Is it redundant to use flatMap in RXJS?

I recently came across an enlightening article on RXJS which delves into the concept of flatMap.
After understanding its purpose - to flatten observable of observables into a single observable sequence (similar to SelectMany in C#) - I noticed an interesting use case where flatMap was employed for a jQuery getJson request:

var responseStream = requestStream
  .flatMap(function(requestUrl) {
    return Rx.Observable.fromPromise(jQuery.getJSON(requestUrl));
  });

While this usage is common and makes sense, it got me thinking, could it be achieved with a simpler approach?: (The code below doesn't function correctly, but it seems like it should logically work.)

var responseStream = requestStream
  .map(function(requestUrl) {
    return jQuery.getJSON(requestUrl);
  });

?

Question

What exactly sets apart these two code snippets?

Fiddle

Answer №1

The code in the second snippet is not functioning as expected because it generates an Observable of promises rather than values. The `map` operator does not unwrap promises that are returned from it.

Therefore, you still require the `flatMap` or a similar operator to unwrap promises. However, you can directly return a promise within it and simplify the code like this:

var responseStream = requestStream
  .flatMap(function(requestUrl) {
    return jQuery.getJSON(requestUrl);
  });

Answer №2

There are multiple questions to address in this situation:

  1. Although the support for promises is currently available, it might not be officially documented and could potentially be removed in the future. To ensure compatibility, consider wrapping every Promise with Observable.fromPromise or a similar method.
  2. It's important to note that internally, flatMap may convert Promises into Observables while map does not. This means that your code snippet may not work as expected because Observables are lazy and require subscription after using the map function to actually execute the Promise.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

What is the best way to create a toggle button that can show more or show less of a text snippet with animation?

Is it possible for someone to assist me with showing a long text partially and providing a "show more" button to reveal the rest, along with a "show less" option, all with some CSS animation? I was thinking of using a font awesome arrow down icon for expan ...

Tips for declaring a particular type during the process of destructuring in Typescript

I have my own custom types defined as shown below: export type Extensions = | '.gif' | '.png' | '.jpeg' | '.jpg' | '.svg' | '.txt' | '.jpg' | '.csv' | '. ...

Trouble with displaying canvas images in imageDraw() function

I'm having trouble with my Imagedraw() method when trying to obtain image data using toDataURL(). var video = document.getElementById('media-video'); var videoCurrentTime = document.getElementById('media-video').currentTime; var ...

How can I combine multiple styles using Material-UI themes in TypeScript?

There are two different styles implementations in my code. The first one is located in global.ts: const globalStyles = (theme: Theme) => { return { g: { marginRight: theme.spacing(40), }, } } export const mergedStyle = (params: any) ...

Learn the ins and outs of utilizing *ngIf in index.html within Angular 8

Can anyone explain how I can implement the *ngIf condition in index.html for Angular2+? I need to dynamically load tags based on a condition using the *ngIf directive, and I'm trying to retrieve the value from local storage. Below is my code snippet b ...

Conceal the object, while revealing a void in its place

Is there a way to hide an image but keep the containing div blank with the same dimensions? I want it to appear as if no content was there, maintaining the original width and height. For example: http://jsfiddle.net/rJuWL/1/ After hiding, "Second!" appea ...

Trouble with recognizing nested functions when calling them in an onClick event

Encountering a `not defined` error on the console when attempting to call nested functions with an `onClick` event in an HTML page. After searching for solutions without success, I suspect it may be a scope or closure issue, but I am unsure of how to addre ...

steps to initiate re-render of rating module

My first experience with React has been interesting. I decided to challenge myself by creating a 5-star rating component. All logs are showing up properly, but there seems to be an issue with the component not re-rendering when the state changes. Thank you ...

Utilizing jQuery for cloning elements

I need to add functionality for adding and deleting rows in multiple tables on my website. Currently, I am doing this by directly inserting HTML code using jQuery, but it has become inefficient due to the number of tables I have. I am considering creating ...

Is it possible to maintain a fixed footer while utilizing async/ajax functions?

Looking for a reliable solution to have a fixed footer that adjusts based on the page content? I've tested multiple samples, but they all fall short when it comes to incorporating AJAX elements. Is there a fixed footer out there that truly works seaml ...

Issue with image magnification on Internet Explorer 9 using the Cloud Zoom plugin extension for Joomla

Recently, I've been utilizing a Joomla plugin called cloud zoom to enhance our gallery by providing an image magnification effect when hovering over the large image. You can see it in action on this link here. While it works flawlessly on most browser ...

Issues with jQuery AJAX functionality

I am in the process of incorporating some ajax functionality into my php website. I have a good understanding of jQuery, but for some reason, the value returned is always empty when I try to alert() it. Below is the code snippet that I am using: PHP: if( ...

having difficulty sending the username and password from the HTML page to the controller in AngularJS

In my AngularJS controller, I am having trouble retrieving the values of the username and password fields after submitting the login form. Here is the HTML code for the form: <form class="form-signin" action="" method="post"> ...

Transitioning from JSTL's forEach loop to angular.js's ng-repeat functionality during the spring season is like switching your

I am just getting started with angular.js. I currently have a spring MVC application and I want to transition from jstl to angular.js. This is how I began the process: <table> <c:forEach var="list" items="${list}"> <tr c ...

transmit JSON formatted form data to an AngularJS platform

I have a webpage built on AngularJS with a login feature. I want to iframe this webpage onto my own page and automatically log in my users. Upon inspecting the AngularJS site, I noticed that the login procedure expects a json object. I have tried multipl ...

Ways to avoid storing repeating paragraphs in JavaScript Array?

Can someone help me with my code? I am struggling to prevent duplicate data from being saved into an array. When I click on any two paragraph elements, the text inside them gets added to an array named `test`. However, I want to avoid saving the same tex ...

Is it possible to trigger JavaScript after loading a page in jqTouch with AJAX?

Similar to the kitchensink demo, I have successfully used jqtouch to call external .html pages into the index page. One of these external pages contains a video that is being played using sublime player. Everything is pretty basic so far, but my challenge ...

Discover the process of integrating PWA features into an Express web application

I'm currently in the process of integrating PWA into a web application. I've created a manifest.json file and added it to the head of my page, which is loading correctly. However, the service worker registered in my app.js doesn't seem to be ...

The <input> element is not functioning as expected when attempting to use it as a button. I am struggling to find the solution to

My HTML file contains: <!Doctype HTML> <html> <head> <title>Orange’s Game</title> <meta charset="utf-8"> <script src="game.js”></script> </head> <body> <input type="button ...

Issues with retrieving information between AJAX and PHP (and vice versa)

I have a script that sends the value of a text input from an HTML form to emailform.php. This PHP file then adds the data to a .txt file. The issue I'm facing is setting the value of $email in the PHP file to match that of the HTML input field. Curren ...