Improving the efficiency of JavaScript loops can actually decrease their speed

According to Stoyan Stefanov in his book JavaScript Patterns, he suggests that instead of the common way of looping in JavaScript:

for (i = 0, max = myarray.length; i < max; i++) {
// do something with myarray[i]
}

it can be optimized by using this pattern:

for (i = myarray.length; i--;) {
// do something with myarray[i]
}

Intrigued by this suggestion, I decided to put it to the test by applying it to a performance-intensive loop as demonstrated in this blog post on canvas pixel manipulation. The results of benchmarking the regular code against the "optimized" code can be found here.

Interestingly, the supposedly optimized loop turned out to be slower than the traditional method in both Opera and Firefox. This raises the question: Why did this optimization not result in improved speed?

Answer №1

Micro-optimizations often have a narrow window of effectiveness. Virtual machine implementations are likely already optimized for standard coding practices, surpassing what can be achieved on the language level.

This is why focusing on micro-optimizations is typically fruitless. Novices tend to fixate on them, leading to code that is not only difficult to upkeep but also sluggish in performance.

Answer №2

Many of the strategies for optimizing loops originate from the realm of C programming when compilers were simpler and processors executed instructions sequentially.

However, with modern processors functioning in a vastly different manner, the effectiveness of specific optimizations has dramatically decreased.

In the world of Javascript, there have been rapid advancements. The transition from interpretation to compilation has significantly improved performance. Additionally, different browsers utilize varied compilers that evolve with each version update, creating a dynamic landscape for optimization efforts.

I conducted tests on various loop optimization techniques and found minimal variations in performance: http://jsperf.com/loopoptimisations

Nevertheless, it is clear that traditional loop syntax remains the most prevalent method, prompting compilers to prioritize optimization for this standard approach.

Answer №3

Initially, it is difficult to determine why the second code example would perform significantly faster than the first one. While there may be a slight difference in comparing with zero as opposed to comparing with another number, this variance might only impact extremely tight loops in compiled code. In most cases, it could just be a result of blindly following an optimization trend without fully understanding its functionality.

One scenario where the second code snippet could potentially be slower is when iterating through an array:

for (i = 0; i < myarray.length; i++) {
// do something with myarray[i]
}

However, if the engine optimizes by hoisting the length check or if the comparison cost is minimal, then there may not be any noticeable difference in speed. It's also possible that both examples could be optimized by certain script engines since looping through arrays is a common practice in JavaScript.

Ultimately, performance results may vary depending on the specific browser and JavaScript engine being used. Without delving into the engine's implementation details, it's challenging to pinpoint exactly why one approach outperforms the other in a particular context.

Even though the differences in execution times are marginal, optimizing for popular browsers where improvements are observed can still be beneficial. For historical insight, testing the code on older browsers like Netscape 2, the first JavaScript-enabled browser, could provide valuable insights into performance variations.

As an experiment, deliberately introducing faulty loops that exceed array boundaries could reveal how the engine handles such scenarios. By testing for potential errors caused by incorrect array indexing, you may uncover additional optimizations implemented by the engine.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Tips for activating swf file autoplay on the mobile edition of WordPress

I recently added a swf file to my WordPress page (https://www.pacifictintlv.com/mobile). However, I have noticed that it does not seem to work properly when viewed on mobile devices. Is there a way to redirect users to the Flash download link if they do ...

Struggling to access the "this.array" variable within a TypeScript-powered Angular 4 application

I cannot access the this.array variable in my TypeScript-Angular 4 application. The error is being thrown at this.services.push because this.services is undefined. My code looks like this: export class ServersComponent implements OnInit { //Initializi ...

Passing a variable to a different PHP script

I'm facing a dilemma and need some assistance. I'm encountering an issue where a PHP variable (or JavaScript/jQuery) is not being successfully transmitted to another PHP file through an AJAX request that I set up. To provide context, I am in the ...

GetServerSideProps function yielding varied prop values

I'm currently exploring NextJS and delving into SSR. I've been struggling to grasp the functionality of getServerSideProps(). It seems that it should replace useState in order to be rendered on the backend, but I'm receiving different props ...

