Understanding Semantic Versioning (Semver) - A guide to properly Semvering major functional enhancements while maintaining backwards compatibility

It is my understanding that when using X.Y.Z, X is only changed for breaking updates while Y is reserved for backward compatible functional modifications.

Therefore, can I infer correctly that even if my update involves a significant enhancement to functionality without any breaking changes, I should not alter the X?

TLDR Regardless of how substantial the update may be, as long as it does not cause any disruptions, the X in X.Y.Z remains unchanged.

Answer №1

When making a significant functional update that remains compatible with previous versions, it is recommended to increment the major version number. This aligns with the guidelines outlined in Semver 2.0.0.

In accordance with Semver 2.0.0, Major version X (X.y.z | X > 0) MUST be increased if any changes that are incompatible with previous versions are made to the public API. It may also include minor and patch level changes. Patch and minor versions should reset to 0 when the major version is incremented.

Following the language specified in RFC 2119 as referenced by Semver, the emphasis on permission to increment the major version only for minor and patch level changes highlights the flexibility in interpreting these guidelines.

This interpretation acknowledges that many non-breaking changes consist of numerous minor and patch-level adjustments. The absence of directives such as "It must not only include minor and patch level changes" or "It must involve backwards incompatible modifications" in the specification allows for some discretion in version increments.

Paragraph 7 suggests an alternative option of solely increasing the minor version in certain scenarios, offering leeway where technically no backward compatibility issues exist but the updates are substantial enough to appear major.

This approach recognizes the need for flexibility in cases where significant business or marketing-driven developments warrant a major version upgrade beyond just changes in the API specifications.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

In Typescript, we can use a class to encapsulate another class and then return a generic result

Trying to wrap my head around the concept of generic classes, and now I need to dynamically create another class. However, I am uncertain about how to go about it. Class A {} Class B<T> { Return T } Const c = B(A); // which is T More context on w ...

How can I convert Double Quotes from (") to (&quot;) in TinyMce Editor?

While using TinyMce Editor, I have encountered a problem with double quotes breaking my code. In the HTML source of TinyMce, it displays " instead of &quot, causing issues in conversion. It seems that it is not converting " to " as it should, simi ...

Text that appears automatically in an input field

I've searched high and low, but I just can't seem to find a solution that works for me. What I need is a way to automatically populate a HTML text field with default text when the page loads. This default text should ideally be a PHP variable and ...

Unable to create a post request using jQuery with a JSON payload

When using the Chrome REST service, I successfully make a post request to a specific URL by sending a JSON string in the body and setting the content type as application/json. However, when trying to achieve the same with jQuery, I encounter some issues. ...

React: Issue with input values not correctly updating across multiple fields when changing state toggles

I am working on a React component that needs to update input values for multiple players independently. However, I am facing an issue where toggling a state causes the first input's value to incorrectly propagate to all other inputs. Additionally, cle ...

AngularJS module is experiencing issues with loading properly

Can someone please help me understand what the issue is? I am new to AngularJS and may have overlooked something. Below is my simple HTML code: <!DOCTYPE html> <html> <script type="text/javascript" src="angular.js"></script> ...

Leveraging the power of React Native with embedded RapidAPI functionality in the source

I had previously used the following code to retrieve a JSON file containing personal data in my React Native source code: async componentDidMount() { try { const response = await fetch('mydomain.org/personaldata.json'); const responseJson ...

Is it possible to create an API directly within the URL of a React.js application, similar to how Next.js allows?

When using Next.js, I can access my application on localhost:3000, and also access my API from localhost:3000/api/hello. I'm curious if there is a way to achieve this same setup with React.js and another framework like Express.js? If Next.js is not ...

Encountered an issue while resolving dependency tree for angular tslib

When running npm install, I encountered the error shown in this image: https://i.stack.imgur.com/PInQE.png The CLI version is Angular CLI: 9.1.8. Any assistance would be greatly appreciated. Thank you! ...

Showing dummy data in demo mode with an AngularJS table

I stumbled upon this interesting jsfiddle http://jsfiddle.net/EnY74/20/ that seems to be using some demo data. If you check out this example https://jsfiddle.net/vsfsugkg/2/, you'll notice that the table originally has only one row, but I modified it ...

Encountering an npm start issue during the development of a React application

I am facing an issue with my React app while using the command npm start. The error occurs specifically when running react-scripts start on my Windows 7 32-bit OS. (NOTE: I created the app using npx create-react-app my-react) The error message is as foll ...

Issue: No default template engine specified and no file extension provided. (Using Express framework)

While I came across numerous questions with a similar title, they only provided me with partial help and did not completely resolve the error that plagued me. Just to provide some context, I had created a file named listing.js as a tool for running node c ...

What is the best way to iterate through multiple iframes?

I need help figuring out how to load one iframe while having the next one in line to be displayed. Is there a way to create a script that cycles through multiple iframes after a certain amount of time? ...

Listening for select elements that have remained unchanged

My current situation involves a select box with predetermined options. One of these options is preselected when the page loads: <select name="select" class="js-choice-select"> <option value="option-1">Option 1</option> <option ...

The entirety of the text has been mirrored to the right in React Native code

Is there a way to align this text on both the left and right sides, along with styling the button and text input elements to be more colorful and have bigger fonts? Below is an example of the desired outcome: This is what I have attempted so far: <Vie ...

Determine the selected option in the dropdown menu upon loading the page and when clicked

I am working on capturing the value of a drop-down list whenever it is changed or when the page loads. The aim is to display different div elements based on the selected option in the report field - either State or Year. Any assistance with this would be ...

Using socket.io in a Django template without the need for the node.js service or socket.io.js file

I am working on a Django app that requires real-time push to clients. I have decided to use node.js and socket.io as it is considered the easiest platform for achieving this functionality. To implement this, I have included the socket.io framework code in ...

What could be the reason for the failure of running the command `meteor npm install --save angular

Encountering a major problem with meteor npm install while using: Meteor Angular Meteor The issue arises when trying to import ui-grid, similar to importing uiRouter or angularUBoostrap. However, this has proven to be extremely difficult. I have attemp ...

Is there a way to modify the value of an object in a Vuex store using actions in Vue.js?

I have data stored in an array within the state and I need to update a specific object. How can I change the value of the object with id 1 to true using Vuex actions? state.js const array=[] mutations.js storeArray(state, data) { state.array = data ...

The bower package named "App States" could not be located as the bower.json file

What can I do to resolve this issue? aaa@aaa $ bower install bower.json bower bower.json#* cached git://github.com/Kalitte/app-states.git#0.6.9 bower bower.json#* validate 0.6.9 against git://github.com/Kalitte/app-states.git#* ...