Could this method effectively protect against Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) attacks?

Our application operates in the following manner:

  • Each user is required to log in
  • The login page sends a request back to the server and returns a Single Page Application (SPA) if the user is authorized
  • The SPA is fully AJAX-driven
  • Operates over HTTPS

Typically, we would set a sessionid cookie and a csrftoken cookie. The token value of the cookie would be included as an x-header in any AJAX posts, with verification taking place on the server for every request.

Since the SPA page is constructed prior to being sent to the browser, we have flexibility in embedding additional information into it. We want users to be able to log in on multiple tabs without affecting one another.

Here's our preferred method:

  • Send the sessionid as a uniquely named cookie, similar to before
  • No csrftoken required, but instead embed the unique cookie name within the JavaScript routine that adds the x-header to AJAX post requests
  • The server can extract the sessionid from the x-header

This approach allows for multiple logins, where each login has a distinct sessionid cookie name, while maintaining a consistent x-header name for all post requests.

Do you think this method is as secure as the sessionid cookie combined with the csrftoken cookie/x-header approach?

Answer №1

Indeed, one way to enhance security is by including a header that cannot be replicated by an attacker in a valid user's session.

For instance, you can include X-Requested-With in each AJAX request (JQuery typically does this automatically) and then verify the presence of this header on the server side when receiving the request. This particular header cannot be transmitted across domains unless explicitly permitted by the server through CORS.

To further bolster security measures, you may also consider integrating a token - for more information, check out this answer.

Example:

X-Requested-With: XMLHttpRequest;0123456789ABCDEF

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Is it possible to adjust the width of the comment box on the Facebook "Like" button?

Is there a way to set the width of the comment box that appears after clicking the Facebook "Like" button? I know how to adjust the width of the button itself and related content, but can't find any options for the comment box: I've tried overri ...

How to deal with simultaneous calls to .save() in TypeOrm within an Express API environment

One issue I encountered is that my frontend needs to fetch both /users/:userId/profile and /users/:userId/profile-small simultaneously in order to display two profiles. When the user is not cached in the database, the .save(user) function will be called tw ...

Upon the initial rendering, Next.js obtains access to the query { amp: undefined }

When using Next.js 9.3, I encountered an issue where I needed to access the query on initial render and pass the result of the query to next/head in order to change the title and description of the page. The component is receiving the query from the useRo ...

What is the best way to define one API route that accommodates two different query combinations?

Is it possible to define 1 API route with 2 different query combination options? We have 2 routes: GET /api/v1/resource?filter=byName&key=restaurant&city=chicago GET /api/v1/resource?filter=byLocation&lat=34&long=78 In soaJS, schema ...

Tips for achieving a seamless transition between elements of varying heights in your Bootstrap carousel

I'm currently working on a Bootstrap carousel project with slides of varying heights. The transition animation between slides is quite choppy due to the different sizes of content. I'm looking for a solution to make the transition smoother and mo ...

After initializing the controller and postLink, ensure to reset the scope variable in the directive

I have created a basic directive: angular.module('app').directive('field', function () { return { restrict: 'E', template: '<div ng-click="clickElement()"><input id="{{inputId}}"></div& ...

Incorporating Jest alongside setTimeout and leveraging useFakeTimers

As I work with a TypeScript async function that requires a 1-second sleep between two statements, this implementation is in place: async function systemUnderTest(): Promise<void> { console.log("One"); await new Promise(r => { set ...

Tips for transforming an Observable stream into an Observable Array

My goal is to fetch a list of dogs from a database and return it as an Observable<Dog[]>. However, whenever I attempt to convert the incoming stream to an array by using toArray() or any other method, no data is returned when calling the retrieveDo ...

Showing no background color until the user lifts their finger

I am currently in the process of developing a website. The navigation on the website starts off as transparent (background: transparent) when opened, but as soon as you start scrolling, it should transition to a colorful state with shades like grey, midnig ...

Regular expression is used to limit input to integers only, specifically numbers between -130 and 30

Completed the regex for 0 to 50 ^(?:[1-9]|[1-4][0-9]|50)$ The current regex is functioning correctly. Next step is to create a regex that includes negative numbers, allowing for values between -130 and 30 without any decimal points. ...

Struggling with the nodejs peepcode tutorial - need some help getting it to run

After purchasing and following the latest nodejs peepcode tutorial, I have hit a roadblock at the initial step. I have spent hours trying to debug my code, but tracing errors in nodejs seems like solving a riddle to me. My app structure is as follows: e ...

Diving into Redux brings up the question of whether to use a generic reducer or a

When working with Redux, what is the preferred approach: Creating entity-specific reducers or utilizing a generic reducer based on strict action keying conventions? The former can result in more boilerplate code but offers loose coupling and greater flexib ...

Activating/diverting DIV elements through specific functions (on a WordPress website)

I have a stronger background in HTML and CSS, but I'm struggling with coding the functionality I want to see on a WordPress page. My goal is to create a page that displays upcoming events for a specific province or region of Canada, with an interactiv ...

Tips for encoding ParsedUrlQuery into a URL-friendly format

Switching from vanilla React to NextJS has brought about some changes for me. In the past, I used to access my URL query parameters (the segment after the ? in the URL) using the useSearchParams hook provided by react-router, which returned a URLSearchPara ...

What happens when you click and trigger mouseleave?

window.onload = function() { $(".compartir").hover(function() { console.log('hover'); var self = this; setTimeout($(self).addClass('ready'), 500); }, function() { var self = this; console.log('leave'); ...

Using Python and Selenium to manipulate the webpage and execute JavaScript can help reconstruct the true HTML structure

I have a very basic Selenium code snippet that I am running: <input name="X" id="unique" value="" type="text"> <script> document.getElementById("unique").value="123"; </script> While I can retrieve the input value "123" using driv ...

JavaScript to adjust the size of a div

I have a hidden div in my JSP code that I want to move from one tab to another tab based on the onclick event of the tabs. <div id="addprojectname" style="-moz-border-bottom-colors: none; -moz-border-left-colors: none; -moz-border-right-colors: ...

Update the information within a div at regular intervals on a Django template

I am trying to update the comments displayed on my webpage at regular intervals. Despite referencing a question, the data remains static and only changes upon page refresh. Below is my code snippet from views.py def index(request): count = Article.ob ...

Error encountered in TypeScript's Map class

When working with TypeScript, I keep encountering an error message that reads "cannot find name Map." var myMap = new Map(); var keyString = "a string", keyObj = {}, keyFunc = function () {}; // assigning values to keys myMap.set(keyString, "val ...

Ways to refresh the DOM while making an asynchronous request

Consider the following async function: async function predict_from_model() { $("#loading").html("first update") const model = await tf.loadModel('model.json'); $("#loading").html("second update") //delayed for (var i = 0; i < 100; i++ ...