What measures can be taken to avoid json hijacking by utilizing the POST method?

Encountered the following issue with ASP.NET MVC while trying to return json in a Get method:

This request has been blocked because sensitive information could be disclosed to third party web sites when this is used in a GET request. To allow GET requests, set JsonRequestBehavior to AllowGet.

This security vulnerability is known as json Hijacking. This article explains how websites can be exploited when returning json using a Get request. However, returning json in a Post request is considered safe.

Why does changing from Get to Post method prevent this type of attack?

Answer №1

It was quite surprising to discover that there are still people attempting to demonstrate that JSON Hijacking remains a security concern (although it only applies to outdated browsers like Firefox 2, Opera 9, or Safari 3). This issue has been resolved in modern browsers for quite some time now. The article referenced in your query dates back to 2009. For further insights on how this problem was addressed, you can refer to this post. Additionally, you don't have to fret over JsonRequestBehavior, simply allow get and forget.

UPDATE

I apologize for not thoroughly reading the bounty question. Why does changing the request to post prevent JSON hijacking?

You can find an article here, detailing the steps involved in a JSON Hijacking attack:

  • Step 1: Convince an authenticated user to visit a malicious webpage.
  • Step 2: The malicious page attempts to access sensitive data from the application where the user is logged in by embedding a script tag in an HTML page, exploiting the fact that same-origin policy doesn't apply to script tags.

    <script src="http://<jsonsite>/json_server.php"></script>

    The browser sends a GET request to json_server.php along with the user's authentication cookies.

    ...

Picture this scenario: a user logs into www.yoursite.com and then visits a malicious site. If this malicious site contains a

<script src="http://www.yoursite.com/some_endpoint"></script>
tag, a GET request is made. If the returned data is JSON, the site could potentially access sensitive information using object prototype setter. (Remember, attackers prefer using SCRIPT tags over AJAX requests due to script tags bypassing same-origin policy. Refer to Cross-origin network access rules.)

However, if you switch the request type of

http://www.yoursite.com/some_endpoint
from GET to POST, your server will reject it when the browser attempts to access it.

Furthermore, here is an old MVC Framework book link provided for a more detailed explanation.

Answer №2

When setting a request as a POST, it will effectively block requests from other domains due to CORS policy unless your server is configured to allow it, adding another layer of complexity. Conversely, GET requests are permitted by browsers to fetch resources such as JavaScript containing sensitive data, especially if the data is in array format rather than an object.

New response:

There isn't a definitive source that explains how GET and POST requests differ when it comes to JSON Hijacking attacks. The distinction lies in how web servers and browsers handle these requests. JSON hijacking vulnerabilities occur when malicious websites exploit a specific endpoint on your site or app that serves JSON data in response to a GET request (which allows for resource downloads by default). By switching to a POST request, these sites cannot insert <script> tags performing unauthorized POST requests from the src attribute, as even within the script tag, CORS policy blocks POST attempts.

In today's browser environment, this type of vulnerability is no longer prevalent, primarily due to CORS policy enforcement (as noted in Jeremiah Grossman's discovery article).

This concept is also discussed in similar posts on related queries.

Answer №3

When you examine the network panel on a webpage containing scripts, images, stylesheets or fonts, you will notice that all requests are made using the GET HTTP method. For example, a request for a file loaded by a <script> tag will appear as follows:

https://i.sstatic.net/79zz0.png

Similarly, an example of a file loaded by an <img> tag will look like this:

https://i.sstatic.net/agsMu.png

The browser trusts that if you are loading such resources, you understand the implications, allowing content delivery networks (CDNs) to function effectively. This stands in contrast to XHR requests!

XHR requests (including fetch calls) are subject to CORS policy checks, which restrict JavaScript from making requests for resources on different domains or ports.

In summary, there are two types of request policies:

  1. XHR requests are CORS-checked, but allow any HTTP request method.
  2. Requests made using img, script, link, etc., are not subjected to CORS policy checks but are limited to GET HTTP requests only. Cookies, including authentication ones, are sent along with these requests.

This means that if you serve a JSON array via a GET request, you can utilize a script tag to fetch and execute it regardless of the domain. By leveraging the technique mentioned in the article, sensitive information can be accessed in this manner.

If you were to use POST, attackers would be unable to perform such requests through a script tag since they rely on GET requests for resource fetching.

You may consider using a form element, but CORS limitations still apply. Submitting a form loads the JSON data into the current page, preventing attackers from accessing it after the script is removed.

Even setting the form target to an iframe proves futile, as JavaScript blocks access within that iframe.

Does this explanation clarify things?

Answer №4

One should avoid returning JSON data using the GET method to prevent potential theft of information by malicious attackers who could inject a <script>. This can happen when dynamic content is loaded without proper HTML escaping. By sending data from the server with the POST method instead, it reduces the risk of running into issues caused by injected scripts. If a hacker manages to run their script, they could potentially access sensitive JSON data, including your logged in cookie.

To learn more about the vulnerabilities associated with JSON hacking, check out this article and this SO answer.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Encountering Android ResponseListener JSON Error while attempting to create a JSONObject instance

I am currently working on an application that interacts with a MySQL database to retrieve and store data. I have successfully managed to fetch one row of data, but running into issues when trying to fetch multiple rows. The problem arises when I try to ini ...

