Confidential data in Module Design

I'm curious about the concept of private variables in JavaScript. How is it that I can still access a private variable through a public method and redefine the properties of the module? For example:

var aModule = (function() {

    var privateVar = 1;

    return {
        publicFunction: function() {
            return privateVar;
        }
    }

})();

aModule.publicFunction = function() {
    privateVar = function() {
        console.log('a new content');
    }
    privateVar();
};

aModule.publicFunction(); // 'a new content'

I understand that this would not be possible if written in ES6 with let or const, but why does it work in ES5?

Answer №1

A private variable is inaccessible and cannot be altered by code outside of the module or class that owns it.

For instance, attempting to retrieve aModule.privateVar will not yield any results.

Your publicFunction acts as a "getter" in Java (and similar languages), providing read-only access to the private variable's value.

In the given scenario, you are not actually modifying the private variable; rather, you are creating a new variable within the scope of publicFunction and assigning a value to it. Despite sharing the same name (privateVar), they occupy separate memory spaces.

I have made modifications to your code for clarity:

var aModule = (function() {

        var privateVar = 1;

        return {
            publicFunction: function() {
                return privateVar;
            },
            getPrivateVar() {
                return privateVar;
            }
        }

    })();

    aModule.publicFunction = function() {
        privateVar = function() {
            console.log('new content');
        }
        privateVar();
     };

     aModule.publicFunction(); // 'new content'
     console.log(aModule.getPrivateVar()); //outputs 1

To delve deeper into why this occurs, it all boils down to scope. privateVar exists within the scope of an anonymous function. This function returns an object with multiple functions defined within it. Upon invocation, this object is assigned to aModule but retains access to privateVar due to shared scope.

However, beyond that function's scope, we reside in a different realm lacking access to aModule's variables, save for those exposed through the returned object.

Answer №2

Trying to modify the public function without access to the module's private variable creates a challenge

An alternative approach is introducing a new function within aModule that attempts to update only the value of var privateVar

The issue lies in the scope difference when this function is called, preventing it from reaching the private variable

var aModule = (function() {

    var privateVar = 1;

    return {
        publicFunction: function() {
            return privateVar;
        }
    }

})();

aModule.newFunction = function() {
    // attempting to alter privateVar within aModule 
    privateVar = 3
};

aModule.newFunction();

console.log(aModule.publicFunction()); //value remains at 1 instead of changing to 3
// revealing where the variable is actually set
console.log(window.privateVar)

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Send input data to a script seamlessly without triggering a page reload

I'm facing an issue with sending form values to a script. My goal is to have the form values displayed on another part of the page when the user clicks a button. While I can achieve this using PHP or similar web scripting languages by sending the valu ...

Having trouble with the CKEditor character count function in JavaScript?

I integrated the Javascript and stylesheet from this source into my webpage. http://jsfiddle.net/VagrantRadio/2Jzpr/ However, the character countdown is not appearing on my site. What mistake have I made? ...

Switch from using fetch to utilizing axios for making API requests

I used fetch for a 'get' request, but now I want to switch to axios. Can someone please help me convert this code to use axios instead? More details: I am fetching an image and using the blob method to display it to the user. I would like to ach ...

What are some strategies for preventing unused setState functions in React? Is it possible to create a React useState without a setter function

Currently working on reducing or eliminating npm warnings related to the React site. Many of these warnings are due to the setState function, which is marked as 'unused' in the code snippet below. const [state, setState] = useState('some st ...

Tool to track character limits in multiple text fields

I'm facing a challenge with a form that includes 3 text areas, a copy button, and a reset button. My goal is to concatenate all the characters in the text areas to get a sum which will be displayed next to the copy/reset button. The character limit is ...

Is the concept of Controlled and Uncontrolled Components in VueJs similar to that of React?

When it comes to React, there is a distinction between controlled and uncontrolled components explained in detail at this link. Controlled components function within the React model where state is managed in the virtual DOM. In contrast, uncontrolled com ...

Issues encountered with AngularJS directive binding inner content not functioning as expected

I am currently developing a feature toggle directive, which requires a check to be performed in order to display content if the check is successful. I want the directive to replace itself with its content without creating a new child scope (so I'm try ...

Illumination causes surfaces to transform

In my simple scene, I have a ground and an interesting light source. However, when the light hits certain meshes, it creates some strange effects. The shadows are being cast correctly, but the other meshes affected by the light are showing unusual results. ...

Differences in behavior of multiple select with track by in Angular versions above 1.4.x

I recently upgraded my product from Angular 1.2.x to 1.4.x. Since updating to angularjs 1.4.x, I've encountered an issue: What I have: I included code snippets for both angular 1.2.0 and 1.4.8. You can check out the comparison on JSFIDDLE. Explanat ...

What is the Best Way to Ask Users Not to Delete Local Storage Information?

As I work on developing an application using angularJS, the need to save data locally has arisen. To achieve this, I am utilizing HTML5 local storage. One challenge faced with HTML5 local storage is that when a user clears their browsing data, all stored ...

Tips for adjusting the duration of a background in jQuery

jQuery(document).ready(function(){ jQuery('div').css('background-color','#ffffff').delay(12000).css('background-color','#000000'); }); Hello everyone! I'm having some trouble with this code. I am ...

Refresh the DATATABLE inside an AJAX call without reloading the entire page

I'm currently working with a table that utilizes the Datatable plugin. I have successfully implemented filtering and deletion functionality within the table. However, after deleting certain entries, I noticed an issue where the deleted item still app ...

Is there a way to initiate LiveServer or npm run dev/start over my local network?

Is it possible to access my project (npm run dev/liveServer) over my home internet network so that my iPad, phone, or iMac could also view the project live as it's being developed (all connected to the same wireless network) without the need to deploy ...

What steps should I take to activate JavaScript type checking in Vue files within Visual Studio Code?

After much exploration, I have successfully configured Visual Studio Code to perform type checking for JavaScript within JS files. This feature highlights any bad code and provides explanations for why it is considered as such here. However, this function ...

Is there a way to stop Bootstrap from automatically bolding the font?

When testing this simple example without the bootstrap link, everything seems to be working correctly: Hovering over any word changes its color to red, and when hovering away it returns to black. But as soon as the bootstrap link is included, the text bec ...

Converting a TypeScript class to a plain JavaScript object using class-transformer

I have a few instances of TypeScript classes in my Angular app that I need to save to Firebase. However, Firebase does not support custom classes, so I stumbled upon this library: https://github.com/typestack/class-transformer which seems to be a good fit ...

Encountered issue with Ajax post request without any additional details provided

I could really use some assistance with this issue. It's strange, as Chrome doesn't seem to have the same problem - only Firefox does. Whenever I submit the form, Ajax creates tasks without any issues. My MySQL queries are running smoothly and I& ...

Filtering Quantity Based on Specific Attribute in ReactJs

I want to implement a quantity filter that can be based on color, size, or both. For instance, when I select the red color, it should display the total quantity of red items available. However, if I choose both the color red and size small, it should show ...

Press on the menu <li> item to create additional submenus

A group of friends is facing a challenge. They want to create a dropdown sub-menu that appears directly below the selected item when clicking on a link from a menu. So far, they have been able to use ajax to send requests and generate a sub-menu. However, ...

What is the best way to filter out specific data fields from console.log in JavaScript?

When working with Java, I often use lombok to exclude certain fields from being printed. For instance, the @ToString.Exclude annotation can be used to prevent printing the user token. import lombok.ToString; public class TokenResponse { @ToString.Excl ...