Uncertainty surrounding $q and commitments

After spending several hours researching Kris Kowal's Q library and the angularjs $q variable, I am still struggling to comprehend how it all works.

Currently, my service contains the following code:

resetpassword: function (email, oldPassword, newPassword) {

                var deferred = $q.defer(); //I find myself questioning why I need this
                var promise = auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword); //$changepassword in angularfire returns a promise
                console.log(deferred); //An object with resolve, reject, notify, and promise attributes is displayed
                var rValue = promise.then(function(){
                        //success callback
                        return 1; //this is expected behavior if changepassword succeeds
                    }, function(error){
                        //error callback
                        return error.code; //handles scenarios like wrong password input
                    }
                );
                deferred.resolve(promise); //Is this necessary? I assumed my promise was resolved in the callbacks
                console.log(rValue); //The output is another promise. How can I access 1 or error.code values?
                return rValue; //My intention is to return 1 or error.code back to the controller
            },

Answer №1

const promise = $q.defer(); //What is the purpose of this?

You are engaging in the deferred anti-pattern by using $q.defer(), indicating a lack of understanding of promises. There is never a valid reason to utilize $q.defer() within your application logic.

Your function should return a promise:

resetpassword: function(email, oldPassword, newPassword) {
    return auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword)
           .then(function() { return 1; })
           .catch(function(e) { return e.code });
}

Usage:

resetpassword(...)
.then(function(num) {
    if (num === 1) {

    }
    else {

    }
});

Consider how the function would look in synchronous code:

 resetpassword: function(email, oldPassword, newPassword) {
     try {
         auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword)
         return 1;
     }
     catch (e) {
         return e.code;
     }
 }

Answer №2

A promise is like a contract between functions, where one function agrees to respond once another function completes its task. This allows for the creation of an execution chain that mimics running multiple threads simultaneously. When the deferred object finishes processing, it sends back a status code which can be used by the calling function to determine its next action, either returning its own status code or responding accordingly.

var deferred = $q.defer();

Creating a deferred object here stores callbacks that will be executed later on.

var promise = auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword);

This line sets up the actual function call but does not execute it immediately. By assigning it to a variable, we are able to monitor its progress.

var rValue = promise.then(function(){

The .then() method defines what happens upon successful completion of the promise. Here, an inline function is set to run after the promise succeeds.

}, function(error){

An error handling function is chained after the success function, specifying how to handle failures. It provides a way to respond in case the promise doesn't deliver as expected.

deferred.resolve(promise);

This step instructs the deferred object to execute the code, wait for results, and then trigger either the success or failure actions. The promise is now part of the execution chain, allowing our main code to proceed without waiting around. Once the promise resolves, the appropriate callback will be triggered.

 console.log(rValue); 

In this log statement, we're not directly returning values to avoid blocking the program's flow. Instead, we allow the promises to work asynchronously while the rest of the code continues executing.

return rValue;

Finally, our function returns the promise to the caller, ensuring that the communication between functions remains seamless. Using promises enables us to handle responses without getting stuck waiting for each individual operation to complete. We pass along success or failure information, keeping the code flowing smoothly.

Answer №3

Deferred promises are used in situations where the time needed to complete a task is uncertain or when the exact completion time is not important - typically for asynchronous tasks. The main focus is on receiving the result whenever the code notifies that the task is finished.

It is crucial to return a promise in your function for the deferred you create. The calling code that invokes resetpassword should then wait for this promise to be fulfilled.

function (email, oldPassword, newPassword) {

                var deferred = $q.defer(); //The purpose is to inform the calling code once $changepassword is done. Alternatively, you could directly return the promise from angularfire with different return values.
                var promise = auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword); //$changepassword returns a promise in angularfire
                console.log(deferred); //An object containing resolve, reject, notify, and promise attributes
                promise.then(function(){
                        //success callback
                        deferred.resolve(1); //Upon successful changepassword completion, execution reaches here
                    }, function(error){
                        //error callback
                        deferred.reject(0); //If changepassword fails (e.g., incorrect old password), this block is executed
                    }
                );
                // It's improper to do this.
                console.log(rValue); //This displays another promise? Why not 1 or error.code? How do I access these values??
                return deferred.promise; //Send back the promise to your controller
            }

Answer №4

Your approach involves combining promises, as indicated in the code comments,

$changepassword in angularfire returns a promise

In essence, var deferred = $q.defer() generates a new promise using deferred.promise, but you are essentially already creating a promise with $changePassword. To achieve what you intend to do, simply follow this:

resetpassword: function (email, oldPassword, newPassword) {               
    auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword).then(function(result)       {
        console.log(result); // success here
    }, function(err){
        console.log(err); // error here
    });
}

UPDATE:

Based on Robin's feedback, if you wish to handle the result within a controller instead of invoking the then() function inside the service, return the promise itself to the controller. Here is an example:

Service function:

resetpassword: function (email, oldPassword, newPassword) {
    // send back the promise to the caller
    return auth.$changePassword(email, oldPassword, newPassword);
}

Controller function:

.controller('MyCtrl', ['$scope', 'myService', function($scope, myService){
    // retrieve the promise from the service
    myService.resetPassword($scope.email, $scope.oldPassword, $scope.newPassword).then(function(result){
        // utilize result here
    }, function(err){
        // handle err here
    });
}]);

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Can you explain the concept of a "cURL" and guide me on how to use it effectively?

