Is it advisable to continue using a server-side grid or should we make the switch to a JavaScript grid

Currently, there is a lively debate in our workplace about the best way to manage data in a grid.

On one side, some advocate for utilizing Server Side grid functionality that can be easily bound from the server and updated either with Ajax or without. On the other hand, others argue for using solely Javascript to invoke WebService calls to populate a Javascript/HTML grid.

Looking at it from a professional standpoint, which approach would yield optimal results in terms of productivity, testability, and maintainability?

It's worth noting that we are currently working with WebForm .Net 4.0 and JQuery.

Answer №1

In my opinion, JavaScript controls are superior in many ways.
I believe that when it comes to this area, Microsoft, Telerik, and other companies often fall short compared to the open-source community (particularly jQuery-based solutions).

Despite the fact that AJAX and asynchronous requests have been around for a while, it wasn't until recently that Microsoft introduced MVC to properly support them (and there are still some shortcomings).

Another advantage of JavaScript controls is the wide variety available for client-side development compared to server-side options. This allows you to find exactly what you need, and if something isn't included out-of-the-box, being open-source means you can customize it yourself.
Personally, I am using jqgrid and am quite satisfied with its performance.

Answer №2

I found myself facing a similar situation. After some deliberation, I decided to implement a server-side GridView for its simplicity in data binding. However, constantly refreshing the page to update the GridView became cumbersome, leading me to opt for asynchronous post-backs with AJAX update-panels to maintain a seamless user experience.

Answer №3

When it comes to modern web development, Ajax is the way to go. Gone are the days of old-fashioned post backs and full page reloads. ASP.NET MVC eliminates the need for traditional postbacks and simplifies the web form page life cycle.

We find ourselves debating between using DevExpress MVCGridView extensions, Telerik options, or going with a complete javascript solution like ExtJs. While ExtJs offers speed and style, it lacks support for cell merging, which is a crucial feature for our project.

Answer №4

We've had this discussion previously.

One of the advantages of ASP grids is that they come ready to use with sorting, paging, and more without needing JavaScript, which can be a hassle for some. However, using ASP grids can be seen as a less efficient method because it involves unnecessary data fetching processes from the database and rebuilding the page just to sort a column.

Even if you have an UpdatePanel surrounding the grid, there may still be a significant amount of data being transferred over the internet and multiple database queries just to sort or paginate a table.

On the other hand, JavaScript may not look as pretty as ASP grids, but it is much more effective in terms of performance. Sorting (and potentially pagination) can be done quickly on the client-side, decreasing the server's workload. Although this might mean creating custom functions unless you opt for a third-party JavaScript table plugin.

Alternatively, you could stick with ASP grids and enhance their functionality using JavaScript dynamically. This way, your server-side code can continue benefiting from simple binding and table creation.

Currently, we are sticking with the default ASP grids. If performance issues arise later on, we may reconsider our strategy. Nevertheless, for now, when speed and minimal complications are priorities, using the built-in controls is the most efficient approach.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Trouble linking Node.js with SQL Server database

const express = require('express') const bodyParser = require("body-parser") const sql = require("mssql") const app = express() const port = process.env.PORT || 3000 app.use(bodyParser.json()); var cors = require('cors') app.use(cors() ...

Incorporate HTML into the div using AngularJS

Is there a way to pass HTML through in an AngularJS controller? This is the content of my list.html: <div class="col-xs-3" ng-repeat="item in companyData"> <a ng-click="getPackageInfo({{item.iCompanyID}},'{{item.vCompanyName}}')" ...

interactive calendar date selector

I am attempting to implement a personalized dynamic date extra button within the jquery datepicker. Unfortunately, it is not functioning as expected. Could there be an error in my code? $(function () { $(".datepicker").datepicker({ dateFormat: ...

The parsererror occurred while executing the jQuery.ajax() function

When attempting to retrieve JSON data from using the following code: (Using jQuery 1.6.2) $.ajax({ type: "GET", url: url, dataType: "jsonp", success: function (result) { alert("SUCCESS!!!"); }, error: function (xhr, ajaxO ...

Tips for updating the input's current value in React-Select multiple

I am facing an issue with adding the current value in a form for editing. I am using react-select multiple like the image shown below: https://i.sstatic.net/aA6i8.jpg Here is my code: These are the initial values const initialStates = { drugs: ...

