Creating a protected pathway using postMessage within an IFRAME for secure communication

Below is an overview of our application. The user interface is sourced from a secure domain , and scripts are hosted on the same domain.

The application loads content from the client site within an IFRAME. Due to concerns about trustworthiness, as the code quality could be lower than our own, we suspect that it may contain malicious XSS vulnerabilities.

In addition, the application also loads a trusted script from our secondary domain . These scripts can call a REST API from aaa.com, requiring a security token for access. This security token is obtained by logging into the UI located at the top window on the aaa domain.

We must establish a secure communication channel to transfer the security token from a private closure in the browser window (scriptA.js) to another private closure in our script within the IFRAME (scriptB.js).

Due to the different domains involved, we need to employ the postMessage API for inter-script communication. Ideally, we aim to pass a securely encrypted message such as "Hey, I am scriptB. Please send me the token encrypted with this key (asymmetric encryption public key generated for this purpose). Let scriptA send the encrypted key so that any malicious XSS attempts to intercept will fail."

However, there is a risk that a malicious XSS attack could impersonate scriptB since it originates from the same domain and therefore may try to intercept the token response.

The main question is how we can ensure that the request message sent from scriptA to scriptB can be authenticated as coming from the script loaded from , and not from an XSS exploit originating from client.com or another domain. Alternatively, are there other secure communication methods that could be utilized to safely transfer the token from scriptA to scriptB?

Do you have any suggestions?

https://i.sstatic.net/UZ60I.png

Answer №1

It is important to alert potential visitors that finding a solution to the specific issue mentioned proved to be challenging. The use of CORS for securing communication poses limitations, particularly when cookies are not used for authorization. Without the presence of cookies, an attacker server can act as a forward proxy and circumvent any CORS protections in place.

Unless postMessage includes the URL of the script (rather than the hosting window), achieving secure communication to prevent XSS attacks from mimicking the target script seems unattainable.

The resolution ultimately relied on a key assumption:

  • Even with a secured token, a malicious XSS attack could still emit keyboard and mouse events to manipulate content as if it were being done by the user.

As a result, the decision was made to encapsulate the initial token within another token, generated by a server API called from the protected scriptA in the parent window context. This new token restricts user actions to only those achievable through genuine user interactions. Upon verification on the server by scriptB, this token is validated.

This approach ensures that even if XSS manages to steal the token from the message, its abilities are limited to simulating user actions through fake keyboard and mouse events. Furthermore, the token has a time limit, preventing the attacker from preserving it for future external data manipulation attempts.

In conclusion, a security vulnerability at the client-side now only compromises the individual single page and does not jeopardize the entire infrastructure.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Hovering over the child element, instead of the parent

I'm working on implementing a highlight feature for my website. The structure of the HTML looks something like this: <div> <!-- this is the main container --> <div> content ... </div><!-- a child element --> < ...

An issue has occurred in AngularJS where the error message "ng areq not

I'm facing an issue with my meta controller, as I am trying to alter the meta tags dynamically. When checking the console, I encounter the error message error ng areq not a function. I have looked on StackOverflow for similar issues but couldn't ...

Efficient File Upload Feature Compatible with all Browsers, Including Internet Explorer versions 7, 8, and 9

Can someone assist me with a problem I'm facing? I need a code script that enables multiple file uploading on all browsers. While HTML5 supports Chrome and Mozilla Firefox, it does not support IE. I am looking for a script/jquery solution that works ...

How can the value be accessed when using getElementById in Angular for <mat-select> elements that do not have a value attribute?

Within a loop, I have an element that has a dynamically generated id: <mat-select multiple class="dw-input" [value]="element.txn_type_id ? element.txn_type_id.split(',') : []" id="field-{{element.Name}}-txn_type_id&quo ...

Eliminate the hovering effect from images that are hyperlinked

I am feeling incredibly desperate as I have spent hours searching the internet for a solution with no success. When it comes to text links, I have included the following CSS code: a:hover img { border-bottom: none !important; } However, this code is als ...

