Is it possible for closures in JavaScript to cause stack fragmentation?

Could the stack become fragmented due to closures being allocated and not deallocated after a function returns?

Closures are essentially stack frames that persist after a function completes execution, similar to a 'stack frame' on the heap rather than the stack itself.

For example, if both foo() and bar() are closures called one after another, is there a scenario where foo()'s closure could be deallocated while bar() still needs space on the stack?

If this process repeats, it could lead to stack fragmentation similar to heap fragmentation, but since stacks work differently, the space would simply be lost. However, this does not seem to occur in practice. What prevents it from happening?

I am particularly interested in JavaScript, where the underlying machine is unknown, but this question applies to any functional language.

To simplify the question...

Consider the code snippet below.

outer = function() {
    var foo = function(v) {
        return function() { return v; }
    }

    var bar = function(w) {
        return function() { return w; }
    }

    var f = foo(5);
    var b = bar(7);
    document.writeln(f());
    document.writeln(b());
    document.writeln(f());
    document.writeln(b());
}
outer();

https://i.sstatic.net/RLYIS.png

Sequence of events: outer() is called. The return address is saved on the stack. Functions like foo, bar, f, and b are hoisted and allocated on the stack when outer() is invoked. When foo() is called with parameter 5, its local variables and the returned anonymous function are also stored on the stack. The same occurs for b and bar. Even though the anonymous function inside foo() forms a closure by referencing an enclosing variable, my main query is: How do we ensure that f and foo() don't get deallocated while b and bar() remain active, potentially causing an empty and inaccessible stack fragment?

Answer №1

Oh boy.

the concept of a closure involves...

Incorrect. A closure actually refers to a function that retains access to its surrounding scope in order to reference variables.

during function execution, a stack frame is created

Correct. The stack frame includes a scope object with declared variables, as well as other necessary information like return addresses. However, not all variables are stored on the stack.

and remains active after the function finishes

Wrong. The purpose of the stack is to pop the stack frame once the function completes its execution.

(almost like having a heap-allocated scope instead of a stack-allocated one!)

It's not merely theoretical; scope objects referenced by closures are indeed allocated on the heap rather than the stack.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Control the line height in DataTables

Is there a way to adjust the line height for a tr using either DataTables settings or CSS? I've attempted different methods, but nothing seems to change the line-height. https://i.sstatic.net/GwFaD.png Table CSS ...

Grunt is designed to generate a single file, instead of producing multiple files

I have a simple Gruntfile that is designed to read a plain text file line by line and create an html file of the same name for each line. However, it seems to only work with one line in the file at a time, not multiple lines. Here is the console output wh ...

The error message "TypeError: undefined in JavaScript Vue's V-for loop

I created a function that generates an array of objects in this format: getMonthDaysGrid() { const totalLastMonthDays = this.getFirstDayOfMonth().dayNumber; const totalDays = this.month.numberOfDays + totalLastMonthDays; const monthList = Array ...

Extracting information from JSON using arrays

I'm facing a bit of a challenge with this one. I've been trying to use jQuery on my website to update an element. It works perfectly fine without using an array of data in JSON, but as soon as I introduce an array of data, it stops functioning. I ...

What is the reason for the maximum alias number in the npm YAML library?

I have been utilizing the npm module yaml to convert complex, interdependent JavaScript objects into a text format that can be easily restored in Javascript. Additionally, I use this package for deep copying of deeply nested objects by serializing and then ...

Nested setInterval in JavaScript refers to the practice of nesting

I am attempting to create nested timed code using setInterval. However, my initial approach does not produce any response from Chrome and Firefox: setInterval(function() { console.log('1'); setInterval(function(){ console.log(& ...

Updating a component with React JS setState() must be done on a mounted or mounting component

I encountered an issue where I am getting the error message setState(...): Can only update a mounted or mounting component., but I am struggling to find a solution. import React, { Component } from 'react'; import Loading1 from '../images/ ...

Ways to modify babel output file extensions

I'm facing an issue where babel --out-file-extension is not working as expected. Below is my package.json : { "name": "Assets", "version": "1.0.0", "description": "", "main" ...

Having trouble with implementing the Drag API Function alongside Javascript Arrow Functions?

I've searched extensively for a similar question but couldn't find one, so I hope this is not a duplicate. Recently, I created a factory function to assist me with drag and drop functionality in my current project. However, I noticed varied beha ...

Accessing a distinct element of e.parameter

I've implemented a Google App Script on my website that automatically writes form data to a spreadsheet upon submission. With multiple forms on the site, I want all their data to go to the same Spreadsheet but different 'Sheets' (tabs at th ...

A guide on creating a clickable polygon in Vue.js using Konva

Is there a way to create an interactive polygon in Vue Konva where I can set each corner with a click? I haven't been able to find any resources other than the v-polygon which only creates predefined polygons. ...

Changes are being made to the state, but the updates are not showing up in the user interface of my photo feed

Welcome everyone, I'm currently immersed in learning react and have developed several apps using react, such as a hotel website (using react and contentful cms), an e-commerce website (using react, contentful cms, paypal), githubfinder app, todos app, ...

Two identical Vue component instances

Is there a way to duplicate a Vue component instance after mounting it with new DOM? I am currently working on coding a template builder and I need to clone some blocks. Similar to the duplicate feature on this website ...

What could be the reason a normalMap fails to render accurately while utilizing THREE.SubdivisionModifier?

When attempting to render a 'soft' cube with a normal map, I encountered an issue. Despite not receiving any errors or warnings while running the code, adding the normal map parameter resulted in a black object when refreshing the browser. Removi ...

Updating the Position of an Element in ElectronJS (e.g. Button, Label, etc)

Is there a way to change the positioning of a button in a window using JavaScript and Electron? I am trying to create new input boxes next to existing ones, but they always appear below the last one created. Is it possible to specify x and y coordinates fo ...

Changing the close button icon in highslide popups

Utilizing highslide together with highcharts, I need to customize the functionality of the close button. Specifically, I want to trigger an additional function when a user clicks on the "X" button. Upon inspecting the "X" button, this is what appears in m ...

What is the best method for validating multiple fields in a form with Javascript?

I am currently working on validating multiple fields within a form. Although I lack experience in JavaScript, I have managed to piece together a code that is functional for the most part. If all fields are left blank, error messages prompt correctly. Howe ...

How can I add a group label to search options in "React Select"?

I have implemented a search/filter feature using react-select for users to search through a list of options. However, I am facing an issue where the group labels are not included in the search. I am now exploring ways to incorporate group labels into the s ...

Guide on embedding PHP/MYSQL array into an independent JavaScript document

I'm looking for guidance on how to insert an array from a PHP MySQL page into a separate JavaScript file. Can someone please help me with indicating where to include the PHP URL and provide the correct format for the PHP array code in order to achieve ...

Tips for altering promises within nested for loops?

Presented below is a complex function that aims to extract model variants from a csv file, which are stored as strings in an array. The path of this csv file depends on information obtained from other csv files, hence the need for looping. The csvService. ...