JavaScript now assigns a value of null in place of undefined

When working with JavaScript, it's important to understand that undefined can be reassigned. Because of this, it is recommended to create a self-executing function to ensure that undefined remains undefined. Are there any other values that are loosely equivalent to null/undefined, apart from the fact that null and undefined are definitely ==?

TLDR

In essence, can you safely replace this:

(function(undefined){

   window.f = function(obj){
     if(obj===undefined || obj===null ){
       alert('value is undefined or null');
     }
   }

})();

with:

window.f = function(obj){
  if(obj==null){
    alert('value is undefined or null');
  }
}

If the above code is completely safe, why doesn't the JavaScript community/libraries eliminate the use of undefined altogether and simply use the shorter x == null conditional to check for both null/undefined simultaneously?

EDIT:

I have never encountered someone representing an "unknown value" with 'undefined' instead of null. It seems like these two values are often misunderstood and not used in their original context. Standardizing the comparison to obj==null would benefit efficiency and prevent any reassignment issues. Everything would still work as expected.

var obj={};
obj.nonExistantProperty==null // true

var x;
x==null // true

function(obj){
  obj==null // true
}

The only exception to this rule appears to be when converting undefined/null to an integer. While this scenario is rare, it should still be mentioned.

+(null)==0 while isNaN(+undefined)

Since NaN is the only value in JavaScript that is not equal to itself, some interesting comparisons can be made:

+undefined == +undefined // false
+null == +null // true

Using null as a loose equality using == instead of undefined is safe, unless you plan on converting the value to an integer which is an uncommon scenario.

Answer №1

The concept of abstract equality as outlined in section 11.9.3 of the language specification is responsible for defining the behaviors of == and !=, establishing rules such as:

null == void 0
null == null
void 0 == null

In this context, void 0 serves as a representation of undefined, making it clear that null is considered equal to both undefined and itself, but nothing else.

Specific provisions within the specification state:

1. If Type(x) matches the Type(y), then
     If Type(x) is Undefined, return true.
     If Type(x) is Null, return true.
     ...
2. If x is null and y is undefined, return true.
3. If x is undefined and y is null, return true.
...

To avoid ambiguity around the meaning of undefined, utilizing void 0 offers a consistent approach.

null               ==  void 0           // True
({}).x             === void 0           // True
"undefined"        === typeof void 0    // True
(function () {})() === void 0           // True
(undefined = 42,
 undefined         === void 0)          // False
"undefined"        === typeof undefined // False
"undefined"        === typeof void 0    // True

Referencing the official language documentation:

11.4.2 The void Operator

The execution of UnaryExpression : void UnaryExpression is detailed below:

  1. Determine expr as the outcome following UnaryExpression.
  2. Invoke GetValue(expr).
  3. Return undefined.

Hence, the void operator generates undefined regardless of any modifications made to the global variable undefined.

EDIT: In light of feedback received,

When dealing with library functions that draw distinctions between null and undefined, understanding and addressing the variance becomes crucial. While newer libraries now treat them interchangeably (

JSON.stringify([void 0]) === "[null]"
), legacy code often treats them differently:

+(null) === 0
isNaN(+undefined)

"" + null === "null"
"" + undefined === "undefined"

For developers creating libraries involving text manipulation or data serialization, normalizing input values to either null or undefined is necessary to ensure consistent behavior.

Answer №2

JavaScript stands out from other languages due to its unique handling of values like undefined and null. While some languages may only have a single representation for absence of value, JavaScript distinguishes between the "unknown value" of undefined and the explicitly stated lack of value with null.

Consider the scenarios where a variable like x being undefined versus a variable like y being assigned as null. This distinction is fundamental in JavaScript's core principles. Other instances include:

  1. A missing or deleted property results in undefined, not null.
  2. Unassigned function parameters default to undefined.
  3. undefined returned from standard functions like getElementById. Refer to comments.

Hence, in JavaScript, using undefined instead of null is often more appropriate. They signify different states. A library that challenges this concept is essentially challenging the essence of JavaScript itself.

Happy coding.


Personally, I tend to avoid explicit checks for undefined or null in most cases. I believe that in general, all false values should be treated equally, and it is up to the caller to adhere to the specified contract.

While some may view comparisons like x == null as overly cautious yet inadequate, catching both null and undefined can prove useful. Perhaps this approach could become a new trend ;-)

Answer №3

Consider the following scenario:

let variable1;
let variable2 = null;

if (variable1 === null) console.log('variable1 is null');
if (variable1 === undefined) console.log('variable1 is undefined');
if (variable2 === null) console.log('variable2 is null');
if (variable2 === undefined) console.log('variable2 is undefined');

It's important to note that setting a value to null explicitly defines it as such, rather than leaving it undefined.

Answer №4

After delving into the pages of Javascript: The Good parts, it becomes apparent that only null and undefined hold equivalence in value.

Within the realm of JavaScript exist two distinct equality operators: === and !==, accompanied by their malevolent counterparts == and !=. The former operate as expected, yielding true if operands are of matching type and value for ===, or false for !==. On the contrary, the latter siblings attempt coercion when dealing with mismatching types, leading to a labyrinth of convoluted rules that often escape memory. A plethora of intriguing scenarios arise:

'' == '0' // false
0 == '' // true
0 == '0' // true
false == 'false' // false
false == '0' // true
false == undefined // false
false == null // false
null == undefined // true
' \t\r\n ' == 0 // true

"JavaScript: The Good Parts" authored by Douglas Crockford, bearing the copyright of 2008 Yahoo! Inc., under ISBN 978-0-596-51774-8.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

How do I navigate to a different page in Vue.js HTML based on user selection?