I'm currently working on setting up a Lyrebird application, but I only have a basic understanding of javascript and php. Despite my efforts to implement a cURL request from , I've encountered issues trying to get it to work in both javascript and ...

What is the correct way to utilize the WhatsApp API for sending messages?

Trying to incorporate WhatsApp API notifications into my app has been a challenge. Despite extensive research, I have yet to find an official solution. The existence of the WhatsApp API Business is known, but it currently remains in beta and caters to com ...

Should scripts be replayed and styles be refreshed after every route change in single page applications (SPA's)? (Vue / React / Angular)

In the process of creating a scripts and styles manager for a WordPress-based single page application, I initially believed that simply loading missing scripts on each route change would suffice. However, I now understand that certain scripts need to be ex ...

Navigating the ropes of push-pull functionality in Bootstrap 5

How can I utilize push and pull in Bootstrap version 5.0.0-beta2? In Bootstrap 3, my code looks like this: <link href="https://stackpath.bootstrapcdn.com/bootstrap/3.4.1/css/bootstrap.min.css" rel="stylesheet" /> <div class="row"> <d ...

Should I utilize Maven to build both the Javascript web app and Java server, or opt for using Grunt specifically for the web app

We are developing a web application using AngularJS and we are interested in incorporating Bower for Dependency Management and Grunt for tasks such as building and running tests. (Yeoman) Our server is built with Java using Maven, so naturally we would li ...

Tips on leveraging state values within the makeStyles function in Material UI React

I'm in the process of building a Webpage and incorporating Material UI for the Components. Here's the code: import { makeStyles, Typography } from "@material-ui/core"; const useStyles = makeStyles((theme) => ({ container: { ...

How can I make the ion-list stay on top of the ion-footer-bar?

In the process of developing an application, I encountered an issue where the ion-footer-bar would cover the last record in the ion-list. After exploring various solutions, such as using `$scope.$broadcast('scroll.resize');`, the problem still pe ...

Amazon Banner Integration for Angular Version 4

Having some trouble getting an Amazon banner to display inside an angular material 2 card. The div appears empty and the banner is not rendering. Any idea what could be causing this issue? Below is the code snippet showcasing my attempts: <md-card clas ...

Tips for retaining component data while navigating between components in vue js

If I have two elements, the first one is named X: <template> <input required type='text' v-model.trim="number"> <input type="date" v-model="date" > <button @click='allData(number,date)'>ok</button> <t ...

Generating a fresh object derived from an existing object without saving any modifications

I am facing an issue with using an Array to store boilerplate objects that can be copied, modified, and added to another Array. The problem arises when the new Array takes ownership of the object, causing changes to persist in the original object. For exa ...

What causes the inconsistency in TypeScript's structure typing?

It is well-known that TypeScript applies structure typing, as demonstrated in the following example: interface Vector { x: number; y: number; } interface NamedVector { x: number; y: number; name: string; } function calculateLength(v: Vecto ...

Looping through images using JQuery

I'm struggling with an image animation and can't quite figure out how to make it work. <div id="img_loop"> <img src="img/img1.jpg" alt="image1" /> <img src="img/img2.jpg" alt="image2" class="hidden" /> <img src="im ...

Styling with CSS and Angular: Loading background images dynamically with a greyscale effect

Incorporating the image displayed above as a background photo in CSS is my current objective using Angular. My aim is to alter the photo path for each new item added to my list. As it stands, the styles are hardcoded, resulting in a constant image that fun ...

What causes the return of 'undefined' during the execution of type coercion?

Can you explain why the type of a variable changes but the value remains undefined when trying to set it? let average; // Do I need to initialize with 'average = 0;' for it to work properly? for (const [oddName, odd] of Object.entries(game.odd ...

Conceal hyperlink repeatedly using jQuery

I am struggling with implementing a feature where I have two links, one displayed and the other hidden. Upon clicking the first link, it should disappear and the second link should be displayed. Clicking the second link should then hide itself and show the ...

Vue search button not returning results

Hello, this is my HTML file. <div id="app1" v-cloak> <input v-model="term" type="search"> <button @click="search">Search</button> <p/> <div v-for="post in posts" class="post"> ...

Utilizing AJAX and jQuery to dynamically load a div instantly, followed by automatic refreshing at set intervals

I am utilizing jQuery and AJAX to refresh a few divs every X seconds. I am interested in finding out how to load these divs immediately upon the page loading for the first time, and then waiting (for example, 30 seconds) before each subsequent refresh. I h ...

Developing an SQL table for a website using JavaScript

My command is not functioning as expected and I am struggling to identify the issue. The database opens successfully, however, it fails to process the table creation. var createtable2 = 'CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS offlineCabinDefects (id INTEGER PRIM ...

Struggling to make the JavaScript addition operator function properly

I have a button that I want to increase the data attribute by 5 every time it is clicked. However, I am struggling to achieve this and have tried multiple approaches without success. var i = 5; $(this).attr('data-count', ++i); Unfortunately, th ...

javascript: update hidden field if date is past January 15th

Having a bit of trouble with this one after a full day! The form contains a hidden field called 'grant_cycle'. If the form is submitted after January 15th, it should have the value 'Spring, [year]', or if after July 15th, it should be ...