The difference between emitting and passing functions as props in Vue

Imagine having a versatile button component that is utilized in various other components. Instead of tying the child components to specific functionalities triggered by this button, you want to keep those logics flexible and customizable within each component using the button.

There appear to be two main strategies for achieving this:

  1. Have the child component emit an event to its parent components, allowing the parents to determine the appropriate handler function.

  2. Alternatively, define the handlers in the parent components and pass them down to the button component as props.

In React, I typically opt for the latter approach. Is there a preferred method or best practice in Vue for handling this kind of situation?

Answer №1

In the world of Vue, the guiding principle is passing props down and handling events up. The preferred approach aligns closely with this philosophy by emitting the event (up) to the parent component for it to be managed.

Additionally, when working within a Vue Single File Component (SFC), you have the advantage of using a v-on (or @) prefix for bound attributes to indicate that they are events being sent upwards, rather than using v-bind (or :) which may imply they are props, when in reality they are callbacks triggered by events.

Answer №2

Vue.js events are callbacks, not actual DOM events. This can be confirmed by the custom name added to the event listener instead of a standard DOM event name like click or focus. Additionally, there is no event object passed to the function unless specifically specified with an $event argument in the $emit call.

Events

Advantages

  • For libraries: provides a lighter option and gives clients more flexibility in method usage
  • Useful Vue devtools event logging feature
  • Allows global listeners (this.$root.on), although this aspect could be improved with Vuex.js
  • Different syntax: : for props and @ for events/methods

Disadvantages

  • Less explicit, making debugging harder (fail silently if there are no listeners or if the event name is misspelled)

Props

Advantages

  • More explicit, declarative, defaultable, required, and validated, which makes them easier to debug (runtime errors or compilation errors in TypeScript)

Disadvantages

  • Need to include props validation to avoid checking if a function() prop exists before calling it (although using props validation is a good practice regardless)

Conclusion

Seems like the choice between approaches comes down to convention and personal preference. If Vue.js documentation didn't favor the events approach, many would likely opt for using props exclusively, which I believe is clearer and better.

Props can accomplish everything that events do, except for a few scenarios (like the $root event listening pattern - where Vuex.js is recommended for scalability). The advantage of using props lies in their explicitness, debuggability, and error-checking capabilities.

Refined from: https://forum.vuejs.org/t/events-vs-callback-props/11451

Answer №3

Coming from a React background, I find it puzzling why the @event attribute even exists (or why it is considered standard as mentioned in the previous answers). It's hard for me to determine which events a component will $emit, but identifying which props are being passed down is much clearer to me. With proper naming conventions, I can easily distinguish which ones are callback events.

Answer №4

Recommended Approach

The best practice in this scenario would be to go with option number 1. This approach is clearly outlined in the official Vue.js documentation under the section: Sending Messages to Parents with Events

Performance

When passing a reference to a function for execution either through an event bus or as a prop, you should not experience any noticeable performance drawbacks.

Illustrative Example of Option 1

To implement option 1, use the following syntax:

this.$emit('eventName', dataToSend, ...)
to transmit data to the parent component which will then listen for the event like so:
<my-component @eventName="yourHandler" />
. This allows for the differentiation of logic based on each button function.

For demonstration purposes, I have put together a fiddle showcasing a multi-select component that applies this methodology: Multi-Select Component Fiddle

// HTML
<div id="app">
  <multi-choice :items="myItems" @selected="alert($event)"></multi-choice>
  <multi-choice :items="myItems" @selected="sayIsCool"></multi-choice>
</div>

// JavaScript
const multiChoice = {
    template: '<div class="multi-choice"><span v-for="item in items" @click="select(item)">{{ item }}</span></div>',
  props: ['items'],
  methods: {
    select(item) {
        this.$emit('selected', item);
    }
  }
};

new Vue({
  el: "#app",
  data() {
    return {
        myItems: [
        'Homer',
        'Marge',
        'Bart'
      ],
    }
  },
  components: {
    multiChoice: multiChoice
  },
  methods: {
    sayIsCool(item) {
        alert(item + ' is cool!')
    }
  }
})

Answer №5

Are you in search of "See-through Packaging"?

The way Vue's custom event functions is distinct from a traditional DOM event. To make it work, you must attach the .native property to the event.

If your goal is for the event to take place on the child element, then create a computed property that will return an object of listeners. This way, you won't have to worry about...

By default, any attributes not specifically defined as props will be applied to the main element of the view.

To change this behavior, set inheritAttrs: false and then connect the $attrs to the child component so it becomes the recipient of those attributes.

This approach eliminates the need to determine the root component.

Chris Fritz offers an excellent explanation of these concepts in his presentation on the 7 secret patterns. His insights begin at 21:44 here.

Answer №6

In my opinion, the outcome of this scenario hinges on whether or not we provide a more comprehensive context. Comparing props to events is akin to comparing pull versus push, much like any pub-sub system.

When passing props, we essentially inject (push) the parent context's dependencies into the child context, resulting in potential contamination of the child context by the parent context. Instead of just holding a weak reference to the parent, any changes made in the parent context will also affect the child context. This creates a tight coupling between the two.

On the other hand, with event pulling, the parent listens for events from the child, and each event data is preferably treated as a copy value rather than a reference. This eliminates the coupling issue between parent and child contexts. By using a queue or custom modifier for events, we can make it easier to control how parents interact with children (for example, avoiding the need to manage debounce or throttle functions in the parent context, and handling them within the child context instead - such as within the Button component).

