code for forming services and controllers in Angular

Lately, I have been immersing myself in articles about Angular to pick up some best practices for an application I am currently developing. One topic that caught my attention is the concept of minifying JavaScript and its preferred syntax:

var myApp = angular.module('myApp',[]);

myApp.controller('Controller', ['$scope', function($scope) {
  //code
}]);

On the other hand, I've come across a few individuals advocating for a different syntax:

var myApp = angular.module('myApp', []);
function ControllerOne($scope) {
 //code
}
myApp.controller('ControllerOne', ControllerOne)

This raises my first question: In the second example, when registering the controller with a string as a parameter that points to a function named "ControllerOne", does it provide the same benefits in terms of minification as passing an array like in the first example?

Furthermore, my second question pertains to whether one approach is considered superior over the other or if it simply boils down to personal preference?

Reflecting on this scenario, I can see how the second method might offer more flexibility since the function is detached from the actual controller and could potentially be reused. On the contrary, in the first example, the code is tightly bound to that specific controller due to its declaration within the array. Am I interpreting this correctly?

Answer №1

  1. Assigning a controller name as a string won't affect minification, but passing dependencies will. It's important to pass them in a minification-safe manner. Utilizing the $inject service can help inject dependencies.

  2. For the best practices in writing Angular code, it's recommended to follow John Papa's Angular style guide.

https://github.com/johnpapa/angular-styleguide

Answer №2

If you haven't already, I highly recommend giving Google's closure library a try (https://developers.google.com/closure/). The @ngInject in the jsdoc is very effective at handling minification. Personally, I use closure regularly and find it to be extremely reliable. While there may be a steep learning curve at first, once you get the hang of it, you'll come to appreciate its capabilities.

Answer №3

The comparison between the second example and other methods is quite different. The absence of `$scope` injection and the use of "ControllerAs" syntax in the template sets it apart.

In my opinion, all the debate surrounding array injection syntax for controllers is unnecessary. When minifying code, utilize tools like ng-annotate to ensure clarity. It's important to prioritize making your code as clear as possible, as maintaining and fixing code is more costly than writing it, especially if automation can be implemented.

Answer №4

  1. When it comes to inline declaration (option one), its main purpose is to ensure correctness after minifying the code.

    It's important to remember that all injectables are stored and referenced within a specific area of the module.

    • On the other hand, option two involves minifying tools potentially renaming the function argument $scope to a shorter name like s, which may not be defined in the module.
    • If you opt for option one: Angular will identify the String $scope, locate its definition on the scope, then execute something along the lines of s = $scope, ultimately proceeding with the controller. This is known as injection.
  2. The recommendation is always to go with option one.

Consider utilizing option one, minimize the code, and observe the outcome.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Binding a value from a template model to the parent scope in AngularJS using directives

I have been attempting to develop an angular directive that mimics the functionality of this jquery jsfiddle. http://jsfiddle.net/RCaCM/7/ The main goal of the directive is for the controller scope to contain a width value, which will be displayed in the ...

Updating a document using the parent and subdocument ID with the findOneAndUpdate method

Seeking the correct subdocument for modification of a specific field. Several attempts have been made: Book.findOneAndUpdate( { _id: req.params.id, chapters: { $elemMatch: { _id: req.params.subid } } }, { $set: { chapters: { title: ' ...

The issue of Access-Control-Allow-Origin restriction arises specifically when using the gmap elevation API

My attempts to retrieve the elevation of a site using latitude and longitude have been unsuccessful due to an error I encountered while making an ajax call. Regardless of whether I use HTTP or HTTPS, I receive the following error message: "No 'Access ...

Can Nest.js providers be intercepted?

I'm attempting to intercept Nest.js providers using the methods outlined in the documentation, but it's not functioning as expected. Has anyone else experienced this issue? If so, is there a particular reason for this limitation? In general, I& ...

Tips for clearing the sessionstorage upon browser refresh without removing data when clicking the back button in the browser

I am looking to clear the session storage only when the page is refreshed, without affecting the browser's back button functionality. I want to achieve this using AngularJS/JavaScript. Currently, I am storing data in sessionStorage on a back button c ...

