Internet Explorer is surprisingly accurate when it comes to Number.prototype.toFixed functionality

Imagine this scenario:

var x = 2.175;
console.log(x.toFixed(2));  // 2.17

It may seem surprising, but it's actually expected behavior. The Number literal 2.175 is stored in memory slightly less than the actual value due to IEEE-754 rules. This can be confirmed by running:

console.log(x.toFixed(20)); // 2.17499999999999982236

This is the case for the latest versions of Firefox, Chrome, and Opera on 32-bit Windows systems. However, that's not the main focus here.

The real curiosity lies in how Internet Explorer 6 (!) handles this situation more conventionally:

var x = 2.175;
console.log(x.toFixed(2));  // 2.18
console.log(x.toFixed(20)); // 2.17500000000000000000

Intriguingly, all tested Internet Explorer versions (IE8-11, including MS Edge) exhibit this behavior. Quite perplexing, isn't it?

UPDATE: The plot thickens:

x=1.0;while((x-=0.1) > 0) console.log(x.toFixed(20));

IE                        Chrome
0.90000000000000000000    0.90000000000000002220
0.80000000000000000000    0.80000000000000004441
0.70000000000000010000    0.70000000000000006661
0.60000000000000010000    0.60000000000000008882
0.50000000000000010000    0.50000000000000011102
0.40000000000000013000    0.40000000000000013323
0.30000000000000015000    0.30000000000000015543
0.20000000000000015000    0.20000000000000014988
0.10000000000000014000    0.10000000000000014433
0.00000000000000013878    0.00000000000000013878

Why the discrepancies between IE and Chrome? And why no difference in the final one? A similar pattern emerges with x=0.1; while(x-=0.01)...: until nearing zero, toFixed in IE appears to take shortcuts.

Disclaimer: I acknowledge that floating-point math has its limitations. What remains puzzling is the differing behaviors between IE and other browsers.

Answer №1

The behavior that was noted does not align with the ECMA specification's requirements found at this link.

According to clause 8.5 in the specification, the Number type should adhere to the IEEE-754 64-bit binary values, except there is only one NaN. As a result, it is impossible to represent 2.175 exactly; the closest possible representation is 2.17499999999999982236431605997495353221893310546875.

As outlined in section 15.7.4.5, when using toFixed(20), an algorithm is utilized that can be summarized as follows:

  • “Find an integer n where the value of n ÷ 10fx is as close to zero as feasible. If multiple options exist, choose the larger of the two ns.”
  • In this scenario, f is set to 20 (representing the number of digits required), and x represents the operand, which in this case would be 2.17499999999999982236431605997495353221893310546875.
  • This calculation results in opting for 217499999999999982236 as the value for n.
  • Finally, n undergoes formatting, leading to the output “2.17499999999999982236”.

Answer №2

Eric's input is appreciated, but respectfully, it doesn't directly address the question at hand. Admittedly, I may have used some playful language with terms like 'right' and 'amazingly correct,' but I do recognize that Internet Explorer's behavior is indeed unusual.

Nonetheless, my quest for understanding the root cause of IE's unique behavior led me to an intriguing clue - ironically found in Mozilla's bug tracker through this extensive discussion. Here's a snippet from the conversation:

OUTPUT IN MOZILLA: 
a = 0.827 ==> a.toFixed(17) = 0.82699999999999996 
b = 1.827 ==> b.toFixed(17) = 1.82699999999999996

OUTPUT IN IE6: 
a = 0.827 ==> a.toFixed(17) = 0.82700000000000000 
b = 1.827 ==> b.toFixed(17) = 1.82700000000000000

The divergence between IE and Mozilla lies in how they handle values. In IE, 'a' is stored as a string, whereas Mozilla stores it as a numerical value. The specifications don't specify the exact storage format. Consequently, when IE executes a.toFixed, it retains the precise string representation, while Mozilla undergoes additional conversions leading to inconsistencies.

