Surprising behavior experienced with Angular alert functionality

I'm currently delving into the world of Angular and came across a puzzling issue that caught my attention. To simplify the problem, I created a concise example as the original code was considerably longer.

Desired Outcome:
I envision a scenario where a user inputs a name. If the name matches "error", it should change to red color and trigger an alert. Upon dismissing the alert by clicking 'ok', the name should revert to "initial name" and return to the color green.

Current Behavior:
Despite the intention, when the name switches to "error", the color doesn't change to red as expected.

https://i.sstatic.net/D4RYi.png

Code:

<html   lang="en-US" ng-app="myApp" ng-controller="myCtrl">
<script src="http://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/angularjs/1.3.14/angular.min.js"></script>
<body>
    <div>
        <input ng-model="name" ng-style="{color: myColor}"/>
    </div>
</body>

<script>
    var app = angular.module('myApp', []);
    app.controller('myCtrl', function($scope, $document) {
        $scope.name = "initial name";
        $scope.myColor = "green";
        $scope.$watch('name', function() {
            if($scope.name === "error") {
                $scope.myColor = "red"; // Why does this line not work?
                alert("Not allowed! Resetting...");
                $scope.name = "initial name";
            } else {
                $scope.myColor = "green";
            }
        });
    });
</script>

It's perplexing that altering $scope.myColor doesn't lead to a color change (removing the else-clause retains the red color indefinitely). It appears that the alert is somehow hindering the intended functionality. Even reshuffling the lines within the if-clause didn't bring any resolution.

Question:
Are there any experts who can shed light on why "error" fails to switch to red?
(I'm not necessarily seeking a fix; I'm just keen on understanding the underlying cause.)

Answer №1

alert() is a function that temporarily halts the execution of other code until it is closed. This means that even though the color of $scope.myColor is changed to red, the alert will appear before the change is visually applied. Once the alert is dismissed, the color will return to its original state.

Because these actions occur almost instantaneously, it may be difficult to notice the color change. To make it more noticeable, you can add a 1-2 second timeout to the alert so that the red color is briefly visible before the alert appears.

Answer №2

Like mentioned by others, using the alert function will pause all processing until the alert is dismissed. If you prefer a more seamless solution, you can consider utilizing a $modal component from ui-bootstrap. However, if you must use the alert function, you can employ setTimeout/$timeout to ensure the alert pops up at the start of the next $digest cycle.

$timeout(function() {
  alert('Hey there!')
}, 0)

Keep in mind that the execution order may not be guaranteed with this method. It's advisable to follow the suggestions of using ui-bootstrap or a similar alternative for a smoother user experience.

Answer №3

alert is causing all script execution to halt prematurely, triggering before a digest cycle can finish.

It is not advisable to utilize this function in an angular application as it operates differently within the framework compared to a standard webpage.

Instead, I recommend implementing a custom alert system using JavaScript. There are several angular modules designed for this purpose that you can explore.

Answer №4

By updating the value to red within the watch function and then immediately changing the name, the watch callback on the name will be triggered again, reverting it back to green. While you may anticipate the text to remain red while the alert is displayed, the fact that you are still within the watch function and the digest cycle is paused due to the alert means you will not see this change reflected.

Answer №5

Angular takes a unique approach by not continuously monitoring all the fields within the $scope. Instead, it periodically executes the $digest function. This occurs after the completion of the body of the $watch function.

For example, if you modify a field, display an alert, and then close the alert, Angular will update the field, trigger $digest, and subsequently restart the function once more.

Answer №6

Angular seems to mimic real-time behavior by storing changes to monitored variables and then applying them to the display. Within a $watch function, changes cannot be immediately applied as the code must finish executing, but an alert can disrupt this process. For more information, refer to:

A potential solution to this issue is demonstrated below:

<html   lang="en-US" ng-app="myApp" ng-controller="myCtrl">
<script src="http://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/angularjs/1.3.14/angular.min.js"></script>
<body>
    <div>
        <input ng-model="name" ng-style="{color: myColor}"/>
    </div>
</body>

<script>
    var app = angular.module('myApp', []);
    app.controller('myCtrl', function($timeout, $scope, $document) {
        $scope.name = "initial name";
        $scope.myColor = "green";
        $scope.$watch('name', function() {
            if($scope.name === "error") {
              $timeout(function(){
                $scope.myColor = "red"; // This line has no effect?
                alert("Not allowed! Resetting...");
                $scope.name = "initial name";
              });
            } else {
                $scope.myColor = "green";
            }
        });
    });
</script>

Answer №7

One reason behind the behavior described in the scope lifecycle is due to dirty checking.

When you assign $scope.myColor = "green"; in your $watch function, it triggers a change in the model which then leads to a $digest cycle. The alert() function pauses the processing before the $digest cycle can be completed.

https://docs.angularjs.org/guide/scope

Following the evaluation of the expression, the $apply method initiates a $digest cycle. During the $digest phase, the scope reviews all the $watch expressions and compares them with their previous values. This process of dirty checking takes place asynchronously. As a result, an assignment like $scope.username="angular" does not immediately trigger a $watch notification, but instead, the notification is postponed until the $digest phase. This delay is beneficial as it combines multiple model updates into a single $watch notification and ensures that no other $watches are running during the notification. If a $watch changes the model's value, it necessitates an additional $digest cycle.

Answer №8

At times, Angular may not digest as expected and a manual digest cycle needs to be enforced.

