Are there any discussions underway about updating JSON standards to officially permit unquoted property names?

Technically speaking, the following JSON is considered invalid:

{
  color: "blue",
  size: 14
}

This is because according to the specification, property names like "color" and "size" should be enclosed in quotes, like this:

{
  "color": "blue",
  "size": 14
}

Despite this requirement, it's common to find web services claiming to return JSON without quoted property names. In addition, JavaScript developers often do not quote their property names since it's not mandatory in JavaScript.

Is there any discussion or proposal to modify or create a new version of JSON that allows for unquoted property names? It would seem like a more intuitive way to work with the format, but as of now, no official adoption of this idea has been suggested.

javascriptjsonstandards

Answer №1

The guiding principle behind JSON's design seems to be simplicity above all else.

The instruction to "Wrap property names with double quotes" triumphs over the more complex alternative of "Wrap property names with double or single quotes, and you can omit the quotes unless the name contains spaces or special characters."

I believe this core principle is here to stay.

I'll pause now before diving into a discussion about the philosophy of HTML5 design.

Answer №2

Dealing with property names that clash with reserved JavaScript words has proven to be a challenge for me. After encountering multiple issues, I've decided to heavily quote my JSON whenever possible. Personally, I find this approach to be much more secure.

Answer №3

I highly doubt this scenario will unfold. If you encounter a web service claiming to provide JSON data incorrectly, it's best to reach out to them for clarification. It's not ideal to change a specification just because some individuals are implementing it improperly.

Let's clarify our terminology here. While JSON contains "JavaScript" in its name, it's important to distinguish that JSON is not equivalent to JavaScript.

Before anyone points out the information on the json.org site stating that JSON is a subset of JavaScript, I am aware of that fact.

From a technical perspective, yes, JSON is related to JavaScript. However, considering its purely declarative nature and its usability beyond JavaScript applications, it's more beneficial to view JSON as a distinct data format with ties to JavaScript rather than treating it as JavaScript itself.

This explains why the statement "JavaScript doesn't mandate it" holds true. While JavaScript may not require JSON, JSON certainly relies on certain rules. Hence, I prefer to think of JSON as "connected to JavaScript, but not synonymous with it".

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

display and conceal a division by clicking a hyperlink

How can I make a hidden div become visible when clicking on a specific link without using jQuery? Javascript function show() { var a = document.getElementsByTagName("a"); if (a.id == "link1") { document.getElementByID("content1").style.v ...

javascripthtmlshow-hide

Can you explain the distinction between Vue's 'v-on' directive and vue.$on method?

If I have two sibling components set up like this: <div id="root2"> <some-component>First</some-component> <some-component>Second</some-component> </div> ... and these components are coded as follows: Vue.comp ...

javascriptvue.jsvuejs2

Effortlessly sending multiple values from text fields using jQuery

i am using jQuery to fetch all values from text fields with the same field name. $('input[name^="StudentName"]').each(function() { StudentName += $(this).val(); alert(StudentName); }); when I alert, all the values are displayed as one s ...

javascriptjquery

The Angular HTML component is failing to display the locally stored JSON data upon page initialization

import { Store,STORES } from '../models/store'; export class StoreLocatorComponent implements OnInit { public Stores: any = []; constructor() { } ngOnInit(): void { this.Stores = STORES ; this.Stores.forEach(element => { ...

jsonangularconstructorhtml-renderingngoninit

Is there a way to retrieve real-time information using momentjs in a Vue.js application without needing to refresh the

I have a unique table where I showcase details about a particular website. Among the displayed information is the timestamp indicating when the data was last updated. At the top of the table, my aim is to include an icon that will only appear if the dura ...

javascriptvue.jsvuejs2momentjscomputed-properties

Develop a novel function

I am working on a new Order page where users can select a category, then a service, and fill out the quantity field for their order. I have an idea to create a function using @if and @else statements. In this function, I want to display the quantity fiel ...

javascriptphphtmllaravel

Ways to categorize items using JQuery based on their hierarchical structure

I am looking to organize the following HTML content: <h2>State the Issue  </h2> <h3>Provide information about your objective</h3> <h3>Share any error messages received</h3> <h2>Outline Your Attempts  ...