A formal confirmation on this matter would be ideal, but for now, this explanation sheds light on all observed phenomena. This becomes particularly evident in scenarios like:

console.log( 0.3.toFixed(20) ); // 0.30000000000000000000
console.log( 0.2.toFixed(20) ); // 0.20000000000000000000
console.log( (0.3 - 0.2).toFixed(20) ); // "0.09999999999999998000"

Answer №3

First and foremost, it is important to note that Floating points cannot be precisely represented in binary numbers. There will always be a slight elevation or depression in the value, leading to either a slightly higher or slightly lower representation. The extent of this elevation or depression depends on the method of conversion used, making it difficult to pinpoint an exact "correct value" even with ECMAScript's toFixed() output.

The ECMA Standards aim to establish consistency by setting guidelines for implementations. This helps standardize practices and minimize discrepancies across platforms, ensuring that errors are consistent rather than varied.

Therefore, the question arises: why does Internet Explorer deviate from these established standards? To explore this further, let's analyze a series of test cases comparing IE 10.0.9200.16688 and Chrome 30.0.1599.69 on x64 Windows 8 Pro.

Case Code                       IE (10)                        Chrome (30)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A    (0.06).toFixed(20)         0.06000000000000000000    0.05999999999999999778
B    (0.05+0.01).toFixed(20)    0.06000000000000000500    0.06000000000000000472

Interestingly, whether in IE or Chrome, we observe that (0.06) is not equivalent to (0.05+0.01). This discrepancy can be attributed to the inherent representations and very minor errors associated with floating-point calculations. These small errors accumulate during operations, resulting in a slightly different total magnitude error.

The variance in represented values between browsers can be influenced by two main factors:

  • The specific conversion algorithms employed.
  • The timing of when the conversion occurs.

While the exact algorithm used by IE remains undisclosed, the above test cases clearly indicate that IE and Chrome not only handle conversions differently but also execute them at distinct instances.

In JavaScript, when a number (an instance of the Number class, with or without the new keyword) is created, a literal is provided. This literal, although representing a numerical value, is internally treated as a string by the browser. The browser parses the literal, creates the object, and assigns the respective represented value.

Here's where the differentiation arises – IE delays the conversion until necessary, maintaining the number in its original literal or intermediary form until an operation triggers the need for transformation. On the contrary, Chrome promptly converts the number into its operational format upon creation.

Following the completion of an operation, IE retains the calculated value without reverting back to the initial literal or intermediary form to prevent any potential loss in precision.

This explanation aims to shed light on the nuances of how browsers approach and handle floating-point calculations.


[1] Values represented in code are always literals; if enclosed in quotes, they become String Literals.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

The onSubmit function is resistant to updating the state

Currently, I am facing a challenge while working on a form using Material-UI. The TextField component is supposed to gather user input, and upon submission, my handleSubmit() function should update the state with the user-entered information. Unfortunate ...

SweetAlert html is not recognizing ng-app, but it functions correctly within the html body

When inserting a bootstrap table inside a SweetAlert, I encountered an issue where using ng-app or ng-repeat to populate data inside the table's rows did not call ng-app. However, when populating the table outside of the SweetAlert in the body, ng-app ...

Consolidate list: Make sure to leave only the currently active item open

For some reason, I am encountering an issue with this code on this platform. The problem is that every time I click on a list title, all items open up instead of just the one I clicked on. Is there a way to modify this code so that only the clicked item ex ...

What methods with JavaScript, Ajax, or jQuery can I apply to populate the student details?

For completing the StudentID section, please fill out the form data.cfm with the first name, last name, and Middle Name. <script language="Javascript"> $(function() { $( '#effective_date' ).datepicker(); jQuery.validator.addMetho ...

Sending a JSON object as a map through AJAX to an MVC controller

I am looking to send a map (dictionary) to the MVC controller along with a string parameter. var reportName= 'ReportName'; var FilterValues = new Map([ [0, "value1"], [1, "value2"], [2, "value3"], ]); var model = { reportName: reportName, ...