Issue TS7053 occurs when trying to access any index of the target of a React.FormEvent<HTMLFormElement>

I've been working on adapting this tutorial to React and TypeScript. Here is the code snippet I have implemented for handling the onSubmit event: const handleSignUp = (event: React.FormEvent<HTMLFormElement>) => { event.preventDefault(); ...

Conceal and reveal content using the caret class

I want to create a feature where a portion of text is displayed from a description field, and then expand to show the full text when a caret icon is clicked. This is my current implementation, which is very close to what I envision: <div class="card-b ...

Create a dynamic prism that adjusts its size according to the distance

I am interested in creating a drawing of an octagonal prism that can also be oblique, with variable face shapes and heights depending on edge lengths. Where should I begin? Is it possible to use a function to calculate the coordinates of base B while cons ...

"Encountering a bug when attempting to load Google Maps while hiding it

I encountered a bug while setting up a google map on a hidden tab. The map is scrollable and zoomable, but it doesn't extend across the entire canvas - leaving the rest of the canvas in grey. Using the jQuery Map Extension (http://code.google.com/p/j ...

Code snippet causing element block JavaScript malfunction

I'm attempting to create a basic automatic slideshow using JavaScript. let currentIndex = 0; startSlideshow(); function startSlideshow() { let slides = document.getElementsByClassName("slide"); for (let i = 0; i < slides.length; i++) { ...

Can I access VueSession in main.js for Vue.js?

In my main.js file, I have set up the following configuration: import Vue from 'vue' import App from './App.vue' import VueRouter from 'vue-router' import Home from './views/Home.vue' import Login from './views/ ...

JEST does not include support for document.addEventListener

I have incorporated JEST into my testing process for my script. However, I have noticed that the coverage status does not include instance.init(). const instance = new RecommendCards(); document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', () => ...

Different option for positioning elements in CSS besides using the float

I am currently working on developing a new application that involves serializing the topbar and sidebar and surrounding them with a form tag, while displaying the sidebar and results side by side. My initial attempt involved using flex layout, but I have ...

Discovering a solution to extract a value from an Array of objects without explicitly referencing the key has proven to be quite challenging, as my extensive online research has failed to yield any similar or closely related problems

So I had this specific constant value const uniqueObjArr = [ { asdfgfjhjkl:"example 123" }, { qwertyuiop:"example 456" }, { zxcvbnmqwerty:"example 678" }, ] I aim to retrieve the ...

Using cellRender in React.js with antd Calendar causes the dates to duplicate in the calendar

element, I have spent time utilizing the antd calendar component to highlight specific days in a light green color on multiple calendars. To achieve this customization, I leveraged the cellRender feature. However, upon implementation, an issue surfaced w ...

The second instance of a React Paginate on the same page remains static and does not trigger a

Having a bit of trouble with using react-paginate for pagination - I have two instances on the same page (one at the top and one at the bottom). When a new prop is received, only the top instance gets re-rendered. The code seems to be working fine as all ...

Tips for changing the visibility of content by combining various Bootstrap 4 display classes

Struggling to figure out a seamless way to toggle the display of a side navigation bar while incorporating multiple Bootstrap 4 display classes due to their heavy use of !important. For instance, consider this div using the display classes that I need to ...

Is it just me, or does Array.prototype.sort() only function properly in Firefox and not

I am currently working on a Next.JS Webapp and I have encountered an issue. Prior to saving my data to a useState object for use in the webapp, I implement this code snippet to arrange an array of objects by a specific date field. person_json[0].events.sor ...

Error: 'require' is undefined in react.production.min.js during production deployment

Greetings! I am encountering some difficulties while trying to build on production: the error "require is not defined" is being caused by react.production.min.js. Below are my webpack.config.js and package.json files: webpack.config.js const path = requi ...

Is it a mistake? Using React and ES6 without Babel may not be the

Have you ever considered bundling all of your classes into a single file without using Babel to polyfill it to ES5? If the browser doesn't support ES6, you could then use Babel in the browser or load the polyfilled bundle and manually add the dependen ...

How can I delete a date value from a td if it matches the current date value?

I'm facing an issue with duplicate date values in my table rows and trying to find a solution using JavaScript or JQuery. The problem cannot be fixed within the SQL query itself, so I need to explore alternative approaches. I want to remove repeated d ...