Dealing with file downloads while using JWT-based authentication protocols

Currently, I am developing a web application using Angular that utilizes a JWT token for authentication. This means that every request must contain an "Authentication" header with all the required information.

While this method works well for REST calls, I am facing a challenge when it comes to handling download links for files stored on the backend server (where the web services are also located).

Traditional <a href='...'/> links cannot be used as they do not carry any header information, causing authentication to fail. The same applies to methods like window.open(...).

I have considered a few possible solutions:

  1. Generate a temporary unsecured download link on the server
  2. Include the authentication details as a URL parameter and handle the situation manually
  3. Retrieve the file data via XHR and save it on the client side.

However, none of the above options seem entirely satisfactory.

As of now, I am using option 1, but I am not fully content with it due to security concerns and the substantial amount of work involved on the server side. Generating a new "random" URL, storing it in a database, and maintaining its validity require significant effort.

Option 2 appears to be equally labor-intensive.

Option 3 involves considerable work, even with available libraries, and presents potential complications such as managing a download progress bar, loading the entire file into memory, and prompting the user to save the file locally.

This task seems relatively straightforward, so I am exploring simpler alternatives that could offer a more efficient solution.

Any suggestions or recommendations would be greatly appreciated, regardless of whether they align with "the Angular way" or involve regular JavaScript techniques.

Answer №1

One method to facilitate client-side downloads is by leveraging the download attribute, the fetch API, and URL.createObjectURL. By obtaining the file through a JWT, transforming the payload into a blob, creating an object URL for it, assigning this URL to an anchor tag, and triggering a click event in JavaScript, you can achieve the desired result.

let link = document.createElement("a");
document.body.appendChild(link);
let fileUrl = 'https://www.samplewebsite.com/some-file.pdf';

let headers = new Headers();
headers.append('Authorization', 'Bearer MY-TOKEN');

fetch(fileUrl, { headers })
    .then(response => response.blob())
    .then(blobData => {
        let objUrl = window.URL.createObjectURL(blobData);

        link.href = objUrl;
        link.download = 'some-file.pdf';
        link.click();

        window.URL.revokeObjectURL(objUrl);
    });

The value of the download attribute will dictate the eventual filename. If necessary, you can extract a preferred filename from the content disposition response header as suggested in various sources.

Answer №2

Methodology

Following guidance from Matias Woloski, a prominent JWT advocate at Auth0, I tackled the issue by crafting a signed request using the Hawk protocol.

In Woloski's own words:

The approach to resolving this matter involves generating a signed request akin to how AWS operates.

For an illustration of this method applied in practice, refer to this resource demonstrating its use for activation links.

Server-Side Implementation

I established an API endpoint for signing download URLs:

Request:

POST /api/sign
Content-Type: application/json
Authorization: Bearer...
{"url": "https://path.to/protected.file"}

Response:

{"url": "https://path.to/protected.file?bewit=NTUzMDYzZTQ2NDYxNzQwMGFlMDMwMDAwXDE0NTU2MzU5OThcZDBIeEplRHJLVVFRWTY0OWFFZUVEaGpMOWJlVTk2czA0cmN6UU4zZndTOD1c"}

By utilizing a signed URL, access to the file is enabled.

Request:

GET https://path.to/protected.file?bewit=NTUzMDYzZTQ2NDYxNzQwMGFlMDMwMDAwXDE0NTU2MzU5OThcZDBIeEplRHJLVVFRWTY0OWFFZUVEaGpMOWJlVTk2czA0cmN6UU4zZndTOD1c

Response:

Content-Type: multipart/mixed; charset="UTF-8"
Content-Disposition': attachment; filename=protected.file
{BLOB}

Client-Side Integration (by jojoyuji)

This streamlined process allows for seamless accomplishment with just a single user action:

function clickedOnDownloadButton() {

  postToSignWithAuthorizationHeader({
    url: 'https://path.to/protected.file'
  }).then(function(signed) {
    window.location = signed.url;
  });

}

Answer №3

A different method from the current "fetch/createObjectURL" and "download-token" approaches mentioned earlier is employing a conventional Form POST that opens in a new window. When the attachment header is read by the browser in the server response, it automatically closes the new tab and initiates the download process. This same technique works well for displaying resources like PDFs in a separate tab.

This option provides enhanced compatibility with older browsers and eliminates the need to handle a new type of token. Furthermore, it ensures better long-term support compared to basic authentication on the URL, as recent changes in browser behavior are phasing out support for username/password in URLs (source).

On the client-side, using target="_blank" prevents navigation even in case of failures, which holds particular significance for SPAs (single page applications).

An important consideration is that for server-side JWT validation, the token must be retrieved from POST data rather than the header. If your framework automatically controls access to route handlers through the Authentication header, you may have to designate your handler as unauthenticated/anonymous to manually verify the JWT for proper authorization.

The form can be dynamically generated and promptly removed to ensure proper cleanup (note: while this can be achieved in plain JS, JQuery is utilized here for clarity) -

function DownloadWithJwtViaFormPost(url, id, token) {
    var jwtInput = $('<input type="hidden" name="jwtToken">').val(token);
    var idInput = $('<input type="hidden" name="id">').val(id);
    $('<form method="post" target="_blank"></form>')
                .attr("action", url)
                .append(jwtInput)
                .append(idInput)
                .appendTo('body')
                .submit()
                .remove();
}

Simply include any additional data necessary as hidden inputs and ensure they are appended to the form.