Incorporate an icon into an Angular Material input field

I want to enhance my input search bar by adding a search icon from Angular Material : <aside class="main-sidebar"> <section class="sidebar control-sidebar-dark" id="leftMenu"> <div> <md-tabs md-center-tabs id=" ...

Encountering a dilemma during the docker build process with npm install is frustrating, especially when faced with an error message like: "Invalid response body when attempting

Encountering a docker build issue with npm install that seems to only occur inside the docker environment. The process works perfectly on my operating system Error Step 6/8 : RUN npm cache clear --force && npm install --legacy-peer-deps ---> ...

`initMap` does not exist as a function

Hey everyone, I need some help: I recently integrated the Google Maps API into my AngularJs project and encountered an error in the console: Uncaught message: "initMap is not a function" name: "InvalidValueError" This occurs when the Google Map API is ...

Local storage synchronization in progress, please hold on

Currently, there seems to be a synchronization issue between the local storage and the server. Countries, cities, and users are synchronized with the server separately through different Ajax calls. The problem at hand is that other JavaScript codes (such ...

Troubleshooting automatic login problem in VB 2013 settings

For my application, I am utilizing the most recent version of Awesomium's WebControl. The goal is for it to automatically log in when it reaches "accounts.google.com/ServiceLogin" by executing some Javascript. In my.settings.java file, I have the foll ...

Refreshing a page in Next.js causes query parameters to disappear

I am facing an issue with routing between two components and passing data from the first to the second without sending the parameter in the URL. The problem arises when I refresh the page and the query params are lost. <p className={styles.jobname}& ...

Why is it that I am unable to utilize the post data stored in $var within my PHP document when making an Ajax call?

Hey there! I've got this function that makes an ajax call. But, for some reason, the $value I'm passing isn't defined in my showuser.php file. Can you help me figure out why? function showUser2(value) { var xhr = new XMLHttp ...

Swapping out Material UI icons for Material Design icons

Using material UI icons, I have a camera icon with an AddIcon connected to it. I want to replace the plus sign (AddIcon) with alphabet letters using 'materialdesignicons'. Is there a way to do this? For example, replacing the plus sign with the l ...

Show a variety of pictures using React

Is it possible to repeat an image (e.g. photo.jpg) n times in Reactjs using a provided value for n in props? If yes, how can this be achieved? function Card(props) { for (let i = 0; i < props.rating; i++) { <img className="star" src ...

Tips on handling a redirection request following a fetch post request

When communicating with my node server (Express) using fetch to build a Single Page Application (SPA), I have encountered an issue. Upon each request to the server, I validate the session and redirect to a login page if it is not valid. However, I noticed ...

access the return value of a jQuery function within another function

I'm struggling to retrieve a value from this function, I suspect it may be due to the nested functions. (ps. I am aware that I do not need to use quotes when retrieving a BOOL value) Any assistance would be greatly appreciated. $(document).ready(fu ...

Is it possible for me to initiate an AJAX request to a particular function in a PHP script from a JavaScript file?

I have a JavaScript function that retrieves the latitude and longitude of the user and saves it in an array for future use. My goal is to compare the user's location with multiple other locations stored in a database. I am attempting to achieve this b ...

Creating a Cloudinary Angular URL: A Step-by-Step Guide

Currently, I am utilizing Cloudinart on Angular and my goal is to create a Cloudinary URL. <cl-image public-id="public_id"> <cl-transformation height="270" width="480" crop="fill"/> & ...

Tips for preserving user input from HTML into a text file and then reloading it back into the HTML document

I have recently created a character sheet for a game using HTML. The HTML file is mainly comprised of various input tags such as <input type="text">, <input type="number">, <input type="checkbox">, <input type="radio">, <select&g ...

Experiencing a lack of content in an Express response

Currently utilizing express to manage a POST request, but encountering an issue when sending the body using node-fetch. After sending the body and logging it in express (server-side code), I am seeing an empty object. The reason behind this behavior remain ...