Can a variable be initialized with a concealed or additional argument?

After just 2 weeks of coding, I'm struggling to find information on how to initialize a variable with an extra argument in a recursive function call. Is this even possible? And if it is, are there any scenarios where it's considered best practice?


This question arose while I was working on a less-than-elegant solution to CoderByte challenge number 10 (Alphabet Soup - a challenge that involves taking a string and returning a string with the same letters in alphabetical order). [Note: I understand that my approach may not be the best way to solve the problem. I'm including the code only for context.]

In essence, I'm wondering if there's a way to remove 'newStr' as an argument (given that JavaScript functions can take extra arguments) and still pass a recursively growing answer string. If I simply eliminate 'newStr' as an argument, the initialization is lost. However, if I initialize 'newString' within the function body (var newStr = ""), I encounter issues passing the sorted string recursively. Is there a valid use case for this approach, or does it simply signify that another method should be used?

Full Code:

function AlphabetSoup(str, newStr) { 
  var alphabet = "abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz";
  var testVal= 0;
  //ATTEMPTING TO PASS A GROWING ANSWER STRING RECURSIVELY
  if (newStr == null)
    var newStr = "";
  if (str.length == 0)
    return newStr;
  for (var i = 1; i < str.length; i++) {
    if (alphabet.indexOf(str[0]) <= alphabet.indexOf(str[i])) {
      testVal += 1;
    }
  }
  // When the first letter, str[0], is earlier in the alphabet than every other letter
  if (testVal == (str.length - 1)) {
    //add the first letter to the newStr
    newStr = newStr + str[0];
    //remove the first letter from the input string
    str = str.substr(1);
    //recursively call AlphabetSoup to continue building newStr
    return AlphabetSoup(str, newStr);
  }
  //When the first letter isn't the earliest in the alphabet
  else {
    //move it to the end of str
    str = str.substr(1) + str[0];
    //until we find the next earliest letter in the alphabet
    return AlphabetSoup(str, newStr);
  }
}

console.log(AlphabetSoup("hooplah"));

Answer №1

Sure, you could theoretically inspect the length of the arguments object and assign your variable based on a specific index, like arguments[1], in relation to your comment about "JavaScript functions accepting additional arguments." However, this approach may seem somewhat unsophisticated. It's perfectly fine to include that argument as part of the function signature. If you prefer not to expose it externally, consider encapsulating your recursive logic within a wrapper function with just one parameter.

Answer №2

The concept of checking newStr at the beginning is a common practice in JavaScript. However, it's important to check for undefined rather than null:

if (typeof newStr == "undefined") {
    var newStr = "";
}

In ES6 (or Coffeescript), you can set default values for your function arguments:

function AlphabetSoup(str, newStr = '') {
    // ...
}

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Expanding and collapsing multiple tables in Material-UI

I'm currently working on creating a collapsible table using MaterialUI. At the moment, all my slides have collapses but they are connected to one state for "open", so when I open one slide, all the other slides also open. Here is an example sandbox t ...

Unexpected errors causing havoc in my internet browser

I am facing difficulties uploading large files (~ 2 GB) on my server. To prevent crashes caused by huge files, I have removed the bodyParser from Express. However, the crash error occurs randomly, making it challenging to pinpoint the exact cause. The cod ...

The result from the AngularJs promise is coming back as undefined

I am facing an issue while trying to implement the login function of my AuthService factory in conjunction with my AuthLoginController controller. The problem arises when the User.login function is triggered with incorrect email and password details, causi ...

retrieve the class name of a reusable component in HTML

I have been assigned a web scraping project and I am required to scrape data from the following website for testing: The HTML: <div class="quote" itemscope itemtype="http://schema.org/CreativeWork"> <span class="text& ...

What is the best way to trigger a controller action using jQuery in your application.js file?

Currently, I am incorporating the jQuery autocomplete plugin into my project and looking to personalize a specific event: select: function(event, ui) { $('.topic_field').val(ui.item.topic.name); return false; This event es ...

