Contrasting v-on:click and onclick in Vue.js

Can you explain the distinction between v-on:click="..." and using onclick="..." in Vue.js?

I am aware that with v-on:click, the handler must be written inside the Vue object (as shown in the documentation example), but what are the benefits of this approach? It seems equally simple to just use onclick="..." to invoke a function (outside of the Vue object).

Answer №1

One of the main distinctions lies in the scope access. The scope bound to `onclick` is global, requiring the functions it calls to be accessible from the global scope. On the other hand, `v-on`'s scope is the Vue model.

Another notable feature is Vue's user-friendly API for defining custom events using `vm.$emit()`. It is also straightforward to listen for these events by using `v-on:customevent="callback"`, which can be easily related to a hypothetical `onfizz="callback()"`.

Considering this, it would be logical to introduce `v-on:click` for a consistent API alongside the other extensions offered by `v-on`.

/*
 * This pollutes scope.  You would have to start
 * making very verbose function names or namespace your 
 * callbacks so as not collide with other handlers that
 * you need throughout your application.
 */
function onClickGlobal() {
  console.log("global");
}

const fizzbuzz = {
  template: "<button @click='onClick'>FizzBuzz</button>",
  methods: {
    onClick() {
      this.$emit("fizz");
    }
  }
};

const app = new Vue({
  el: "#app",
  components: {
    fizzbuzz
  },
  methods: {
    onClickModel() {
      console.log("model");
    },
    onFizz() {
      console.log("heard fizz");
    }
  }
});
<script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/vue/dist/vue.min.js"></script>

<div id="app">
  <section>
    <h2>Buttons and Clicks</h2>

    <!-- Calling function of the bound scope -->
    <button @click="onClickModel">v-on Model</button>
    <!-- Works as well, but calls the global  -->
    <button @click="onClickGlobal">v-on Global</button>

    <!-- You need to explicitly invoke the function from onclick -->

    <!-- This won't work because onClickModel isn't global -->
    <button onclick="onClickModel()">onclick Model</button>
    <!-- Works because onClickGlobal is global -->
    <button onclick="onClickGlobal()">onclick Global</button>

    <!-- You can technically call onClickModel through the global app -->
    <!-- but you really shouldn't -->

    <!-- Works because app.onClickModel is technically global -->
    <button onclick="app.onClickModel()">onclick Global through app.onClickModel</button>

  </section>
  <section>
    <h2>Custom Events</h2>
    <fizzbuzz @fizz="onFizz"></fizzbuzz>
    <!-- The element below doesn't work -->
    <button onfizz="onClickGlobal">Hypothetical Fizz</button>
  </section>
</div>

Answer №2

When considering the scope, the advantage becomes clear. To address your query regarding its benefits:

There is no added value if you confine its use within a small scope. However, if you intend to incorporate it into another project that already contains JS components, you may encounter issues with conflicting global functions. By keeping everything within the component itself, these concerns are eliminated entirely.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Transforming various date formats into the en-US format of mm/dd/yyyy hh:mm:ss can be accomplished through JavaScript

When encountering a date format in en-GB or European style (mm.dd.yyyy), it should be converted to the en-US format (mm/dd/yyyy). If the date is not already in en-US format, then it needs to be converted accordingly. ...

Changing Highcharts Donut Chart Title Text via Legend Item Click in React

Utilizing React. In my Highcharts donut chart, there are 5 legend items of type 'number' and a 'title text' (also type: number) displayed at the center. The title text represents the sum of all the legend items. However, when I click o ...

Locate a specific sequence of characters within an array of objects using JavaScript

I am working with an array of objects, where each object contains a string value. My task is to search for a specific substring within the string. [ { "link": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1702510/000170251022000084/00 ...

Is it possible for me to avoid html tags inside a class without using the xmp tag?

There are a few ways to approach this question. It's important to decide which method will be most beneficial for your specific needs... Is it possible for JavaScript to recreate the deprecated <xmp> tag using an "xmp" class? Can we replicate ...