This can be achieved by utilizing

$timeout(function(){
    //Your content here
});

Alternatively, you can also use

$scope.apply(function(){
    //Your content here
});

However, it is important to note that the last method is not recommended as it may result in triggering exceptions such as "digest already in progress."

I have created a working example of your code on Plunker: plunker

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Load live data based on tab selections in AngularJS

I am looking to bind data when a tab is clicked and display it in a shared div for all tabs. For example: <ul><li>Tab1</li><li>Tab2</li><li>Tab3</li></ul> <div id=tabsdata>Data will be bound here usin ...

JavaScript image sorting function fails to sort multiple ID elements that match

Currently, I am working on a project to develop an image sorter using toggle buttons. However, I have encountered an issue where my function is only effective for the first image ID and not any others. Below is the JavaScript function in question: functi ...

Every time Jquery tries to retrieve cookies, it consistently returns as undefined

Having trouble accessing Application cookies using jquery in my Asp.Net MVC App. Check out this Screenshot of Cookie and its Value. I've been trying to access the Cookie with $.cookie('ASP.NET_SessionId'); but it keeps returning "undefined" ...

What is the correct way to show a PHP script as an HTML page following an AJAX call?

Attempting to utilize AJAX to call a php file that will display an html page from my js. Below is the php file in question: <!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en"> <head> <meta charset="UTF-8"> <meta http-equiv=& ...

The corresponding Javascript method for jquery's ajaxStop

Currently, I have numerous ajax requests running concurrently and I would like to trigger a function once they all have completed. I came across the jQuery function: ajaxStop(), however, I am unable to utilize jQuery in this particular project. Is there ...

PHP script is not successfully receiving the Ajax post request that is

As a newcomer to the world of php and ajax, I am facing a challenge in passing a variable from jquery to a php page loaded within a modal window. My php script fetches table information for multiple users. Next to each user's name, there is an edit b ...

"Sorting function malfunctioning when applied to a column populated with values retrieved from a service

While displaying basic personal information in a table and sorting the rows using the orderBy function, I encountered an issue with one specific column. This column's value is retrieved from a service, and when I try to resort the rows by clicking on ...

What is the process for determining the text direction of a website's title?

My website is having trouble displaying the title in the correct direction. I've attempted to add dir="rtl" to various tags like html, head, and title, but nothing seems to be working. In the English version I have "Select a service:" In the Arabic ...

Unlocking request header field access-control-allow-origin on VueJS

When attempting to send a POST request to the Slack API using raw JSON, I encountered the following error: Access to XMLHttpRequest at '' from origin 'http://localhost:8080' has been blocked by CORS policy: Request header field acces ...

When a user clicks on a React listItem, the information for that specific item is displayed using

As a beginner in the coding world, I am currently learning about React and JSON. My project involves working on three interconnected panels. Specifically, I aim to showcase checklist answers on the third panel. First Panel: Displaying: All the ESN ("46 ...

Steps to retrieve the search box input value and submit it in an AngularJs component using the Enter key

I'm facing an issue where I am trying to fetch the search list using speciesName from a table. However, when I attempt to retrieve the data by pressing the enter key, it is returning an error stating that the input data is undefined. Is there a way ...

Removing OTP user input upon pressing the Backspace key can be achieved through the following steps

I've developed an OTP component but I am encountering two specific issues that are posing a challenge. The first problem arises when I hit the Backspace key - I want the input value to be deleted, followed by automatically moving to the previous inpu ...

What is the significance of `(<typeof className>this.constructor)` in TypeScript?

After inspecting the source code of jQTree, written in Typescript, available at https://github.com/mbraak/jqTree, I came across the following snippet: export default class SimpleWidget{ protected static defaults = {}; ...

Obtain the Key with the Greatest Value from a JSON Object

I'm currently working with data fetched from an API response in an attempt to identify the pitch with the highest speed. Below is a snippet from the API response. { page: 1, total_pages: 4, listings: [ { name: "Zack Greinke", pitc ...

Experiencing unexpected output from Angular model class method

I have developed a user-friendly Invoicing & Inventory management application that showcases a list of invoices for each customer. However, there seems to be an issue with the calculation of the Grand Total function, which I am struggling to rectify due to ...

Choosing a lone column in amcharts 4

Is there a way to highlight just one column and unhighlight any previously highlighted columns in an amCharts 4 Column chart? I've been attempting to adjust the colors of all the columns before highlighting the target column, but it doesn't seem ...

The function cannot be accessed during the unit test

I have just created a new project in VueJS and incorporated TypeScript into it. Below is my component along with some testing methods: <template> <div></div> </template> <script lang="ts"> import { Component, Vue } from ...

Numerous directive references attached to document event

Trying to implement a directive that allows the binding of keyboard actions to elements on a page. Here is the directive: angular.module('app').directive('keyboardAction', keyboardAction); function keyboardAction() { return { ...

Discovering the specific style within an inspect-element and transferring it to a JavaScript file

As a novice in the realm of react/javascript, I encountered a situation where I successfully edited a specific style using the inspect element tool. However, despite my efforts, I struggled to locate the corresponding style within the Javascript file. Ha ...

Ensure that the second y-axis in charts.js consistently shows the 100% tick

I have implemented a scatter chart using recharts and it currently looks like this: The right-y-axis in my chart represents the percentage and is showing the correct values as desired. However, I am looking to make a modification so that the 100% mark is ...