What are the drawbacks of implementing two-way binding between a parent component and a child component in a software system?

Lately, I have been focused on AngularJS development but recently I started exploring Vue.js and going through its guide. On one of the pages, I came across the following:

By default, all props form a one-way-down binding between the child property and the parent one: when the parent property updates, it will flow down to the child, but not the other way around. This default is meant to prevent child components from accidentally mutating the parent’s state, which can make your app’s data flow harder to reason about.

You can find this information at https://vuejs.org/guide/components.html#Prop-Binding-Types.

I am curious about the principles guiding the use of two-way binding versus one-way binding. In situations where the child component needs to handle an array variable, it seems logical that two-way binding would be beneficial.

For instance, if I were to create my own version of selectize.js using Vue.js or AngularJS, utilizing two-way binding would involve passing the parent component's array to the selectize component for management.

In cases where two-way binding isn't used, other options would entail either manual updating of the array by the parent component, setting the array via a function passed to the child component, or having the child dispatch an event to update the parent's array.

Both alternatives seem more verbose and less advantageous compared to two-way binding. This scenario could apply to many components, such as a product-selector component where managing selected products becomes easier when the component handles the array reflecting these selections.

My key inquiries regarding this matter are:

  1. Is my understanding of the alternatives to two-way binding correct?

  2. Are there specific advantages to employing one-way-down binding in the mentioned cases? The alternatives don't seem to offer significant benefits in preventing unintentional changes to the parent's state.

  3. If (1) and (2) are accurate, can you provide an example where one-way-down binding clearly prevents "accidental mutations to the parent's state"?

Answer №1

"One-way-down binding" is a fundamental concept that aims to simplify code complexity, much like OO's Encapsulation.

I believe the author did not intend to discourage the use of "two-way binding" (which VueJS actually supports), but rather emphasized the importance of using it judiciously.

In the examples provided, the product-selector behaves similarly to a native input field, making it suitable for two-way binding usage, akin to what v-model offers.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

combine various types of wrappers in React

We're embarking on a fresh project with React, and we will be utilizing: React Context API i18n (react.i18next) GraphQL (Apollo client) Redux CSS-in-JS (styled-components or aphrodite) The challenge lies in each of these implementations wrapping a ...

Having trouble with $ionicModal throwing an undefined error?

I am attempting to implement a modal window upon clicking, I had successfully used the code in a previous project but encountering an error when trying it in a new project: > TypeError: Cannot read property 'show' of undefined at > Scope.$ ...

Getting the Right Value: A Step-by-Step Guide to Setting the Default or Selected Value in

When creating directive form controls (text, select, radio), I am passing a value to the directive function. If this value is not set or empty, then the default value should be taken from the question data._pageAttributes.defaultValue. HTML <div ng-re ...

Customize form input using Javascript prior to inserting into database

On my Rails form, I have a basic setup like the following: <%= form_for @song do |f| %> <p> <%= f.label :url %><br> <%= f.text_field :url %> </p> <p> <%= f.submit %> </p> <% en ...

The wrapping of cells in React Material UI GridList is not functioning properly

While working with Material-UI GridList, I've encountered an issue where the cells don't wrap correctly within the grid. Upon inspecting the CSS, I noticed that it utilizes flex-wrap, which is intended to flex rows. However, I believe there must ...

The component triggering the redirect prematurely, interrupting the completion of useEffect

I set up a useEffect to fetch data from an endpoint, and based on the response, I want to decide whether to display my component or redirect to another page. The problem I'm facing is that the code continues to run before my useEffect completes, lead ...

Unable to view cross domain cookies within the browser's development tools

I am currently working on a web application that has an Angular front end running on http://localhost:4200 and a NodeJs backend running on http://localhost:3000. When a user successfully logs in, a cookie is set from the backend containing a token. However ...

Issue with Bootstrap Scrollspy: Scrollspy function not functioning as expected

I need help with creating a one-page website where the navbar links change based on the section of the page you are on. I tried implementing it using HTML, but it didn't work out as expected. The code I used was within the container holding different ...

The relationship between Vue TypeScript props is influenced by the presence of another prop

Is there a way to define a property in <script setup lang="ts"> that depends on another property? For instance, how can I require a variable only if another variable is present? I attempted using defineProps<Props | PropsA>(), but e ...

Typescript: Determine when a property should be included depending on the value of another property

Having some difficulty with Typescript and React. Specifically, I am trying to enforce a type requirement for the interface Car where the property colorId is only required if the carColor is set to 'blue'. Otherwise, it should not be included in ...

The cross-origin resource sharing (CORS) functionality is functioning properly on the

I've encountered an unusual problem with express cors. While my Cors configuration works perfectly on localhost, it fails to function in the production environment. Every time I encounter the same error. Failed to load : Response to preflight r ...

Limit the input to a specific format

Currently developing a JavaScript application, but having some confusion with Regular Expressions. The main goal is to allow users to input a specific format of strings in a text area for the application to process accordingly, thus requiring restriction o ...

What could be causing the issue with HTML not being printed upon button click in ReactJS?

My goal is to display the word "Hello" on the screen when the add button is clicked. However, I am encountering an issue where it is not showing up. Any insights or solutions would be greatly appreciated! import React, { Component } from 'react'; ...

Can custom HTML elements be designed to function similarly to standard ones?

What is the best way to create a custom HTML element that functions as a link without relying on inline Javascript? For instance: <x-button href="...">...</x-button> Can I develop an element like <x-button> that can accept an attribute ...

Quantifying the passage of time for data entry

Looking to create a quiz form where I can track how long it takes users to input/select answers. I attempted the following code but the timing seems off: $('input, select').on('focus', function(event) { el = $(this); name ...

Can you provide the syntax for using the watch function in the Vue 3 composition API?

https://stackoverflow.com/a/63800832/1497720 In the world of watching variables, there is a common syntax that looks like this: watch(<variable>, <function to handle>). However, in the insightful answer provided at , a different approach is in ...

Tips on customizing the appearance of mat-card-title within a mat-card

Is there a way to truncate the title of a mat card when it overflows? I tried using the following CSS: overflow:hidden text-overflow:ellipsis white-space: nowrap However, the style is being overridden by the default mat-card style. I attempted to use mat ...

Karma is reporting an error with TypeScript, saying it cannot locate the variable 'exports'

Currently, I am in the process of mastering how to write Unit Test cases for an angular project coded in Typescript. To facilitate this, I have opted for utilizing Karma and Mocha. Below lays out the structure of the application: Project/ ├── app/ ...

Start with Angular routing, then switch to mvc routing if needed

My project utilizes Angular and node.js on IIS 7.5 for the frontend, and a .NET Web API for backend calls. The Angular routing and API routing are working smoothly when testing with Visual Studio/IIS Express and ng serve. However, they run on separate por ...

Exploring the Method of Accessing data-* Attributes in Vue.js

I have a button that, when clicked, triggers a modal to open. The content displayed in the modal is determined by the data attributes passed to the button. Here is my button: <button class="btn btn-info" data-toggle="modal" data-t ...