Error message in Angular when promises are not defined

Recently, I started working with promises for the first time. I have a function that returns a promise: public DatesGenerator(futercampaign: ICampaign, searchparam: any, i: number): ng.IPromise<any> { return this.$q((resolve, reject) => { ...

What is the best way to create a smooth sliding effect using CSS?

Need help with creating a transition effect within a bordered div that reveals hidden content when a button is clicked? I'm looking to have the <a> tag displayed after clicking the button, with both the button and text sliding to the left. Here& ...

Error: The object being referenced (scope.awesomeThings) is undefined and unable to be evaluated

Each time I run the grunt test command, I encounter this error. I set up a project using yo angular and attempted to execute the example code provided in Yeoman's scaffold. Something seems to have gone awry here - below is the code snippet that I trie ...

How can you navigate a self-referencing one-to-many table in Sequelize to find the parent, the parent of the parent, the parent of the parent of the parent, and

I have a model called DriveObject, which has a self-referencing foreign key named parentId For the backend, I am utilizing express and node.js In my code, I have defined the association as follows: driveObject.hasMany(driveObject, { as: 'Children&ap ...

What is the best way to trigger the keyup event in that moment?

Currently, I am using regex to validate the name field. Each time a key is pressed, a validation function is triggered. If the input matches the regex pattern, I need to empty out that specific character from the input field. However, when previewing the p ...

What is the reason behind the content of a div tag not hiding while the content of a p tag does

<html> <head> <title>How to make a div content disappear when clicked?</title> <meta charset="UTF-8"> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"> <scrip ...

Capture and transform every alert into a notification

I have implemented Gritter for notifications across my website and am curious if there is an easy method to intercept all alert() messages triggered by scripts using jQuery, and then display the contents of the alert in a Gritter notification. Is there a ...

Summernote information embedded with HTML elements

I just started using the summernote text editor and I'm trying to figure out how to extract the content from the textarea without all the HTML tags. This is what I have in my code: <textarea class="summernote" id="summernote" ng-model="blog.c ...

Steps for removing routing in Angular 2 after setting the folder as a dependency for another project

In my testing Angular project (referred to as project1), I am developing components and utilizing routing for organizational and aesthetic purposes. There is another Angular project (referred to as project2) which includes the component project-project1 i ...

Neglecting to send a socket signal while assigning a variable to a socket message

In my client-side script, I am using the following snippet: socket.on('bla', function(data) { if (data == ID) { console.log('I don't understand what's happening here.'); } }) socket.on(ID, function(data) { ...

Changing the positions of objects on a resized HTML Canvas

I am currently developing a tool that allows users to draw bounding boxes on images using the Canvas and Angular. Everything was working smoothly until I encountered an issue with zooming in on the canvas causing complications when trying to draw bounding ...

Guide to encapsulating an angular material form within a component and making it accessible to the FormGroup as a formControl property

My goal is to create a custom component (let's call it custom-input) that acts as a formControl element using Angular material components. It should include the following structure: <mat-form-field > <input matInput [formControl]=" ...

Disabling the submit button after submitting the form results in the page failing to load

I am encountering an issue with my HTML form that submits to another page via POST. After the form validates, I attempt to disable or hide the submit button to prevent double submission and inform the user that the next page may take some time to load. He ...

Mocha test failing to trigger function execution

I've been developing an Express.js application that includes a feature for creating appointments with a post request. This feature involves retrieving and saving data from a third-party API, followed by sending updated API data in the subsequent reque ...

Issue with Discord.js: Newly joined user's username appears as undefined

robot.on('guildmateEntry', person =>{ const greeting = new Discord.MessageEmbed() .setTitle(`Greetings to the realm, ${individual}!`) const room = person.guild.channels.cache.find(channel => channel.name === " ...

Ensuring uniform sizing of anchor text using jQuery

My goal is to creatively adjust the font size of anchor text within a paragraph, making it appear as though the text is moving towards and away from the viewer without affecting the surrounding paragraph text. Currently, I am encountering an issue where th ...