Step-by-step guide on creating a pressure gauge using canvas

Seeking assistance with creating an animated pressure gauge in Canvas for a new application. I need to animate the red needle to move from one angle to another when given a specific input. My original attempt to calculate the ratio between pressure and ang ...

The AJAX response shows a value of "undefined"

My HTML page contains these codes, which display a list of employees from the database. <!DOCTYPE html> <html> <head> <title></title> <meta charset="utf-8" /> <script src="Scripts/jquery-1.10.2.js"></script> ...

How can I import a JavaScript file embedded in another project using ASP.Net?

I am currently working on two projects - a control library and my main project. In the control library, I am using a user control and some embedded CSS files. To use these CSS files in my main project, I am adding them from the PreRender event of my user c ...

Troubleshooting a JavaScript bug involving a TYPO3 plugin and jQuery

Having some trouble with jQuery or javascript while using the "Easy route planner" extension in typo3. You can find the extension here: Initially, the jQuery of the extension wasn't functioning at all. It seemed to be a conflict with the $ variable. ...

AngularJS: dual occurrence of stateChangeStart without stateChangeSuccess

I encountered a challenge while developing a simple code for managing user roles. There are certain parts of my back-office that are restricted for guests but accessible to admins. The issue arises with the "stateChangeStart" function in the run code. Lo ...

I'm encountering an undefined JavaScript variable, how should I proceed?

$(function(){ //Location was "set". Perform actions. $("#geocodesubmit").click(function(){ var geocoder = new google.maps.Geocoder(); geocoder.geocode( { 'address': address}, function(results, status) { if (status ...

During the rendering process, the property "quote" was accessed, however, it is not defined on the current instance. (Vue.js)

Every time I try to retrieve data from the kanye API, I encounter this error message: Property "quote" was accessed during render but is not defined on instance. Below is the code snippet that triggered the error: <template> <div> ...

Creating an HTML form to collect user data and then automatically saving it to an Excel file stored in a shared Dropbox account

I am looking to extract data from a user form on a website and then automatically save it as an Excel file in a designated Dropbox account once the user clicks submit. Instead of receiving multiple emails every time the form is filled out, I would like t ...

Angular is not refreshing the DOM, but it is instead logging the data to the console

Can anyone explain why AngularJS is not updating the div, even though I can see the data in the console? What am I overlooking here? Here is a fiddle I created: function jsonp_example($scope, $http) { $scope.doRequest = function() { var url ...

Changing image/jpeg, image/png, and similar file types to multipart/form-data format in Node.js

I am working on an application that randomly selects an image and then uploads it to a blog site. The challenge I am facing is that the blog site requires the image to be in the multipart/form-data format. const FormData = require('form-data') ...

Bypass ajax request with the use of a returned promise

I've come across a scenario where I have a function within a class that is designed to return a promise for deleting an item. Here's what the function looks like: function Delete(){ // if(this.id == ""){ // return ?; // } ...

What is the best way to transfer data from app.post to app.get when navigating between multiple pages?

Within my app.js file, I am encountering a challenge as I aim to transfer the username inputted in a form on the login page over to the game page. Despite having successfully retrieved the data using req.body.username within app.post('/login'), I ...

Is it possible to access a comprehensive list of all the elements that are currently available?

Is there a way to retrieve all HTML tag names that are supported by the browser for my web application? I want it to be displayed like this: console.log(getAllElements()) //[a, abbr, acronym, address, applet, area, base, ...] ...

Mastering the Art of Modifying HTML with Node.js

Is it possible to manipulate HTML using Node.js? 1. First, I need to retrieve data from a database. 2. Then, I need to modify or add HTML code within Node. In essence, the goal is to fetch data and integrate it into an HTML file. The JavaScript snippet ...

How to implement a link_to tag in autocomplete feature with Rails

I'm having trouble adding a link to the show page in autocomplete results. Although my jQuery alert box is working fine, I can't seem to apply CSS to a div using jQuery. Here's the code snippet I've posted below: //application.js ...