Here is my first attempt at writing HTML code: <div class="col-md-4" > <div class="form-group label-floating"> <label class="control-label">Select No</label> <select class="form-control" v-model="or" required=""> ...

Why does the CLI crash when attempting to retrieve all data from an Oracle Database with JQuery?

Trying to utilize JavaScript and Jquery for database search, a generic query.php file has been set up to pass in the database and query, returning an array. Strangely, when attempting to select all using *, the PHP server crashes with: https://i.stack.img ...

Utilizing Regular Expressions in Express.js Routes

Is there a way to extract a specific value from my URL using Express? For example, my URL structure is as follows: host/:value.schema I need to retrieve the value from this URL. Here's an example: host/horse.schema (In this case, the value wo ...

if considering an integer value of 0 as equivalent to null

I am struggling with using axios to send data to an API in react. Despite the server successfully receiving the values, my code is not entering the if block as expected. Interestingly, when I make the same request from a rest client, it works perfectly. He ...

Issue: Catching errors in proxy function calls

I am currently using Vue 3 along with the latest Quasar Framework. To simplify my API calls, I created an Api class as a wrapper for Axios with various methods such as get, post, etc. Now, I need to intercept these method calls. In order to achieve this ...

Is there a way to create a Vue.js component that retains the data I have added to it even when transitioning between routes? Currently, whenever I switch routes, the component deletes all the previously

I'm currently working on a webshop using Vue.js. When I add products, I utilize an event bus to pass the data to the CartComponent. Everything works as expected; however, if I navigate back or reload the page, all the data in my CartComponent gets del ...

Guide on implementing a check all and delete function using the datatables (jquery datagrid plugin)

I am currently utilizing the Datatables jQuery plugin to manage my table rows. While it comes with a tabletools plugin that allows for a checkall function, I am wondering how I can add a custom delete button and retrieve the selected row. Fortunately, I a ...

Guide to incorporating tesseract OCR into a Cordova/Phonegap application

My attempts to use Tesseract OCR with my app have been unsuccessful despite following the instructions provided here. After inspecting the code using Google Chrome Dev console through the WebView, I encountered an error: Uncaught SyntaxError: Unexpected ...

Tips for adjusting an svg component to suit various screen sizes

I inserted the following SVG component into my HTML file. It fits perfectly on my tablet, but it's too large for my smartphone. How can we automatically adjust the size of the SVG to fit different screens? <svg viewBox="310 -25 380 450" w ...

Tips for positioning text on the left and right sides of a div in HTML styling

I am struggling with positioning two pieces of text within a div. Despite having some styling already in place, the text is currently displaying one after the other on the left-hand side. I want to position one piece of text to the left and another to the ...

Issue with Angular 2 (Ionic 2): Struggling to properly display Component within Page

I have successfully created an Angular 2 Component: import {Component, View} from 'angular2/core'; @Component({ selector: 'sidemenu' }) @View({ templateUrl: 'build/pages/menu/menu.html', }) export class Menu { } Howev ...

Trouble initializing Google Maps in an Angular directive

I'm currently working on integrating the Google Maps API into an Angular website, but I'm encountering initialization issues. Within my HTML page, I'm utilizing bootstrap nav nav-tabs and switching between tabs using an Angular controller. ...

Using Three.js BVHLoader in React/React Native applications

I am currently working on developing an application or website for displaying BVH animation. I came across a BVHLoader example in Three.js that I found interesting: BVHLoader example. I am aware that React and React Native can be used with Three.js as we ...

Is it possible to hide and reveal specific form elements based on the selection of a checkbox?

Having issues with the code provided below, it's not working as expected. Can you help me figure out what I might be missing? HTML: <input id="id_code_col" type="checkbox" name="code_col"></input> SCRIPT: $(document).ready(function(){ ...

JavaScript 'this' pointing to incorrect object

Unfortunately, this doesn't seem to be pointing to the correct object in this scenario. I'm having trouble figuring out how to reference the right one. function myObject() { this.someMethod1 = function() { var elementBtn = document.getEl ...

Adjusting specific sections of a container in real-time

Fiddle: https://jsfiddle.net/1b81gv7q/ Sorry for the slightly cryptic title; I couldn't come up with a better way to phrase it. Imagine this scenario: there's a container with content that needs to be dynamically replaced. If I wanted to repla ...

Issue with React form not appearing on web browser

I'm having trouble getting the form to show up on the browser. For some reason, the formComponentDict variable is not displaying any of the form steps. Can anyone point me in the right direction? Any assistance would be greatly appreciated. Thank you ...

Hero Sticky Transition with 100vhDivElement

My code is giving me some trouble. I want the div with text to stay at the bottom of the hero section with a transparent background. When that div reaches the top, it should stick with a black background. The issue is that I have set it in the javascript v ...

Utilize an npm package to transform a CSS file into inline styles within an HTML document

I have an HTML file with an external CSS file and I would like to inline the styles from the external style sheet into one inline <style> tag at the top of the head. Any assistance would be greatly appreciated. Note: I do not want to use the style a ...

Unable to trigger onClick event in React class-based component

I came across the following code for a class-based component: class PostLike extends Component { constructor(props) { super(props); this.state = { likes: null, like_id: null } this.likeSubmit = t ...