javascripthtmljquery

Create a filter system using a MERN stack that incorporates regex, a search box,

In an effort to understand how the MERN stack operates as a cohesive unit, I have taken on a hands-on approach by following tutorials from bezcoder. These include guides on Node.js/Express/MongoDb (Github entire code) and Reactjs (Github entire code). Sam ...

javascriptnode.jsreactjsmongodbexpress

Using AngularJS to display multiple objects in the same ng-repeat loop

Is it possible to display two objects simultaneously in ng-repeat? <tr data-ng-repeat="target in targets |session in sessions |filter:query | orderBy:orderProp"> ...

javascriptangularjsangularjs-ng-repeat

Step-by-step guide on how to include the "content-based-recommender" package in a Reactjs project

I recently started learning React.js and I'm interested in using the "Content-Based Recommender" package from npm. However, after downloading it, I encountered an issue with importing it. The documentation suggests the following: const ContentBasedRec ...

javascriptnode.jsreactjs

The property cannot be set because it is undefined in nodejs

var list = [ { title : '', author : '', content : '', } ] router.get('/japan',function(req,res){ var sql = 'select * from japan'; conn.query(sql,function(err,rows,fields){ for(var i = 0 ; ...

javascriptmysqlnode.jsexpressejs

Vue application experiencing never-ending update cycle following array assignment

Here is the JavaScript code I am working with: const storage = new Vue({ el: '#full-table', delimiters: ['[[', ']]'], data: { events: [], counter: 0, }, methods: { eventCounter: fu ...

javascriptvue.js

Error message "Unknown web method DoesUserExist. Parameter name: methodName" occurs when trying to pass a JSON value to a Web Method

Greetings, here is the JavaScript code I am working with: <script type="text/javascript"> $(document).ready(function () { function validateEmail(email) { var emailReg = /^([\w-\.]+@([\w-]+\.)+[\w-]{2, ...

c#jqueryajaxjson

Issue with horizontal scrolling in ng-scrollbars occurs when scrolling from right to left

We are currently developing a single page application that supports two languages, one being right to left and the other left to right. For scrolling functionality, we have implemented ng-scrollbars, an Angularjs wrapper for the malihu-custom-scrollbar-pl ...

javascriptjqueryhtmlcssangularjs

UI-Router is malfunctioning, causing ui-sref to fail in generating the URL

I'm currently working on a project that involves Angular, Express, and UI-router for managing routes. While I've properly configured my $states and included the necessary Angular and UI-router libraries in my HTML file, I am facing an issue wher ...

javascriptangularjsnode.jsexpressangular-ui-router

Is there a way to display the overall count of items in ReCharts?

I'm curious about how to access the additional data items within the 'payload' field of recharts when using material-ui. Despite my efforts to find relevant sources, I have not come across any references pertaining to accessing other group n ...

javascriptreactjsreduxmaterial-ui

Determine the originating page in Next.js that leads to the current page

Imagine a scenario with three pages: A, B, and C. In this setup, it is possible to navigate from page A to C, as well as from page B to C. However, the displayed content on page C will vary depending on the origin page of the navigation. I am curious to ...

javascriptreactjsnext.jsnext-router

Mongoose: An unexpected error has occurred

Recently, I developed an express app with a nested app called users using Typescript. The structure of my app.js file is as follows: ///<reference path='d.ts/DefinitelyTyped/node/node.d.ts' /> ///<reference path='d.ts/DefinitelyTyp ...

javascriptmongodbexpressmongoosetypescript

Ways to Halt observable.timer in Angular 2

As I work on Angular2's Component, I am currently implementing the following functions: export class MypageEditComponent { ngOnInit() { this.timer = Observable.timer(100, 100); this.timer.subscribe(t => { this.setFormData(); } ...

javascriptangulartypescriptrxjsrxjs5

I have the capability to capture HTTPS requests with Jmeter, however encountering difficulties when trying to input the data

When using Jmeter's proxy settings to record HTTPS requests and enabling the "Use this Proxy for all protocols," I encounter an issue. After logging into the application and entering a value in the search field, upon clicking on search, the system ret ...

jsonjmeter