Ensure that the entire webpage is optimized to display within the viewport

My goal is to make the entire website fit perfectly into the viewport without requiring any scrolling. The main pages I am focusing on are index, music, and contact, as the other two pages lead to external sources (you can find the link at the bottom of th ...

What is the optimal approach for managing multiple languages using React Router version 5?

I am exploring the possibility of incorporating multiple languages into my website using React and React Router v5. Can you provide guidance on the most effective approach to achieve this? Below is a snippet of the current routing code I am working with: ...

A guide to showcasing a subcategory within a parent category through ajax

I have a custom module that displays the root category. When I click on a specific category, I want to use Ajax to display its subcategories with checkboxes. The code provided above retrieves all root categories: <?php $parentCategoryId = Mage::app() ...

Is there a way to verify if a username is already in use as I type it?

Most well-known websites feature a username field that changes color (usually red or blue) as a user types a new character. This color change indicates whether the entered characters match an existing username or not. For example, consider the following u ...

The labels on the bar graph ticks are failing to update in d3.js when the data is modified

My complete working code is below: const outerWidth = 600; const outerHeight = 300; const margin = 60; const height = outerHeight - 2*margin; const width = outerWidth - 2*margin; var data = [ { group: 'A', value: 5 }, { group: 'B', ...

React: Modifying values of individual input fields

Utilizing React, I have developed a basic list that showcases data fetched from an API. The fetching and updating of data is done through axios. An issue arises when updating a specific element in the list, causing all inputs to clear except for the acti ...

Checking the parameters passed to a function in Typescript: A step-by-step guide

Currently, I am working with Typescript and then transpiling my TS code into JavaScript. However, I have encountered an issue that I am struggling to resolve. The error message I am facing is as follows: Error Found in TypeScript on Line:2 - error TS230 ...

Activate bundling for AjaxToolkit stylesheets

Currently, I am utilizing the CompositeScript feature provided by the ajax ToolkitScriptManager to consolidate ajax .js files referenced in assemblies: <ajaxToolkit:ToolkitScriptManager ID="manScript" LoadScriptsBeforeUI="false" EnablePartialRender ...

Assistance with Jquery for toggling checkboxes when labels are clicked

I'm currently working on a feature that allows for checking and unchecking checkboxes upon label click. You can find my Jsfiddle here: http://jsfiddle.net/PTAFG/1/ The HTML structure cannot be altered Here is the snippet of my HTML: <div style= ...

The success callback in jQuery's $.ajax function is returning empty data

Using jQuery $.ajax to send a basic contact form to a php script, I am attempting to assess the response. Depending on the result, I aim to either replace the entire form with a "thank you" message or populate an "error" div with any issues encountered. De ...

Utilizing FeedIron for eliminating hyperlinks from TT-RSS feed content

I'm attempting to create a formula that will strip all links from the content of a feed. I'm using FeedIron on TT-Rss. Here is what I have so far: { "url": "example.com", "type": "regex", "pattern": "^(http:\/\/www\. ...

How can you show a different value in a select menu with AngularJS on selection?

When designing my menu to display US States for selection, I wanted to show both the 2-letter state code and the full name of the state initially. However, once the user selects a state, I only want to display the 2-letter code. This is how my menu looks: ...

What is the best way to manipulate and update individual counters in React components?

I developed a ticket ordering system for a project, but encountered an issue where increasing the quantity of one ticket also resulted in the incrementation of the other ticket's counter. I suspect this occurs because only one value is stored in the s ...

Is there a way to retrieve the present value of a dropdown menu once an ajax call is successful?

Currently, I am facing an issue where I am unable to retrieve the selected value from a dropdown menu. The logged value is always the first option in the dropdown menu, even though I have set it to a different value. Can someone help me identify what I may ...

Having trouble establishing a connection between data in Databricks and the data lake, as well as reading JSON files into

i'm currently working on a project inspired by the content in this blog post: specifically focusing on section 13 - utilizing Chloropleth maps: the code snippet they provide is as follows: import pandas as pd url = ( "https://raw.githubus ...

What causes objects to be added to an array even when the condition is not met?

In the process of creating a terminal game using node.js, I am developing a random field consisting of different elements such as hats, holes, and pathways. The player's objective is to navigate through the maze and locate their hat within the field. ...

Is it possible to use speech recognition on browsers besides Chrome?

Is there a way to utilize a microphone with JavaScript or HTML5 without relying on Flash technology? I was able to achieve this in Chrome by using webkit-speech, but I am looking for solutions that will work in other browsers as well. Any suggestions wou ...

What is the best method for disseminating data to multiple stores with just a single action in the React flux architecture?

Is there a way to efficiently update multiple stores with data in one action? Imagine receiving post data from a server as a user action. Below is a simple pseudo code for this action: class UserActions { getPosts() { asyncFetch(apiEndPoint, ...

In production environment, the CSRF Cookie is unexpectedly undefined while it functions properly during local execution on Express +

I am currently deploying my express API on Heroku and my client on Netlify. A peculiar issue arises when testing the signup route locally - the cookie is properly defined, and everything functions smoothly. However, once in production, the cookie always re ...