provide functionality to these scopes for taking user input and a) Updating the model b) Manipulating the DOM

So why do we need controllers? It appears that directives can handle everything that controllers do.

Is the distinction that controllers are responsible for updating the model while directives take care of DOM manipulation?

Answer №1

Some may argue that Angular is not a strongly opinionated framework, but others may claim otherwise.

Controllers provide an efficient means of accessing/creating a scope and connecting various components together. They offer flexibility and simplicity, making them ideal for handling tasks in a specific area.

Directives should aim to be reusable and descriptive, such as creating a button that triggers an ajax request and can be used in multiple locations. In this case, using a controller would not be suitable.

Opting for a directive instead of a controller when a controller is more appropriate can result in excessive code and a less appealing structure. This could be seen as a key differentiator between the two approaches.

However, if you believe directives are superior, there is no rule preventing you from utilizing them extensively.

Answer №2

Exploring the wisdom found in the AngularJS documentation :

Referencing this particular chapter:

Diving Into Directives

Directives serve as markers on a DOM element, be it an attribute, element name, comment, or CSS class. It signals AngularJS's HTML compiler ($compile) to imbue a specific behavior onto said DOM element or even metamorphose the DOM element and its offspring.

As discussed in another chapter:

Controllers come into play for:

  • Setting up the initial state of the $scope object.

  • Injecting behavior into the $scope object.

Controllers are not meant for the following:

  • Manipulating DOM — Controllers ought to encompass solely business logic. Injecting presentation logic into Controllers severely impedes testability. Angular offers databinding for most scenarios and directives for encapsulating manual DOM manipulation.

  • Formatting input — Opt for angular form controls instead.

  • Filtering output — Rely on angular filters instead.

  • Sharing code or state across controllers — Utilize angular services instead.

  • Overseeing the life-cycle of other components (e.g., creating service instances).

You're almost there, just scratching the surface.

An intriguing aspect is that due to AngularJS functioning atop Html pages and js code exclusively (contrary to conventional client/server setups), the view and "backend," typically supported by servers, coexist within the same document. The directive, designed to manipulate the DOM, plays a pivotal role in bootstrapping the application. Consequently, the temptation may arise to hardcode the application directly therein. This inclination is already reflected in the framework: specific directives cater to controllers.

In the MVC architecture, the controller serves as a liaison between views and models, consolidating functionalities revolving around a set of models and their data. It delineates pure UI aspects from business logic, ensuring that modifying your UI doesn't impact said logic unless new functionalities are being introduced. Nevertheless, these patterns intersect due to platform limitations.

The final verdict probably hinges on this notion: sans the built-in controller modules and directives, crafting new directives to bind UI entry points to business logic would become imperative. In doing so, one might end up creating objects adhering to the controller pattern to underpin code behind these entry points.

AngularJS streamlines this process for you, providing a ready-made solution.

Or perhaps pondering an alternative route?

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Error message: Attempting to access a property that is undefined (specifically 'ref') in MUI

Has anyone encountered this error when trying to customize themes in MUI v5 using custom variants? I keep seeing this error message: https://i.sstatic.net/D7F0e.png TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'ref') at Select (/va ...

Is there a way to trigger an Ajax function after individually selecting each checkbox in a list in MVC 4 using Razor syntax?

Is it possible to trigger an AJAX function when a checkbox within the ul below is checked? Each checkbox has a unique name attribute, such as chkbrand_1, chkbrand_2, chkbrand_3, etc. I am able to obtain the correct value using this code: $('.sear ...

Utilizing jQuery to dynamically update background colors within an ASP repeater based on the selected value of a dropdown list

On my asp.net web page, I have a repeater that displays a table with various fields in each row. I am trying to make it so that when the value of a dropdown within a repeater row changes, the entire row is highlighted in color. While I have achieved this s ...

Generating and verifying checksums for strings in Node JS: A step-by-step guide

I am in the process of rewriting a function in Node.js for generating and verifying checksums for payment transactions. I am new to coding in Node.js and need some guidance. The code I have received from the Service Provider needs to be converted into Nod ...

a guide on configuring a default input value from a database in a React component

In my current project, I have an input field with the type of "checkout" and I am looking to utilize Firestore to retrieve a default value. Once I obtain this value, I plan to store it in the state so that it can be modified and updated as needed. Here i ...