Combining TypeScript and JavaScript for efficient mixins

I came across an article on MDN discussing the usage and creation of mix-ins (link). Intrigued, I decided to try implementing it in TypeScript: type Constructor = new (...args: any) => any; function nameMixin(Base: Constructor) { return class extends ...

The Jquery function for setting the active navigation tab based on the URL is currently over-selecting and choosing more options

I have a customized Jquery function that assigns the 'active' class to my navigation anchors based on the URL. While this function generally works, the issue arises when tab 1 is active - tabs 10, 11, and 12 also get marked as active. The code s ...

Changing the value of a variable in React Native does not reflect in the child component when passed as props

Hey there, I'm facing a bit of a dilemma with this problem. The issue is that I can't use state within navigationOptions. Here's what I've attempted: I initialized my variable let isFilterVisible: boolean = false; In the navigationOpt ...

Error in Function Due to Undefined jQuery DataTable Parameters

In the jQuery datatable column, the below JavaScript code will display either a green checkmark button or a red X button: { data: "HasPayment", render: function (data, type, row, meta) { if (data) { return '<bu ...

Updating Select Options Disabled/Enabled in Angular 2

In my Angular2 project, I have 2 select elements: <div ng-controller="ExampleController"> <form name="myForm"> <label for="companySelect"> Company: </label> <select name="companySelect" id= ...

`How can you utilize typeahead.js to showcase images on your webpage?`

Is there a way to show images using typeahead.js? I am attempting to include profile images in the list generated by typehead.js. Currently, I can only display text in the list as shown below: This is how my javascript appears: Along with my PHP code w ...

The collection is not an array

I am currently running the following code: var n = []; jQuery.toJSON( n ); Interestingly, on one page I receive "[]", while on another I get ""[]"". Both pages are utilizing the same version of jQuery along with a toJson Plugin. Upon inspecting the arra ...

The code functions correctly on JSfiddle, however it is not executing properly on my website

When I tried to implement the code from this jsfiddle link: http://jsfiddle.net/mppcb/1/ on my website (), it didn't work as expected: Here is the HTML code snippet: <form id="myform" novalidate="novalidate"> <input type="text" name="fi ...

Having trouble triggering the onclick event on a dynamically created table using JavaScript

I am facing an issue with adding a table programmatically that has an onclick event triggering a specific JavaScript function using the row's id for editing purposes. Unfortunately, the function is not being called as expected. I have attempted to mod ...

Tips for utilizing the window object in Angular 7

To implement the scrollTo() function of the window object directly, we can use window.scrollTo(0,0). However, when researching how to do this in Angular, I found that many people create a provider as shown below: import {InjectionToken, FactoryProvider} f ...

Issue detected in rxjs-compat operator's shareReplay file at line 2, column 10:

I've encountered an issue with the angular material spinner I'm using in my project. The error message is as follows: ERROR in node_modules/rxjs-compat/operator/shareReplay.d.ts(2,10): error TS2305: Module '"D:/ControlCenter/ofservices ...

activate a specific tab within a tab container using JavaScript

Having an issue with the JavaScript function below that I am using to set active ASP.NET tabs. Whenever I run the code, it always returns CurrentTab as "null". Can anyone help me solve this problem? function SetActiveTab2(tabNumber) { try { ...

Unable to access object key data from JSON-SERVER

I am currently attempting to send a GET request to json-server in order to retrieve data from a nested object. However, the response I am receiving is empty instead of containing the desired data key. After thoroughly reviewing the documentation, I could ...

What is the best way to retrieve the "name" and "ObjectId" properties from this array of objects? (Using Mongoose and MongoDB)

When trying to access the name property, I encountered an issue where it returned undefined: Category.find() .select("-_id") .select("-__v") .then((categories) => { let creator = req.userId; console.log(categories.name) //unde ...

The post request is successful in Postman and cURL, however, it faces issues when executed in Angular

A remote server and a local client are set up to communicate through a simple post request. The client sends the request with one header Content-Type: application/json and includes the body '{"text": "hello"}'. Below is the s ...