Contrasting runtime.sendMessage and port.postMessage operations

Currently, I am in the process of developing a Chrome extension and planning to incorporate message passing between my background page and content script. This will involve three messages exchanged in a synchronized order (content -> background -> content -> background).

I find myself uncertain about which message passing API to use for this task as I lack clarity on the distinction between the Port API and the standard chrome.runtime API. Are there any limitations with using runtime.sendmessage that could be resolved by switching to Port.postMessage? Are there significant differences between these two options that might influence my decision?

Answer №1

A port acts as a versatile, two-way connection.

Individual messages follow a consistent pattern and do not rely on the state between interactions:

sendData -> onReceive (optional ->) respondToRequest -> callback of sendData

You can achieve a wide range of tasks using this approach.

There are several unique characteristics of ports that I find intriguing.

  1. sendData functions like a broadcast operation.

    When utilizing runtime.sendMessage, the message is distributed to all active pages within the extension. While typically only one page (the background page) will respond, every page receives the message. This feature allows for resource optimization or the isolation of specific instances of a page.

    If you use tabs.sendMessage, the message is automatically sent to all frames within the tab. If necessary, you can specify a frameId to target a specific frame. However, when broadcasting to all frames without specifying, you can establish a port to maintain communication with the correct frame.

  2. An open port keeps an Event Page active. This can be beneficial in scenarios where asynchronous tasks could potentially unload the Event Page. On the other hand, if maintaining the Event Page's activity is unnecessary, it may hinder performance improvements provided by...

  3. A port serves as a "death alarm": if the counterpart context ceases to exist (e.g., the page containing the context script unloads), the onDisconnect event will notify you.

Unless any of these features are required, a straightforward sendData-onReceive communication setup suffices.

In your scenario, initiating the connection from the content script would involve two calls to sendData, with responses from the background script in respondToRequest. It is essential to consider the... intricacies of async responses.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

issue with unknown values in Vuejs array of objects

Struggling to create an array of objects, but encountering an issue where the first 83 objects are returning as undefined while only the last 4 have the correct data. Despite multiple attempts to refactor the code, a solution remains elusive. Here is the ...

Converting Repository Objects to Json in Symfony3

element, I am facing an issue while attempting to send a repository object as JSON. In my controller code, I have implemented a conditional check to ensure that the request is made via XmlHttpRequest. Upon receiving the data and fetching the corresponding ...

Tips for expanding button width in 'react-native-swipeout' to enable swipe action on ListView row (React Native)

Currently, I am exploring how to implement the component found here: https://github.com/dancormier/react-native-swipeout My goal is to have the row swiped all the way. Is there a method to increase the button width so that it covers the entire width of th ...

Adjust the scroll speed of the mouse

Is there a way to make my ReactJS application scroll to screen height with each mouse scroll? And if not, how can I manually set the scroll step for the mouse? Alternatively, I'm looking for a solution to detect the user's mouse step regardless o ...

Ensure that Ajax is updated when the document is ready

Upon document loading, the page initiates an ajax call to display a table of results. Updating rows can be done by clicking on a button, which triggers a function to post the update to the server. I had this functioning properly without wrapping the clic ...

Changing the user object stored in the database within the next authentication process following registration

In my next.js application, I have implemented Next Auth for authentication and used a database strategy. Once a user logs in, is there a way to update their data? ...

Experiencing issues with autoungrabify or autolock in cytoscape.js?

I have been working on a web application using Cytoscape.js, and I recently integrated the Edgehandles extension to allow users to add edges. The two types of edges that can be added are undirected and directed. Adding directed edges is functioning as expe ...

"Exploring the possibilities of Sketchfab through an AJAX JSON

Currently, I am on a quest to gather the URL for the thumbnail of a Sketchfab model. To access this information, you can visit: Upon visiting the above URL, all the necessary details are visible to me. My next step involves making an AJAX call to dynami ...

Utilizing Node.js and express to promptly address client requests while proceeding with tasks in the nextTick

I am looking to optimize server performance by separating high CPU consuming tasks from the user experience: ./main.js: var express = require('express'); var Test = require('./resources/test'); var http = require('http'); va ...

Issue with email validation not functioning properly post HTML page rendering

My attempt at validating emails after the user enters them doesn't seem to be working properly. I have placed the JavaScript code at the top of the file to run during rendering, but it still does not indicate whether the email is valid or not. Below i ...

What is the best way to retrieve past data using RTK Query?

When working with data retrieval using a hook, my approach is as follows: const { data, isLoading } = useGetSomeDataQuery() The retrieved data is an array of items that each have their own unique id. To ensure the most up-to-date information, I implement ...

What are the recommended best practices for effectively implementing DropZone.js?

I am currently tackling the challenge of properly integrating DropZone.js with PHP in my project setup. In my scenario, I have a primary form with multiple fields and a separate dropzone form on the side. Whenever a file is uploaded, upload.php is triggere ...

Enhancing user experience with dynamically resized Jumbotron images based on screen sizes in HTML

I am experiencing an issue with the jumbotron images on my website where they become increasingly zoomed in as the screen size decreases, and are extremely zoomed in on mobile devices. Is this a normal behavior of jumbotrons? I do understand that the image ...

Spin the content of a div after a button click with the power of jquery and css

Looking to add interactivity to rotate text within a div upon button click using jQuery and CSS. If the user selects Rotate Left, the text will rotate to the left. Alternatively, if the user chooses Rotate Right, the text will rotate to the right. Here&a ...

Identifying repeated numbers within an array using objects

What is the most effective way to replicate array integers according to their key values retrieved from an API? Input: {1208: "1", 1209: "2"} Output: [1208, 1209, 1209] I attempted using Object.keys but it only fetched the parent key ...

Cannot remove selection of an image in Firefox after dropping it into a contenteditable area

When manipulating images in Firefox within a contenteditable area using drag-and-drop, you may encounter a selection issue where the images get selected unintentionally. This problem occurs randomly and can be frustrating to deal with. For reference, you ...

Trying out the Angular resolve feature

I am utilizing Angular with ui-router, so the toResolve variable will be resolved in my SomeController. .state('some.state', { url: '/some', controller: 'SomeController', templateUrl: '/static/views/som ...

Unable to successfully display AJAX data on success

After successfully running my GradeCalc function in a MVC C# context with the grade parameter, I am facing an issue where the data is not displaying and the JavaScript alert pop up shows up blank. Can you assist me with this problem? $("#test").o ...

Issue: `TypeError: store middleware is not a valid function`

In my React-Redux code, I have successfully combined the store and reducer in previous apps, possibly due to different versions of React and React-Redux. However, when setting up a new React project with the latest versions, I encountered an error: T ...

Managing the Navigation Bar

I am currently using Bootstrap and ReactJS, and I am facing an issue where the active tab on the navigation bar does not change when I scroll down the page. At the moment, the active tab only changes when I click on a specific section. Each section corresp ...