Error: An error occurred because the program attempted to read properties of a null value, specifically the property "defaultPrevented"

There seems to be an issue with a script error involving both the bootstrap alert and my own close alert tag. I have a script set up to automatically close alerts after 2.5 seconds when certain user actions trigger them, such as creating a blog post or del ...

A perfectly organized and justified menu with evenly spaced horizontal list items

I couldn't find a solution to evenly spacing out a series of list items for a menu styled list. After realizing CSS alone wasn't enough, I decided to incorporate some javascript (jQuery). My goal was to have equal padding between each LI without ...

I have decided to integrate Laravel with Vite for building CSS and JS. However, when I attempted to run `npm run dev`, it appeared to execute but was accompanied by an error in the background that

Hi there, I'm new to Laravel and I've created a small app that primarily uses CSS and JS scripts. Everything was working fine in my development environment, so I decided to push it to a production server. However, after installation, my code does ...

When attempting to log in, the GetAuthorizationContextAsync(returnUrl) method of the IIdentityServerInteractionService may not

After setting up an Identity 4 app server using a template provided in the documentation, I specified that the database should be prepopulated with 2 standard users. However, upon attempting to log in with any of these users, the page simply refreshes and ...

Having trouble with the submit event listener in vanilla JavaScript

Looking to post a form via AJAX without jQuery involved. The form has an action of "/generate/transaction" and method="POST". After submitting the form, the URL changes to 'localhost/generate/transaction', which is causing an issue. It seems like ...

Activate trust proxy in Next.js

When working with Express.js, the following code snippet enables trust in proxies: // see https://expressjs.com/en/guide/behind-proxies.html app.set('trust proxy', 1); I am attempting to implement a ratelimit using an Express middleware that is ...

Get ready for 10 AM with the RxJS timer function

I am trying to figure out how to schedule a method in my code using rxjs/timer. Specifically, I want the method to run at precisely 10 AM after an initial delay of 1 minute. However, my current implementation is running every 2 minutes after a 1-minute d ...

The JQuery pagination feature fails to function properly once an AJAX load is initiated

I am using jspages.js to implement pagination with jQuery. Everything works fine when the page is initially loaded. However, I encounter an error when the content for pagination is loaded after an ajax call. The plugin does not seem to work as expected. ...

IPAddress.TryParse Returns an Incorrect Location

Here is the code snippet I am working with: string addrStr = "010.000.000.010"; bool parsed = IPAddress.TryParse(addrStr,out IPAddress addr); After parsing, the returned IPAddress is 8.0.0.8 even though TryParse returns true. When I change addr ...

Converting a custom type property to a string with JavascriptSerializerSerialization

For a while now, I have been using the .NET JavascriptSerializer class to serialize my object into JSON for client-side use. Everything works fine with default types like int and string, but now I want to serialize a custom type property in my object. Here ...

What is the best location for storing an individual user's UI configuration settings?

I recently built an ASP.NET MVC app using KnockoutJS, incorporating a data grid which allows for customizable visibility of columns, column sizes, and filter generation in JSON format. This grid also supports remote sorting, filtering, and ordering. User ...

Once the data has been successfully loaded via Ajax, I intend to utilize another Ajax request to switch the image to loading.gif

$.ajax({ type: "POST", url: requestUrl, contentType: "application/json; charset=utf-8", dataType: "json", success: function(data) { for (var i = 0; i < data.posts.length; i++) { ...

Incorporate fresh Google sites into different web pages using iFrame integration

Wishing you a fantastic day! I am currently working on embedding a brand new Google site into another webpage. I attempted to use an iframe for this purpose, but unfortunately it did not work as expected. Here is the code snippet: <iframe width="1280 ...

Customize your Angular UI Bootstrap Datepicker with unique buttons - here's how!

Currently, I have a datepicker with clear and close buttons. I tried using the append function to add more buttons to this datepicker, but it didn't work because the content is not loaded until we click the icon since it's a popup datepicker. Is ...

Finding patterns of different lengths with JavaScript Regular Expressions

Allow me to clarify my question with an illustration: I am extracting page names from a website. The page names vary in length, for example: Data1|Data2|Data3 Data1|Data2|Data3|Data4 Data1|Data2 I need to create a Regex that will work for all of the sc ...