Answer №4

A JavaScript-only adaptation of James' solution

function downloadFileFromUrl (fileUrl, authorizationToken) {
    let formElement = document.createElement('form')
    formElement.method = 'post'
    formElement.target = '_blank'
    formElement.action = fileUrl
    formElement.innerHTML = '<input type="hidden" name="authToken" value="' + authorizationToken + '">'

    console.log('form:', formElement)

    document.body.appendChild(formElement)
    formElement.submit()
    document.body.removeChild(formElement)
}

Answer №5

My approach would be to create tokens for downloading purposes.

Using Angular, I would send an authenticated request to acquire a temporary token that expires within an hour. This token would then be appended to the URL as a query parameter, allowing flexibility in how files are downloaded (e.g., using window.open).

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Sending parameters to a personalized Angular directive

I am currently facing a challenge in creating an Angular directive as I am unable to pass the necessary parameters for displaying it. The directive code looks like this: (function () { "use strict"; angular.module("customDirectives", []) .directive ...

The term "Call is not defined" suggests that

I am currently setting up my plugin to accept a callback function as an option argument: (function($) { $.fn.MyjQueryPlugin = function(options) { var defaults = { onEnd: function(e) {} }; var settings = $.extend({ ...

Error: Document expected to be found has already been removed

Upon attempting to log into the app, I encountered an error message in the client console (chrome dev tools) that reads as follows: Uncaught Error: Expected to find a document already present for removed mongo.js?69942a86515ec397dfd8cbb0a151a0eefdd9560d:2 ...

The AJAX request is functioning properly, however, when I attempt to click the icon within the button, a 500 internal server error is triggered

Encountering a 500 internal server error specifically when attempting to click the thumbs-up icon within the like button: <button class="submit-btn like" id='{{ $image->id }}'> <i class="far fa-thumbs-up"></i> Like </ ...

Tips for refreshing a nested state in React

Currently, I am facing an issue with updating a nested value in a React state. My goal is to update data that is deeply nested, specifically 3 levels deep. Let me provide you with the state structure that contains the data: const [companies, setCompanies ...

Need help with Jquery JSON Request - I can successfully retrieve the Array but struggling to showcase it

Seeking assistance with using an API that retrieves information about ARK servers, such as the number of online players. The API can be found at this link: ... I have managed to obtain the array using a basic script I stumbled upon, but I am not well-ver ...

Animating the elements inside a nested div container

Just dipping my toes into the world of jQuery, so any guidance is greatly appreciated. I recently encountered a design challenge where I needed to showcase content from one div inside another div upon hovering over a third element. After finding some help ...

The jQuery functionality is not functioning properly within the aspx file

I came across some JavaScript code on stackoverflow that is not working in my own code, but strangely it works perfectly fine in the jsFiddle: https://jsfiddle.net/rxLg0bo4/9/ Here is how I am using inline jQuery in my code: <nav id="menu"> < ...

Breaking the Boundaries of Fuzzy Search with JavaScript

I am currently utilizing ListJS's plugin for fuzzy search. It can be found at the following link: In an attempt to enhance the plugin, I implemented my own method to filter by the first letter of the items in the list. This involved selecting from an ...

AngularJS: Exploring the Depths of Nested Object Loops

{ name: 'Product One', visibility: 1, weight: '0.5', price: '19.99' custom_attributes: [ { attribute_code: 'image', value: '.img' }, { ...

Avoid shifting focus to each form control when the tab key is activated

I have a form where users need to be able to delete and add items using the keyboard. Typically, users use the tab key to move focus from one element to another. However, when pressing the tab key in this form, the focus only shifts to textboxes and not t ...

Having trouble properly sending gender value through javascript/ajax functionality

Within my database, the gender_id attribute is configured as an enum with options ('M', 'F') and M serves as the default selection. Gender Selection Form <div class="col-lg-6 col-md-6 col-sm-12 col-xs-12"> <label>Gend ...

The call to Contentful's getAsset function resulted in an undefined value being

I am facing a challenge while trying to fetch an asset, specifically an image, from Contentful and display it in my Angular application. Despite seeing the images in the Network log, I keep encountering an issue where the console.log outputs undefined. Any ...

When implementing a v-for loop in Vue.js with Vuetify and using v-dialog components, the click event may be overwritten for all v-dialogs except

My app features the utilization of a Vuetify v-dialog within a v-for loop. However, I am encountering an issue where clicking on any chip within the loop triggers the click event for the last v-chip, instead of the specific one being clicked. It appears t ...

Changing Marker Color in Google Maps API

There are multiple Google Maps Markers colors based on certain conditions being TRUE or not. In addition, these Markers will change color when the mouse hovers over a division (a1,a2..ax). I want the Markers to revert back to their original color when th ...

Is there a way to display only the first x characters of an HTML code while disregarding any tags present within

When I work with a text editor, it generates HTML code that I save in the database. On another page, I need to display only the first 100 characters of the text without counting the HTML tags. For instance, let's say this is the HTML code saved in th ...

Creating a promise class in JavaScript

I am in the process of creating a simple promise class with chainable .then() functionality in javascript. Here is my progress so far: class APromise { constructor(Fn) { this.value = null; Fn(resolved => { this.value = resolved; }); ...

What is Express' strategy for managing client IP changes?

Does Express handle client IP addresses when they change, such as when a client is moved away from their original network? I am curious if the value of req.ip remains the same when making a request in one network and then another. If it does change, does E ...

Retrieve items by name using an HTML array

I am dynamically adding new inputs and would like to read values from them dynamically as well. However, I am facing an issue where my championName variable is not working in JavaScript. <form name="second_form" id="second_form" action="#" method="PO ...

Guide to Utilizing Angular Service in SlickGrid Custom Editor

Is there a way to access an Angular service from a custom cell editor in Slickgrid? The following link provides information on creating custom cell editors for Slickgrid. https://github.com/mleibman/SlickGrid/wiki/Writing-custom-cell-editors function IEd ...