Surprising behavior encountered while utilizing fsPromises.open with Node.js

As I work on a larger app, I encounter an issue with a file writing operation. I am utilizing fsPromises to generate an autosave file, but the path variable seems to lose its value between a console log for debugging and the actual call to open the file. I ...

Click the button to send the form without including any hidden HTML element array value

My main goal is to create a dynamic dropdown menu for users when they click a button. Each click triggers a new dropdown to appear. To achieve this, I have been cloning a hidden div each time the button is clicked. Here's an example of how I am accom ...

Eliminate any unauthorized characters from the email address

My goal is to assist users in avoiding entering invalid characters in an email input field (prior to server-side validation and cleanup). Please note: I am not validating emails on the frontend, only cleaning them up. // Coffeescript $(Element).find(&apo ...

Generating data within an express route (with the use of socket.io-client)

Recently, I made the decision to refactor my code in order to separate the front and back end, which were previously combined into one service. However, I am now facing an issue where I need the web server to emit data to the data server after validation. ...

Error: Could not locate local grunt on Windows 7 Professional

When attempting to initiate grunt, an error message is displayed: c:\repositories\kunde_1\themes-projekt_1\projekt_1-responsive\source>grunt grunt-cli: The grunt command line interface. (v0.1.13) Fatal error: Unable to find lo ...

Even in the face of errors, Selenium with Node.js continues to run seamlessly. The challenge arises specifically with the 107.xx version of the Chrome browser and Chrome driver

Currently, I am employed in a project involving NODE JS (javascript) with selenium webdriver. Package.json- “chai”: “^4.3.6”, “chromedriver”: “^107.0.3”, “geckodriver”: “^3.2.0”, “mocha”: “^10.0.0”, “mochawesome”: “^7. ...

Learn the process of zipping a folder in a Node.js application and initiating the download of the zip file afterwards

After encountering issues with the latest version of the npm package adm-zip 0.4.7, I reverted to an older version, adm-zip 0.4.4. However, despite working on Windows, this version does not function correctly on Mac and Linux operating systems. Additionall ...

Is it possible to send arguments to the functions executed by "jQuery then"?

Check out the complete code here: http://jsfiddle.net/BurFz/ http://jsbin.com/dagequha/1/edit?js,console /** * executed function chain */ func1('arg1').then(func2).then(func3).then(function () { console.log('execution comp ...

Removing a pin from google maps using a personalized delete button

I have encountered an issue while attempting to remove a marker from Google Maps using a custom delete button within the info window. Even though I have successfully added the button and necessary information, it seems that the function responsible for del ...

Converting a String into a JSON Array

I currently have an array of JSON plots saved in MySQL. However, when I retrieve this information from the database, it is returned as a single long string. How can I convert this back into an array of JSON objects using JavaScript? My setup involves NodeJ ...

The input field does not accept any values even after setting it to be editable

Hey there! I have a specific requirement where I need to edit certain fields by clicking on an edit link. Initially, these fields will be disabled and in a readonly state. Once I click on the edit link, the field should become blank and editable. The issu ...

The class name is not defined for a certain child element in the icon creation function

Currently, I am developing a Vue2 web application using Leaflet and marker-cluster. I am encountering an issue with the iconCreateFunction option in my template: <v-marker-cluster :options="{ iconCreateFunction: iconCreateClsPrg}"> ...

Using JQuery to target the input value based on its ID

When trying to extract the value of the input with id "registration_type," I entered the following command in the console: $('#registration_type') The output displayed was: <input id=​"registration_type" name=​"contact_registration[ty ...

Issue with prop inheritance in componentInheritance problem with passing props to

How can I pass the state function setMyChoice as a prop to the GamePlay component in a rock paper scissors Nextjs application? The goal is to produce a value for comparison. In the Gameplay component, I then pass a prop to another component called PlayButt ...

Navigating to a different state key within a state object in React - a simple guide

Trying to dive into React, I encountered an issue. My goal is to create my own example from a tutorial. import React, { Component } from 'react'; class MyComponent extends Component { state = { persons: [], firstPersons: 5, variab ...