Incorporating a .json file into res.render to pass data

Is there a way to pass an object array similar to the one below into res.render? var DataArray = [ {"type": "c#", "script":"csharp script"}, {"type": "javascript", "script":"javascr ...

Clearing FullCalendar events when the month button is pressed: A step-by-step guide

What is the best way to hide ONLY events on a calendar? I was considering deleting all events when the user clicks the "month" button. How can I achieve this functionality? $scope.uiConfig = { calendar: { height: 450, editable: false, ...

What impact does changing the Device Language have on a heading?

At the top of an html page, I have the word "Color" in a heading. If a user's device is set to British English, I would like the text to automatically switch to "Colour". What is the best way to accomplish this with minimal Javascript? ...

Setting the parent's height to match one of its children

I'm struggling to align the height of the pink '#images-wrap' with the main image. When there are too many small rollover images on the right, it causes the pink div to extend beyond the main image's height. If I could make them match i ...

Ways to retrieve a grandchild element of a specific element using its tag name

I'm struggling to access elements that are nested within various levels of parent elements with and without IDs. The usual method getElementByTagName doesn't seem to be working for me, especially when the target element is three levels deep. Is t ...

Incorporating a Link into a Radio Button component in Material-UI using react-router

Greetings! I have two radio buttons and would like to include a link. I attempted to achieve this in the following manner: <RadioButton value="/searchByArtistAndName" label="Artist and Name" style={styles.radioButton} contai ...

How can I ensure the Jquery datepicker functions correctly?

I've been attempting to create a jsp page with some Jquery functionalities. Unfortunately, despite my best efforts, I am unable to make it work. I have downloaded jquery1.7.1 and jquery-ui1.8.17 (non-mini), renamed them to jquery171.js and jquery-ui. ...

unable to assign values to this.props (appears as undefined or an empty array)

Upon setting up react/redux, I encountered a peculiar issue. When my component mounts, it should render the information stored in this.props.heroes.data. However, upon logging this data, I receive an unexpected value of [{id:1,heroname:'Batman',r ...

Trouble arises when adding a .js script to the webpage

I'm feeling quite puzzled by this small piece of code, as it appears to be the simplest thing you'll come across today. Despite that, I can't help but seek guidance because I've been staring at it for what feels like an eternity and can ...

The issue with the <Button> component not properly linking in next.js

Having trouble with a button wrapped inside a custom Navbar component. The code snippet in question is: <NavBtn> <Link href="/contact" passHref> <Button> Contact Me </Button> </Link> & ...

Generate a fresh DOM element when a particular height threshold is achieved, utilizing a portion of the previous DOM element's content

Update: 27th December 2016 The heading has been modified because any DOM element can be the target, whether it is a <p> element or not. Additional information has been provided about the tools being used and the desired outcome. Are there nativ ...

jQuery toggle functioning in one scenario, but failing in another

My experience with JS/Jquery is limited which might explain why I'm struggling with this. I am attempting to hide some text on a page and then make it visible again by clicking on a toggle link. The JavaScript code below is what I have been using. The ...

Is it possible to execute TypeScript class methods in asynchronous mode without causing the main thread to be blocked?

Creating an app that retrieves attachments from specific messages in my Outlook mail and stores the data in MongoDB. The challenge lies in the time-consuming process of receiving these attachments. To address this, I aim to execute the task in a separate t ...

The process of including or excluding an item in an array

There are 2 toggle buttons. If the value is true, it will be added to the array, otherwise the element will be removed. data: originality: [] toggles: <toggle id='1' ref='toggleOriginal'> Click </toggle> <toggle id=&apo ...

Utilize the function specified in an external file

In my project, I have a typescript file named "menuTree.ts" which compiles to the following JavaScript code: define(["require", "exports"], function (require, exports) { "use strict"; Object.defineProperty(exports, "__esModule", { value: true }); var Menu ...