Is it possible for the Redux inside a React component from npm to clash with the Redux in the container?

I am looking to bundle a React component with npm and incorporate Redux to handle state within the component.
If another React project imports my component, will it cause conflicts with the Redux instance of that project?

For example: The component code will be:

// File Explorer Component, packaged as an npm module
import React from "react";
import { Provider } from "react-redux";
import { store } from "./store";
function FileExplorer({source}) {
  <Provider store={store}>
     {/* there will be complex business logic inside */}
  </Provider>;
}

Now, in a separate React project, I import the FileExplorer component from npm

index.jsx

import { StrictMode } from "react";
import ReactDOM from "react-dom";
import { Provider } from "react-redux";
import { store } from "./store"; // this is a different store instance
import App from "./App";

const rootElement = document.getElementById("root");
ReactDOM.render(
  <StrictMode>
    <Provider store={store}>
      <App />
    </Provider>
  </StrictMode>,
  rootElement
);

App.jsx

import FileExplorer from 'file-explorer';

export default function App() {
  return (
    <div className="App">
     <FileExplorer source={'https://example.com/data/v1/files'} />
    </div>
  );
}

Answer №1

I have a couple of thoughts on this issue.

Firstly, it is important to note that if the components nested within <FileExplorer> also require access to the global Redux store of the application, there may be conflicts. This is because all Redux-connected React components typically access the same store instance through React context by default.

However, it is technically feasible to pass a custom context to <Provider> and create personalized versions of useSelector/useDispatch that retrieve data from that specific context:

https://react-redux.js.org/using-react-redux/accessing-store#providing-custom-context

It seems that we currently do not document the procedure for creating customized selector hooks using context.

In fact, React-Redux should export functions like createSelectorHook and createDispatchHooks, as seen here:

https://github.com/reduxjs/react-redux/blob/v7.2.6/src/hooks/useSelector.js#L166

You can use these functions as follows:

const useCustomContextSelector = createSelectorHook(MyCustomContext);

Despite these options, my recommendation would still be to manage state using a useReducer hook by default rather than maintaining a separate Redux store.

Additionally, it's worth noting that you can utilize RTK's createSlice to develop a reducer specifically for use with a useReducer hook - reducers are essentially just functions that work effectively in both scenarios.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Engage in a conversation with a specific individual on the internet using node.js

Looking to implement a chat feature with specific online users similar to Facebook or Gmail using node.js and socket.io. Can anyone assist me with this? Thanks in advance! Client.html <html> <head> <title>My Chat App</title> <d ...

Steps to trigger a JavaScript popup from an iframe window to the parent window

Currently I am developing a web application using JSP with JavaScript. Within the parent window, an iframe is being utilized. The issue arises when a button in the iframe page is clicked, as it opens a popup window within the iframe itself. However, my obj ...

Using Jquery and Ajax to pass an extra PHP variable to a server-side script

I am working with a dropdown select box where the selected option is sent to a server-side script using Ajax. <select id="main_select"> <option selected="selected" value="50">50</option> <option ...

Updating switch data on click using Vuejs: A step-by-step guide

Could someone please explain to me how to swap two different sets of data when clicked? For instance, let's say we have the following data: data() { return { data_one: [ { name: "Simo", ...

What's the best way to add row numbers within ajax requests?

I wrote a function that retrieves values from a form using jQuery's AJAX method: function getvalues(){ var sendid = $('#id').val(); $.ajax({ type: "POST", url: "ready.php", data: {sendid} }).done(function( result ) { $("#msg").html( "worked ...

Executing AngularJS code that returns a promise within an event

In my run function, I am handling the $routeChangeSuccess event. My goal is to use $http to load some data and then change the $template. The issue here is that $http works asynchronously. I have attempted to return a promise inside the event, but it has ...

Communication between different windows using Chrome

I am facing an issue with my HTML5 Framework where the debugger is not visible in fullscreen mode due to the canvas taking up the entire screen. I need a solution where the debugger can be opened in another tab or popup so it can be moved off to another mo ...

What is the proper method for appending a data array to the state array?

How can I add array data to my state array if my array props are: 0 : {name : "David", Age : 32}, 1 : {name : "John", Age : 23} This is my current state: data : [ {name : "Joy", Age : 24}, {name : "Dave", Age : 28 ...

Encountering issues with jQuery AJAX POST request

I'm currently facing an issue while attempting to send a post request to parse JSON formatted data into my webpage. Here's an example of the query: $("#click").click(function () { $.ajax({ type: "POST", url: "http://ut-pc-236 ...

The module ~/assets/images/flags/undefined.png could not be found in the directory

When I use the img tag with a dynamic address filled using require, it works well in the component. However, when I try to write a test for it, an error is thrown. console.error Error: Configuration error: Could not locate module ~/assets/ima ...

Select values to Component from an array contained within an array of objects

Each user possesses a unique list of tags, and every item owned by the user can be associated with multiple tags from this list. In this scenario, I am attempting to display all the tags belonging to a user for a particular item. If the item has a tag tha ...

Reorganizing JSON structures by incorporating unique identifiers into nested elements

I am working on restructuring an incoming JSON object to utilize in a React component. The JSON data that I'm receiving is stored in jsonData. This is the current structure of my code: const jsonData = { "Jonas": { "position": "CTO", "em ...

Error: Unable to access 'map' property of null (TypeError: Cannot read property 'map' of undefined)

Every time I attempt to execute this code, it throws the following error: × TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'map') What is causing this issue? How can I resolve it? import React from 'react'; import Grid from ...

How can you customize the appearance of the Input component that wraps the Select in Material UI for React?

Here is an example of my JSX code: <FormControl> <InputLabel>My label</InputLabel> <Select> ... </Select> </FormControl> When using the classes prop to style elements within the FormControl and Select, I enco ...

I'm encountering an issue in JavaScript while attempting to convert the following string into a JSON object. Can anyone assist in identifying the problem with this string?

How can I correct this string to make it a valid JavaScript JSON object? txt = '{"Categories" : [{"label":"petifores","id":"1"}, {"label":"wedding cake","id":"2"}, {"label":"shapes of cakes","id":"3"}, ...

The v-model in the Vue data() object input is not functioning properly and requires a page refresh to work correctly

Explaining this situation is quite challenging, so I created a video to demonstrate what's happening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=md0FWeRhVkE To break it down: A new account can be created by a user. Upon creation, the user is automatically log ...

What is the functionality of a nested child directive root element when placed at the same level as the parent directive root element?

Hello there, I'm currently facing a unique situation that has me stumped. Is it possible to replace the content of a directive's root element with that of a nested (child) directive? Here is an example scenario: <div id=”main”> <n ...

Having trouble resolving React within the Formik/dist package due to a custom webpack configuration

Struggling to set up projects from scratch, encountering an issue with webpack not being able to resolve formik's modules while other third-party modules like styled-components work fine. I've tried searching online for a solution but couldn&apos ...

I'm encountering an authentication issue while passing an axios configuration object containing an authorization token. Can anyone provide insight on why this is happening? Using

I am currently developing a small social networking application and have implemented a feature for users to like posts. To ensure security, I have set up an authentication middleware as shown below: const auth = async (req, res, next) => { // check he ...

Clearing Input Values in Text Boxes, Dropdowns, and Checkboxes in ASP.NET MVC

Currently, I am working with Asp.net MVC 4 using C#. On one of my pages, I have a Text box, Drop down, and checkbox all together as search filters. There is also a "Clear" button to reset the values. When this button is clicked, I want the textbox value to ...