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

How can the 'Read more' feature be modified to impact multiple boxes? (Using jQuery, JS, and CSS)

I am trying to add a 'Read more' feature on my friend's website. I was able to achieve the desired effect, but when I tried to adjust the alignment of the box, it affected the 'Read more' feature. Original design: https://codepen. ...

Allow-Origin-Control, handler.php for emails, and form validation script

I encountered a strange bug recently. There's been some issues with the HTML5 template I downloaded, specifically related to the contact form and MailHandler.php file. Despite having both files in the same directory, when inspecting element in Chrome, ...

Watch as jQuery preloads every select list

There are two select lists, and the second one is dependent on the first. After loading the second list, I want to trigger some alerts. What is the most effective approach to accomplish this using jQuery? Let's say the second list is populated in the ...

Is it possible to implement Vue2 components within a Vue3 environment?

Recently, I've built a collection of Vue2 components that I've been using across multiple projects through a private npm repository. Now, as I begin a new project in Vue3, I'm wondering if it's feasible to incorporate the old components ...

What is the process for filtering out a particular version of an npm package?

Here is my current configuration: "@vue/test-utils": "^1.0.0-beta.25" Can anyone recommend a way to exclude a particular version of this package while still using the caret ^ notation? I specifically need to exclude version 1.0.0-beta.31 as it has cause ...

JavaScript and PHP are successfully displaying a success message despite the data not being saved to the database

I recently added a new feature to my website where users can submit a form using Javascript without having to reload or refresh the page. This allows for a seamless experience and displays success messages instantly. However, being a newcomer to Javascript ...

Could using 'require' in node.js lead to a memory leak issue?

I have been working on a program that experiences continuous heap growth. The program is quite simple - it repeatedly tries to load an external file (SyntaxError) using require. However, this external module fails to load due to a syntax error present in i ...

Having trouble with testing axios web service promises to return results using Jest in a Vue.js application

In the process of developing a new application with Vue.js and axios, I am focusing on retrieving stock market details based on company names. To kickstart the application, I am compiling all the names of US-based S&p 500 companies into a JavaScript ar ...

What is the most effective method for transmitting a zip file as a response in Azure functions with node.js?

With the Azure function app, my goal is to download images from various URLs and store them in a specific folder. I then need to zip these images and send the zip file back as a response. I have successfully achieved this by following these steps: Send ...

What is the best way to manage the back button functionality on pages that use templates?

I am currently developing a website using angularjs. The layout consists of two main sections: the menu and the content area. For instance This is an example page: /mainpage <div> <div id="menu"> <div ng-click="setTemplate('fi ...

Modifying subtotal values using PHP and JavaScript

I've been working on this code snippet to calculate my subtotal and determine the total payment. Can someone provide some assistance? $viewx = mysql_query("select distinct toorderid from ordercontainer where toordercategory='$ordercategory' ...

Issue with React Hot Toast not displaying properly due to being positioned behind the <dialog>

The Challenge of Toast Notifications Visibility with <dialog> Element tl;dr When utilizing the native dialog.showModal() function, the <dialog> element appears to consistently remain on top, which causes toast notifications to be obscured by ...

Animate failed due to the appending and adding of class

$('#clickMe').click(function() { $('#ticketsDemosss').append($('<li>').text('my li goes here')).addClass('fadeIn'); }); <link href="http://s.mlcdn.co/animate.css" rel="stylesheet"/> <script ...

Utilize regular expressions in TamperMonkey to extract specific groups of text

I'm currently working on a TamperMonkey userscript that aims to identify URLs matching a specific pattern, visit these pages, extract relevant information, and then update the link for each URL with the extracted text. I'm facing some challenges ...

Unregistering an event with AngularJS

Exploring the functions of a controller named MyCtrl: class MyCtrl { constructor($scope, $rootScope, ...) { this.$scope = $scope; this.$rootScope = $rootScope; this.doThis = _debounce(this.resize.bind(this), 300); ... ...

Transforming Adobe Animate CC into a customized Vue.js component

Can someone share the optimal method for integrating published Adobe Animate CC HTML5 canvas / JS files into a Vue.js component? Appreciate it ...

Designing a sequential bar graph to visualize intricate data using AmCharts

I received the following response from the server in JSON format: [{ "data1": { "name": "Test1", "count": 0, "amount": 0, "amtData": [ 0,0,0,0 ], "cntData": [ 0,0,0,0 ], "color": "#FF0F00" }, "data2": { ...

Regularly check in with the server via ajax calls

I have a page that needs to send periodic "background" ajax requests after it is loaded. These requests should be sent at specific time intervals. Would using cron be the best option for this task, considering that I have never used it before? Are there a ...

Removing punctuation from time duration using Moment.js duration format can be achieved through a simple process

Currently, I am utilizing the moment duration format library to calculate the total duration of time. It is working as expected, but a slight issue arises when the time duration exceeds 4 digits - it automatically adds a comma in the hours section (similar ...

What could be the reason for Vue's ref not functioning properly with Set data type, but working perfectly fine with integer

There seems to be an issue with the watch function when using Set, but it works fine with int. Switching from ref() to reactive() resolves the problem. Is this behavior expected? <script setup> import { ref,watch,reactive } from 'vue' cons ...